After the bombing of Pearl Harbor, President Franklin D. Roosevelt asked Congress to declare a “a state of war” between the United States and Japan.
He made sure the nation’s commitment to go to war, the most serious and costly action a nation can take, came from the elected representatives of the people. The president did not choose on his own to go to war.
His and Congress’s actions stand in absolute contrast with Trump’s choice to go to war with Iran and Congress’s refusal of its responsibility under Article I of the Constitution to decide whether or not America makes such a commitment. We are in time of presidentially chosen wars, and chosen wars end badly for the American people, not to mention for the people of the nations we attack.
The cost of war
We do not know what will happen in Iran, especially as the president who chose to go to war seems to have no plan. We do know that Trump’s choice did not come from deep and careful thought. He can’t explain it even now.
We also know that both Iranians and Americans — and many others in the Middle East — will pay the price, as many already have. Those killed, of course, will be listed name by name. But what of those who survive? Those who serve and survive a war that never had reason to be waged?
This is the persistent question associated with the Vietnam and Iraqi wars. Lyndon Johnson ordered troops to Vietnam after it was reported that North Vietnamese torpedo boats attacked an American destroyer in the Gulf of Tonkin. The attack was disputed at the time, and Secretary Robert McNamara later admitted that it did not happen.
Likewise, the war against Iraq that was a part of the lesser Bush’s “war against evil” was rooted in a lie from its inception. Iraq was not involved in the 9/11 attacks in New York, nor did it possess “weapons of mass destruction.” Colin Powell lied to the U.N. about both matters and said regretfully later that his testimony would be a stain on his reputation for the rest of his life.
The conclusion to be drawn is that the wars in and on Vietnam and Iraq were completely “wars of choice” that America did not have to fight. These wars took the lives of more than 62,000 American men and women. They left at least 336,000 wounded. (The estimate of 32,000 for Iraq is widely thought to be an underestimate. The Pentagon reported that 1 in 4 soldiers returned with health problems.)
An illegal war
What could deservedly be called worse is that between 17 and 22 veterans have been lost to suicide every day (every day!) between 2017 and 2024 — roughly 7,000 a year — many of them veterans of Vietnam and Iraq.
I leave it to more dispassionate thinkers to judge if their service could have led some to take their lives. Unlike the presidents who were primarily responsible for both wars, the veterans did not have the option of a retirement that offered luxury on a Texas ranch thereafter.
The war in Iran is illegal and was initiated in cooperation and in collusion with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who has been trying for decades trying for decades to create a war between Iran and the United States. What has now become public knowledge is that every senior commander from each of our armed services had voted against such an involvement because of the international consequences to oil-dependent countries, including our own. What happened instead was a cooperative bombing campaign against Iran by Israel and the United States.
Most Americans oppose dictatorial government, but they tend to treat Trumpism with indifference, as if it were a passing phase. “This won’t last,” they say. “All politicians lie.” “All democracies go through times like these.” “He won’t be president for long.” “The Democrats will take over soon.”
But that kind of thinking is both immature and dangerous. Thinking that a president’s excesses — and their effects — will just evaporate only leaves us feeling secure in our indifference while the worst keeps happening. The effects of a war a president chooses to wage last for decades.
Those responsible for war
Based on the history, starting at least with Johnson and Vietnam, and then Bush and Iraq, and the chosen attacks on Venezuela and Iran by the current occupant of the White House, the attraction of pursuing chosen wars has not waned.
Apart from those killed, the probability is that future veteran suicides will occur because of their service in a war their nation should not have been fighting. If they do, who will be to blame but the president who chose to go to war and the Congress that did not restrain him?
Samuel Hazo, Pennsylvania’s first poet laureate, was a professor of English at Duquesne University and the founder of the International Poetry Forum. His latest book of poems is “But More So.” He is subject of “Before the Pen Runs Dry,” a biography by Janine Molinaro. His previous article was “The true citizen fights injustice.”
Editor’s Note: A change to the last paragraph was made at the author’s request. When the op-ed was first published, the first name of the author of the biography of Mr. Hazo was incorrect. It is Janine.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.