WASHINGTON — Joe Manchin says he still thinks there’s a way for a bipartisan ticket to win the White House — if the candidates can get on the November ballot.
Manchin, the former Democratic-turned-independent senator from West Virginia, panicked his former party in 2024 when he made noises about running with a Republican on a third-party slate for president. The anguish you heard were Democrats worried sick about Manchin pulling enough votes to give the election to Donald Trump.
The relief came when Manchin finally said no to the effort championed by No Labels. “The system right now is not set up” for a viable third-party candidacy, he said in February 2024. Trump won anyway.
Not the last word
Manchin may have forgone an actual campaign but not the idea of a unity ticket, though only if the rules were changed so the candidates could compete in all 50 states.
“I really thought the country was ready in 2024 to have a person who had been associated as a Democrat and a person associated as Republican running as a team showing that you can work together and you can bring people together,” Manchin said at the National Press Club last month. “We just couldn't get on the ballots. It was futile.”
During the first two years of Joe Biden’s administration, with the Senate divided 50-50 and only Vice President Kamala Harris’ tie-breaking votes giving the Democrats the trifecta of the White House, Senate and House, Manchin basically decided which bills would live and which ones would die.
Read More
While he supported Biden’s bipartisan infrastructure bill, for example, he opposed a separate measure to spend $1.75 trillion to fight climate change, increase health coverage and expand child care, killing it. He later agreed to a scaled down version known as the Inflation Reduction Act.
Supporting the filibuster
And along with then-U.S. Sen Kyrsten Sinema, D-Ariz., he blocked efforts by other Senate Democrats to weaken the filibuster requiring 60 votes to pass legislation. Senate Republican opposition stymied several Biden initiatives, including legislation making it easier to vote.
Now Senate Republicans are the ones looking at ways to kill the filibuster at President Donald Trump’s behest, so they can enact their own voting legislation, one that would impose new restrictions to prevent voter fraud and noncitizens from going to the polls. Studies show that fraud and noncitizen voting is virtually non-existent, but the new identification requirements in the bill could disenfranchise millions of legal U.S. voters.
“You get rid of the filibuster and you've lost the civility of what little bit you think is even there,” Manchin said. “You've lost everything. We're going to lose the country, because we'll be flip-flopping back like European countries do and have to have special elections just to move on, because nothing will last.”
That filibuster has allowed Democrats to demand changes in Immigration and Customs Enforcement operations in exchange for funding the Department of Homeland Security.
Manchin agreed with his fellow Democrats in expressing concerns about how ICE is operating under Trump. “He's overplaying his hand with basically paramilitary in the streets — camouflages, ICE agents. We've never done that. Never. That bothers me and worries me.”
He said Democrats needed to acknowledge that their policy on immigration, a key issue in Trump’s presidential campaigns, wasn’t a winning one.
“Can't you just say we made a mistake on the border? I've begged them not to do asylum at the border,’’ Manchin said. “Just made a mistake. We can use whatever excuse you want to.”
He said the Democratic message should be: “I want to work with the president to secure the border. But I really want the president to work with us to have a legal immigration policy.”
They were close to both in 2013 when a bipartisan group of eight senators came out with a bill that passed the Senate, 68-32. It likely would have passed the House too, but then-Speaker John Boehner, R-Ohio, refused to bring it up for a vote.
It combined tougher border security with a path to citizenship for millions of law-abiding immigrants here illegally who committed no crimes after they arrived.
A path not taken
“You would have an immigration policy today, I promise you that,” Manchin said. He would say to immigrants “You came the wrong way for the right reason. But you're here now, we're not going to throw 11 million people out then.” And now, he added, “it will be 20 million.”
But the No. 2 House Republican, Eric Cantor of Virginia, lost his primary to a right-wing challenger, and Boehner killed the bill.
“They accused Eric Cantor of being for amnesty, he’s allowing criminals to stay here,” Manchin said. “That's how they attack the bill. So we never got it done, and it’s still the best bill. If they pulled it off-the-shelf today, I think 90% of you would vote for it.”
Instead, Manchin said, there has never been an operation on the streets of America like the one ICE is carrying out now.
“What's happening with the paramilitary ICE right now, if you don't look just exactly the way they think you should look, my God, they're going after you,” he said. “You know, we’ve just never done that.”
Jonathan D. Salant has covered Washington for almost four decades, including for the Post-Gazette. He is a former National Press Club president and a member of the Society of Professional Journalists D.C. chapter's Journalism Hall of Fame. His previous article was “Pirates’ Horwitz embraces his heritage in World Baseball Classic.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.