After the landmark social media trials in California, which found Meta and YouTube guilty of creating addictive platforms and harming children, one has to wonder: has the Tech Titan Tower begun to tumble?
As an educator and parent, I fervently hope so, because the tech industry has turned a blind eye to the damage it is causing, including the damage to childhood. Families have been asked to manage technologies that have been intentionally designed to be unmanageable. It’s not a fair fight.
Parents undermined by technology
Tablets, smartphones, and school-issued devices have replaced free play, friction, true learning and in-person relationships. This complete metamorphosis has been remarkable, and overall not beneficial for children’s healthy development.
Parents work diligently to protect their kids’ health and learning, but feel undermined at the intrusion of technology into everyday life, the behavior it encourages and the expectations it creates.
We’ve been forced to accept several tech-industry created messages along the way. Messages like: every kid needs a smartphone to stay safe, schools need educational technology to make our kids smart, kids need social media to be social, and preschoolers need tablets to ensure a bright future.
These messages, circulated and supported by well-funded PR and marketing departments, placed digital tools on a pedestal — whose value is unquestioned. We are told to “meet kids where they are” and to encourage “responsible tech use” at home and school.
But research and experience do not support these messages. People are starting to see that “where the kids are” is often not a safe or supportive environment for healthy growth and development. Parents are starting to understand that apps designed purposely to encourage overuse (and to override our best intentions) make “responsible tech use” difficult, if not impossible.
The Tech Titans’ false childhood
Humans are analog creatures that evolved over millennia to function and learn in a three-dimensional, sensory-rich world full of nature, people and friction. We’ve been sold a false bill of goods.
Digital communication can never replace the richness of in-person relationships or the “serve-and-return” interactions that humans need in order to thrive. Our phones often provide a false sense of security, while at the same time serving children dangerous material.
Decades of research and lived experience show us what kids need to grow and thrive. Technologies will continue to change, but kids’ developmental needs will not. A real, healthy childhood looks a lot different from the Tech Titan supported version.
Parents want the first, and that requires communities that support and encourage more free play, more in-person interactions and social-emotional skills practice, and more real learning in the classroom. These activities build healthy skills and habits that will benefit benefit our children in the future — no matter what that future looks like.
We must establish essential collective values like safety, focused attention, strong social and emotional skills, and meaningful relationships with peers and adults. We must create the environments that allow our children to experience these values, and to build the skills and habits required to maintain them.
Safety at home and school requires protection from sextortion and harmful material. Focused attention requires the removal of distractions from the learning environment, and strong social-emotional skills require many and repeated opportunities to practice engaging with others and solving problems.
If we value these things, we must fight for better environments, policies, product design and business practices, as well as for more accountability from companies and institutions that fail to provide environments suitable for safety and healthy development.
Reclaim childhood
Parents are looking to redefine the rules in order to reclaim childhood for our children. Tech companies will not change overnight. Until they do (or are forced to), we need legislators, parents, school communities and health practitioners to stand together in support of future generations.
Everyone must work together to create the environments our children deserve: phone free schools, pro-learning classrooms that support only intentional technology use, and communities that encourage childhood independence and free play.
Katie Talarico-Ramirez is a co-lead of PA Unplugged and co-creator of Let's Grow Brain P.O.W.E.R.!. She lives in Upper Saint Clair.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.