The death of Tyre Nichols at the hands of police officers in Memphis brings us to a tragically familiar place. We feel pain, anger and deep frustration. Many questions surface, and not for the first time.

Is the problem in the Memphis police department five “bad apples,” now fired and charged with homicide? Or does this terrible event point to something worse? How could this happen to another Black man at the hands of five Black officers, in a department with a Black chief of police? What went wrong with the Scorpion unit, the same unit touted by the Mayor and the Chief for suppressing violent crime? And, most agonizingly, why does this keep happening? Is there anything we can do to end this recurring nightmare?

The answers are out there. What we have lacked is leadership with the political will to make the changes necessary.

A diseased culture

Advertise with us

Every neighborhood, and every neighbor, wants policing that is effective, but also respectful, lawful and determined to avoid harm and violence. That is the minimum standard.

The problem in Memphis, and in other police departments, is not a few bad officers. It is the culture in which officers operate — in Memphis itself, and in policing more generally.

In the horrific videos of the beating that killed Tyre Nichols, viewers could see the result of a culture that accepted and encouraged violence. Officers pulled Mr. Nichols from his car, screamed contradictory orders at him, and used force of many kinds on his body — all without any sign of resistance or the presence of a weapon. When the terrified man ran and was caught, the infliction of pain without reason resumed.

At no point did any officer intervene with others, to say “enough” or “you’ve gone too far.” And all of it took place with officers aware that their own cameras recorded their actions — the surest sign that they expected not discipline or punishment, but praise. And why not? After all, despite mounting complaints from citizens in Memphis about hyper-aggressive tactics, both the Mayor and the Chief had held them up as exemplars of successful police work.

As Mr. Nichols’s medical distress mounted, officers ignored him, instead practicing the stories they’d put in their reports to justify their actions. Two officers exchanged a congratulatory fist bump, and one officer sent cellphone photos of the battered and helpless Mr. Nichols to friends. Following their vicious behavior with those actions tells you everything you need to know about the department’s culture.

Advertise with us

How could this happen to a Black man at the hands of Black police officers in a majority Black department, led by a Black chief?

The answer, again, is culture. Every person within the organization who wishes to succeed will adopt the prevailing culture. If the culture of the organization does not value the lives of Black citizens, and if it uses violence more readily against Black people — a fact proven by the Memphis department’s own statistics — members of the organization will conduct themselves the same way, regardless of their own race.

To be sure, diversity in a police department matters. It matters for people to see officers who look like them. And the research of Prof. Jonathan Mummolo of Princeton University and his colleagues tells us that compared to white officers, “Black and Hispanic officers…use force less often, especially against Black civilians” and focus less on “enforcing low-level offenses, with greatest impact on Black civilians.”

But the overall culture of a department matters more than anything else. As a Black police detective I interviewed more than twenty years ago told me, police officers aren’t Black or white or brown. “They all belong to the same race — the blue race.”

Tough on crime?

Advertise with us

Culture problems are particularly acute within specialized crime-suppression units. These special units typically have more autonomy and less supervision than regular patrols. Considered prized assignments, they are often staffed by more aggressive officers whose records include more arrests and more stops (traffic and pedestrian) than others’. They often use unmarked vehicles and work in plain clothes. Leadership tells them, sometimes subtly, and sometimes not: be aggressive. As Memphis’s chief said herself, she formed Scorpion to be “tough on tough people.”

We know something else about these units: their aggressive style of policing sometimes results in disaster. In 1999, it was an NYPD Anti-Crime Unit that killed Amadou Diallo in the vestibule of his building, with 41 shots. In 2006, Atlanta’s Red Dog Unit killed an elderly woman in a botched raid, and was finally shut down in 2011. In 2010, three Pittsburgh Police officers in a “99 Car” confronted Jordan Miles steps from his mother’s home in Homewood, and when the 18 year old CAPA honors student ran, the beating left him bruised and bloodied. (Mr. Miles survived.) Members of the CRASH team in Los Angeles and the Gun Trace Task Force in Baltimore engaged in incidents of brutality too numerous to catalog, and some went to prison for serious crimes on the job.

There is little evidence that any of these units in these or other cities made significant contributions to decreasing violent crime. When city and police leadership call for and applaud aggressive tactics, we may feel appalled by the consequences — but we cannot feel surprised.

Changing organizational culture is never easy. In police organizations, with cultures that are usually insular, distrustful of anyone from outside, and deeply resistance to change, it is harder still. But it is not impossible. Here are six changes any police department can make that improve morale, enhance community relations and reduce unnecessary violence.

Healing police culture

Advertise with us

From warriors to guardians. Too much of law enforcement has become enamored with the warrior culture. This set of ideas, infused through training (both in the academy and from private instructors) assumes that domestic law enforcement has the characteristics of a war. Officers should be ready to use “righteous violence” (quoting one of the most visible teachers of the warrior outlook, Lt. Col. Dave Grossman) to protect the “sheep” from the vicious “wolves.” As in war, the warriors accept a certain amount of collateral damage as inevitable.

