WASHINGTON — As April 15 drew near, Republicans from President Donald Trump on down took turns praising the GOP tax law, their signature accomplishment.
“It is a great day because this filing season, three things are happening: lower taxes, bigger refunds, and more money in the pockets of hardworking Americans,” proclaimed House Speaker Mike Johnson, R-La. “We did that intentionally, and that’s exactly what’s happening.”
The day after the deadline for Americans to file their income tax returns, the House voted largely along party lines for a resolution that “recognizes the significant tax relief” in the Trump tax law.
“In Western Pennsylvania, when people say they work a ‘half day,’ it’s likely they mean 12 hours, not four,” said U.S. Rep. Mike Kelly, R-Butler, who introduced the resolution. ”The Working Families Tax Cuts reward hard work today while saving you money for tomorrow.”
The Working Families Tax Cuts used to be known as the One Big Beautiful Bill, but Republicans started using the new moniker after polls showed the measure was unpopular. In an October 2025 Quinnipiac University survey, 55% opposed the legislation and 35% supported it.
But the new name didn’t change the fact that 72% of the benefits went to the richest 20% of Americans, according to the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy, a progressive research group.
Read More
Tariffs erased tax cuts
But a recent ITEP study found that there wasn’t more money going into the pockets of anyone but the wealthy.
Trump’s tariffs and the Republicans’ refusal to extend health care subsidies canceled the benefits of any tax cuts for most Pennsylvanians except the rich. The study found only those making more than $334,600 a year were paying less, the study shows. And that’s even before the spike in gas prices as a result of Trump’s war with Iran.
“The tariffs ate up any tax cut for the vast majority of people in Pennsylvania or in the country,” said Michael Ettlinger, an ITEP senior fellow. “The bottom line is ‘whatever you got in tax cuts from the Republican tax bill, you lost in tariffs’ is the story for most people.”
Republicans have been hyping the tax law as the midterms near, hoping it will reverse their fortunes. Remember that opposition to Trump’s major legislative accomplishment during his first term — the 2017 Tax Cut and Jobs Act — helped cost the Republicans 41 House seats, including three in Pennsylvania.
Seven months before Election Day, the Cook Political Report put Democrats ahead in 217 congressional districts. If that holds, they would need just one of 16 tossup races to win a U.S. House majority.
The Democrats also have a path to win back the Senate, helped by a recent NBC News poll giving Trump a 37% job approval rating, the lowest of his second term.
Rising prices
As the price of goods, the price of gasoline and the premiums for health insurance all rise, those tax cuts may not be viewed so favorably after all, according to Christopher Borick, a political science professor at Muhlenberg College.
“You have to do a lot of selling if you’re Republicans right now to keep reminding people of those things when the other reminders hit them on a daily basis,” Borick said.
Yes, the tax bill delivered some benefits, such as no tax on tips and tax breaks for overtime pay and seniors, Borick said.
“They’re real and the Republicans and the president can absolutely take credit,” he said. “And if people see those results in their paycheck, there’ll be some degree of satisfaction.”
On the other hand, Borick said, “if you’re stopping a gas station and you’re paying a dollar more right now or you get your electricity bill or your monthly insurance premium if you’re buying on the market, that’s going to make many people put aside any warm feelings about their tax breaks that they may have received.”
Incomplete arguments
Ettlinger said some of the Republican arguments supporting the tax law don’t tell the whole story. Yes, he said, refunds may be up, but they may be up for reasons that have nothing to do with the legislation.
“Your refund just reflects the amount you overpaid,” he said. “There are lots of factors that affect the refund levels, not just changes in the tax law. So refunds are a really bad measure of how tax policy changes are affecting people.”
And citing an increase in the average tax refund means nothing. If you get $1 back and a millionaire gets $100,000, the average refund would be $50,000, but you won’t see any benefit.
“If you average a massive tax cut for a rich person versus pennies for a middle or low-income person, you get a big number as an average,” Ettlinger said. “But the actual amount that the middle or low-income person gets is relatively small.”
And the ITEP study didn’t take into account the law’s spending reductions that won’t go into effect until after November’s midterms. According to Congressional Budget Office estimates, the legislation will cost 11.8 million Americans their health coverage and 2 million their Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program benefits.
Jonathan D. Salant has covered Washington for almost four decades, including for the Post-Gazette. He is a former National Press Club president and a member of the Society of Professional Journalists D.C. chapter's Journalism Hall of Fame. His previous article was “Joe Manchin still insists there’s a path to a unity presidential ticket.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.