Amidst the standard affirmations of American freedom, and the patriotic service that sustains it, this Independence Day, the nation was confronted with a stark reality: The latest attempts to preserve and defend that freedom have resulted in pervasive disillusionment that is severely impacting military recruitment.

The lost war in Afghanistan — and the return of the Taliban to power and al Qaeda to safe haven there — has compounded the apparent uselessness of the war in Iraq and exhaustion from the two-decade duration of the conflicts. The Army fell 25% short of its new enlistments goal last year, and the other branches are struggling as well. The widely acknowledged but little-discussed problem is expected to worsen this year.

Sacrifice and complacency

While factors as varied as a relatively strong economy, the effects of the pandemic, the decline in physical fitness and the culture wars have all been cited to explain the sudden drop, it coincided exactly with the aftermath of the disastrous withdrawal from Kabul. Yet even that debacle was merely the culmination of the contradictory manner in which the wars had been waged since 9/​11, not only in terms of strategy but in their relation to the society in whose name they were fought.

Advertise with us

A November 2017 Foreign Affairs cover captured this contradiction perfectly: Beneath the words “America’s Forgotten Wars,” a split illustration depicted a man in casual summer wear on a lush lawn before a barbeque, while on the other side of a picket fence soldiers in full gear engaged an arid, devastated landscape. Both scenes feature smoke: from the barbeque and from burning buildings.

The 9/​11 attacks unleashed a torrent of patriotic emotion, amid which a narrow yet intensely committed segment of the citizenry stepped forward to shoulder the military burden of fighting Islamic extremism, accompanied by a chorus of verbal support from the rest of the population. Despite serious questions raised from the start about the ethics and viability of prosecuting major conflicts with an all-volunteer force and without meaningful engagement from most civilians, this commitment was sustained by familial solidarity for as long as the wars actually continued.

Yet their conclusion in failure, the resulting bitterness and the knowledge that most Americans have long since moved on to other concerns have released a cascade of doubt among the families of those who served: “What was it all for?” Among a critical mass of veterans, three attitudes have come to define their relationship with their own service: a loss of faith in the political leadership; an alienation from civilians; and advice to their younger family members and friends that they not enlist.

Broken traditions

Counting against the politicians is the inescapable reality that they could not come up with a strategy to win a war that was a direct response to the worst attack on America since Pearl Harbor; rejected a logical alternative — a containment regime directed against Pakistan, the Taliban’s chief sponsor — when it was presented; and did not attempt a course correction over the full length of 20 years of hard mountain fighting.

Advertise with us

On a more instinctive level, there is resentment that presidents Bush, Trump and Biden all evaded military service in Vietnam, while Obama did what most Selective Service-era youth have done: He selected not to serve. And at no point during the long wars did any of the commanders-in-chief make even a symbolic call to sacrifice from the great mass of the non-serving, such as asking people to forgo a single weekend’s entertainment and donate the savings to a charity that serves soldiers and their families.

These failings raise questions about basic empathy, and many veterans have extrapolated that doubt to the wider civilian population. The essential injustice of the America represented by the Foreign Affairs cover, with a complacent majority benefitting from the sufferings of a dutiful minority, was sublimated during the wars by soldiers who had missions to fulfill, comrades to back up and a fierce pride in their indispensable role in society. Yet the ignominious end of the conflicts, and the considerable burden of physical mutilation, mental health problems, substance abuse, and suicide that is the legacy of repeated deployments, have enhanced feelings of ingratitude and betrayal.

And the preoccupation of so many Americans with divisive partisan issues represents the opposite of the ethos of selfless national service for which they endured so much.

The harvest of these contradictions was detailed in a front page story in The Wall Street Journal right before the holiday. Some 80% of Army recruits have a family tradition of military service, but the article showed how parents and other elders who had once taken for granted that their children would follow them into uniform are now counseling against it. As one Afghan veteran put it, “I just don’t see how it’s sustainable if the machine keeps chewing up and spitting out our young people.”

Such visceral, existential doubts are not going to be overcome by a slick advertising campaign, as is being proposed. And Hollywood, long a reliable partner of the Pentagon in recruitment efforts, cannot be counted upon this time: All recent films about the Afghan war depict lone veterans going back to the country to rescue native allies left behind in an effort to reclaim lost honor.

Advertise with us

In it together

Meanwhile, command generally views the enlistment shortfall as a technical problem that can be solved by spreadsheets and PowerPoints, when in reality it is a spiritual crisis whose stakes are national integrity, and ultimately national security.

If a fresh generation is to be asked to sign up for a new era of great power competition against Russia and China, the question of whether the previous challenge of Islamic extremism has been successfully met must be answered — and if it was not, why? Was the great surge of patriotism that followed 9/​11 fumbled by incompetent and self-interested leaders? If it was, why should recruits believe that the wars they will be asked to fight will be won, when the last two were not? And what reforms in government, the military and society as a whole are needed to achieve decisively better results?

The faith in national institutions that is clearly waning, and of which the recruitment crisis is the most serious example, can only be restored by an open debate about these questions. And it must be deepened by a more fundamental discussion of the meaning of citizenship, and whether widely shared security and prosperity must be accompanied by widely shared sacrifice.

Ultimately the nation must realize that the provision for the common defense which the Preamble to the Constitution regards as an existential necessity must, as it was during America’s greatest crises, be provided for in common.

Vanni Cappelli, a freelance journalist, is the president of the Afghanistan Foreign Press Association.