The warrior ethic must go. It is incompatible with any concept of assuring civilian public safety for all citizens. And it must be replaced by a guardian outlook, in which officers conceive of themselves as guardians of the safety of all of us, with use of force as a last and rare resort. The training academy for the Washington State Police has adopted this path wholeheartedly, and it has changed the culture of that department.

Sentinel event reviews. Every department must require command staff to confront incidents of serious misconduct in an open and frank way, to ask what went wrong and how to prevent it from happening again. Incidents within the department would always get this treatment, as would high profile incidents elsewhere, such as the Tyre Nichols killing.

This would not displace appropriate disciplinary processes where there has been misconduct. But the focus would be different: not about assigning personal blame, but figuring out how the system failed. This kind of process, called sentinel event review, has proven fundamental to improving safety in fields like aviation and medicine. With sentinel event review, practices are improved, flaws in systems are identified, and policy and training follow. All of this can lead to culture change.

Duty to intervene. Bystander intervention must become a norm in policing just as it has in other areas. For example, students at the University of Pittsburgh receive training on how to intervene with others when they recognize sexual misconduct or hazing among their peers.

Advertise with us

The New Orleans Police Department is a case in point. The department had resisted reform for decades, even after a Department of Justice intervention. When the DOJ had to return a second time, they created the Ethical Policing Is Courageous (EPIC) program, in which officers were taught to intervene with each other when they observed a situation escalating toward violence or other misconduct. EPIC had a transformative effect on the culture of the agency.

The University of Pittsburgh Police Department is the only agency in the region to have received similar training in an updated program called Active Bystandership for Law Enforcement (ABLE), and Pitt officers regularly praise the training as a real benefit to them and those they serve.

Real and transparent accountability. To members of the public, it often seems that police officers who violate law or policy on the job have little to fear. That’s because, in most places, the disciplinary process is completely hidden from public view under state law and collective bargaining agreements.

No sensible person believes that police are always wrong. But when the facts are hidden, reason is replaced by speculation and distrust. In many meetings in communities here in Pittsburgh, members of the public will say, “everyone knows the Fraternal Order of Police runs the police department.” It doesn’t. But without transparency, we don’t know what happens within the department.

Further, state-mandated arbitration can restore police officers fired from their jobs for serious misconduct, often due to technicalities in law and labor contracts. Besides eroding trust with the public, this communicates to the rest of the force that misconduct doesn’t matter. The officers who do their jobs well, and who should be driving the department’s culture, become demoralized.

Advertise with us

State and local laws and labor contracts that hide misconduct and disciplinary matters must be stripped out and rolled back. California and New York have changed their laws to make at least some police disciplinary records, previously hidden from the public, available to all. An Illinois court decision recently achieved the same result. Every state must follow these examples.

Elevating de-escalation and communication. Today, in the almost three years after the murder of George Floyd in Minneapolis, most police departments will say that they want officers to de-escalate situations whenever possible. They will say that they want officers who can communicate well, and who avoid using force when possible. Some departments have gone further, putting these values into agency policy, and training officers to match.

But even policy and training on these issues cannot do the job of changing the culture. Every use of force, at any level, must be subject to supervisory review. That review should include asking, every time: could the officer have tried de-escalation? (Clearly, not every situation will allow for it.) If yes, how effective was it? Could use of force have been avoided? If so, how?

Officers should be evaluated based on how many confrontation are avoided, how effectively they communicate, and how they do their difficult jobs with their heads, not their muscles. (It turns out that most female officers are better at most of these things: Hire more of them, and make policing into an environment that welcomes them.)

Limiting specialized units. Abolish these units, or put them on an extremely tight leash, tied in with the communities they serve. Specialized units like Scorpion in Memphis have such a checkered and violent history that they should be the exception to the rule. And where in use, they must work with the communities they serve, and not just be unleashed on them.

Advertise with us

In Denver, for example, police “impact teams” work under close consultation with community groups and with regular patrol officers. In Portland, Ore., the “Focused Intervention Team” was developed with community oversight, and the community continues to have a say on how the team operates.

These six proposals for shifting police culture are starting points. All communities police serve must be involved in designing and implementing these changes, at every step. One thing is certain: Shame on us and our leaders if we fail to do much more than we have. Because so far, we have not done enough. The cycle of tragedy, unbearable for families and communities, continues. Even if we cannot fully solve these problems, we are not free of the obligation to keep trying.

David A. Harris is the Sally Ann Semenko Endowed Chair and Pro-fessor of Law at the University of Pittsburgh. His most recent book is “A City Divided: Race, Fear and the Law in Police Confrontations” (Anthem Press, 2020).