Sexuality and procreation have been central to philosophy, religion and politics for as long as human beings have lived in societies. Today, as the question of abortion has taken center stage once again, people on all sides of the issue have appealed to the ancient world — especially the early Christian church and its pagan and Jewish precursors — to justify their views. But the reality, as always, is more complicated than tweets and bumper stickers.
Society needs fertility
Many of the preoccupations of today’s politics were just not that interesting to the ancients. There was little discourse on whether life began at conception, or debates over how much time in the womb conferred legal rights and privileges. For them, one concept dominated their thinking and their experience: fertility. That included the fertility of crops, of herds and of people. Without fertility, society would not survive. Thus, most ancient gods were paired with goddesses and produced offspring. (The God of Israel was different; he created through speech.)
Because of this emphasis on fertility, the complementarity of men and women took on enormous significance. The structure and order of society was maintained by fulfilling the obligations of gender. In pagan societies, these roles were understood to have been handed down by the gods, and were therefore religious duties.
To maintain social order, then, women were generally considered the property of men — first of their fathers, and then their husbands. Marriage contracts detailed the responsibilities, and adultery was considered to be the violation of another man’s property. The prescribed punishment of death, in both pagan and Jewish law, was so strict because the only way to be sure of paternity — and the preservation of the husband’s bloodline — was absolute sexual fidelity.
Meanwhile, sexual intercourse with slaves was common in all cultures: Consider the story of Abraham and Hagar in the Book of Genesis. This was not considered adultery, since slaves were property. Prostitution was also widely tolerated, since prostitutes did not have a legal marriage contract to violate. There was a sense, however, that having sex with a prostitute ‘wasted’ precious seed.
Read More
The worth of the child
In part due to the focus on fertility, ancient cultures viewed miscarriages, and premature births that resulted in death, as the loss of a child, and they were grieved as such. There were also criminal penalties against anyone who caused a miscarriage.
Then as now, however, unwanted pregnancies were a social problem. Methods for dealing with unwanted pregnancy involved prophylactics, surgery, drugs, potions and magic formulas. We have medical recipes from Egypt for a paste applied to the vagina to thwart pregnancy. Just mixing up these formulas may have been a deterrent to sex: They included crocodile dung.
But the general attitude toward birth control and abortion was negative. It undercut fertility and interfered with the rights of the father who was being denied descendants. On the other hand, there was a tacit assumption that brothels and street prostitutes used various methods of abortion. This also contributed to their low social status, as they were seen to be acting against nature and the will of the gods (or God).
Legal personhood, however, was considered very different from moral or social worth. In Rome, when a child was born, it was laid at the feet of the father who could either pick it up and formally name it — or ignore it. Only once acknowledged and named by the father did the child have legal personhood — the eligibility to inherit family estates.
The widespread practice of infanticide in Rome is largely a myth. More commonly, unwanted children were left outside the house, where anyone could pick them up and adopt them. (While some may have had altruistic motives, this was also a cheap way to acquire slaves.) It is also a myth that daughters were abandoned more often than sons. From tombstone inscriptions we know that a daughter who died young was mourned as much as a son.
Changing views of sex
This doesn’t mean ancient cultures believed in equality, far from it. The pseudoscientific idea that was popularly believed was that men had hot blood, and women cold blood. The early philosophers equated this to the active principle (masculinity) and the passive principle (femininity).
This led to great restraints on women’s participation in society, but it also meant that ‘activeness’ of men could not be given free rein, or else the passions would overtake reason and society wouldn’t be able to function. The new philosophical schools of the day taught apatheia, which meant not being ruled by the emotions or the urges of the body. In some circles, then, sex came under suspicion because in orgasm the body is completely beyond the control of reason. The institution of marriage, however, was thought to channel those urges in a socially constructive way.
The Jewish scriptures generally took a strict view of sexual morality, which they thought was related to religious infidelity. The Prophets of Israel applied metaphors of marriage and adultery in their descriptions of spiritual faithfulness, such as, “Israel whored after the gods.” The Greek word for sexual immorality, pornea, is translated in English Bibles as “fornication,” which itself comes from the Latin forne, “arches,” which referred to where prostitutes stood along the streets. We don’t see the Greek word used in the New Testament until Paul’s letter to the Corinthians, which condemns “sexual immorality” outside of marriage.
The teachings of Jesus are hard to mine for insights on sexuality. While he rarely directly addressed the topic, he generally affirmed and strengthened existing Jewish teachings. In Matthew’s gospel, for instance, Jesus disapproves of divorce (“Therefore what God has joined together, let no one separate.”) and expands the prohibition on adultery to include even lustful thoughts (“But I tell you that anyone who looks at a woman lustfully has already committed adultery with her in his heart.”).
The early church to today
The combination of the influence of the new philosophical schools and Jewish teaching meant that the early Christian church existed in a period of great suspicion of sexual intercourse. This also interacted with the misogynistic view that the only way in which women could obtain power was by seducing men. Christians found support for this in the Garden of Eden narrative, where Eve was seduced by the serpent, then seduced Adam in turn.
What was supposed to be the purely rational act of procreation had now been infected with the sin of lust. To fight back against this ‘fall,’ Christians were admonished to perform intercourse only for the procreation of children. By the fifth century, Augustine of Hippo had as defined this concept as original sin, which was passed down from Adam and Eve through all the generations of humanity through sexual intercourse.
It was the Emperor Constantine, who converted to Christianity in 312 CE, who brought the early Church and the Roman state together. From him, ultimately, we get the idea that the state has the duty to protect the morals of the people. He made adultery and abortion a crime, and allegedly ordered the closure of all brothels — not very successfully.
While various Christian sects adopted different understandings throughout the centuries, culminating in the Protestant Reformation, it is this basic understanding of sex (shameful but necessary) and procreation (essential and sacred) that imbued European civilization. But it did not arise fully formed. Rather, it emerged from a complex mix of cultural, social and religious attitudes. We are still working out the tensions inherent in it to this day.
Rebecca I. Denova is an Emeritus Lecturer in the History of Christianity at the University of Pittsburgh.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.