We recently had a little protest in Steubenville, and the way our community responded to it tells me a lot about who’s a grown-up and who isn’t. And about what the city’s older residents should be encouraging in their teenagers.
It all started when a history teacher, Scott Lane, was filmed criticizing President Donald Trump to his students. Obviously, a history teacher has to talk about current events to high schoolers. I can't imagine how he could do that without mentioning the horrific bombing of a girls’ elementary school in Iran
But he also called Trump a “liar” and a “pedophile” and started telling the students about the Epstein Files — topics that are important for adults to talk publicly about, but I don't think I’d have brought them up to a classroom full of teenagers. Lane resigned from his position at the high school after a video of his lecture went viral online, drawing quite a bit of both praise and harsh criticism.
The walk out
That Friday, about fifteen high school students staged a walk-out to protest their teacher’s resignation. They stood across the street from the school, cheering and waving homemade signs in support of Mr. Lane. The students were under an adult's supervision the whole time. They didn’t break the law in any way.
They spoke politely with local reporters who showed up to cover the event. A freshman named Kaden Cummings told the Intelligencer, Steubenville’s newspaper, that “Politics are a part of American history. If we’re allowed to hear about the Holocaust, we should be able to hear what’s going on with President Trump.”
When the protest hit the news, many people supported the students, but many who didn’t like the protest posted angry and even bullying comments. Some taunted that the teens were “brainwashed from pre k” by liberals. Somebody said, “we'll be seeing ¾ of the kids here next” with a screenshot of the sheriff's facebook page where the jail book-ins are reported.
Another called them “the short bus crowd,” insinuating that the children were intellectually disabled (and thus insulting every intellectually disabled student in Steubenville as well). I heard that some people were taunting that the teens ought to “go play in the bus lane” and get hurt or killed.
The pile-on
People piled on. They were reacting on a newspaper’s comments section and social media, of course, but they represent what I’ve heard others say around here. Even children aren’t safe from public contempt.
I doubt every single word of Mr. Lane's lecture was well advised. I don’t know whether he should have resigned. But I'm certain that I’m ashamed of the so-called adults reacting that way to students exercising their First Amendment rights.
These teens were not cutting class for the heck of it. They were not committing crimes. They weren't bullying people or getting pregnant or using drugs or doing anything to be ashamed of. They were angry at what they perceived to be an injustice and concerned that they weren't getting a good education and staged a peaceful protest.
I’m sure that if pro-Trump students walked out to protest Lane’s continuing the teach, the people who criticized the students supporting him would be cheering those who wanted him fired.
The commendable protest
Protest’s a commendable thing for high schoolers to do. Young people ought to look at the world around them and form opinions about it. Maybe you think they’re wrong — whether you’re for Lane or against him — but they’re teenagers. They’re learning. And they’re showing a faith in American democracy many adults have lost.
They ought to feel empowered, and encouraged, to do what they can to make the world a better place. Educators should facilitate that, because it's good for society when the youth want to be involved in public life, and what better place to start than the politics of the place they know?
I commend the teenagers for speaking out, and I hope they remain so passionate about right and wrong.
Mary Pezzulo, a contributing writer for the Post-Gazette’s Opinion page, is a writer in Steubenville, Ohio. her previous article was “What I would do if I were rich.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.