Ten years ago, on the eve of the presidential election, I wrote a column for this paper in which I said that while campaigns are a time for making promises, when the election is over, we and our leaders must face reality. The reality then was that our federal government was on a financially unsustainable path.

That remains true and for the same reasons: the nation’s ever-growing debt and its way of financing Social Security and Medicare.

The growing debt

The first reason is that since 1981, in good times and bad, the federal government has consistently spent more money than it had collected in taxes. Financing those deficits had driven up our national debt more rapidly than our Gross National Product (GDP), which is the capacity to pay the interest on that debt, had grown.

The ratio of our public debt to GDP was .3:1 in 1981. By 2025 it had grown to 1.24:1. That ratio cannot continue to grow indefinitely. At some point, lenders will believe that we do not have the capacity to pay the interest due. To avoid default, the government will simply print more money and generate inflation.

Advertise with us

We are a long way from that point. But history provides many unhappy stories of nations that were forced to inflate away their debt burdens. It is not a position in which we want to find ourselves.

The failing funds

The second reason we were and are on a financially unsustainable path is that our system of financing Social Security and Medicare depends on collecting a wage tax. This was not a problem when retirees represented a small fraction of the population.

But those days are past. Our retired population has been growing more rapidly than our working population for a long time. In 1965, there were four workers paying the wage tax for every retired person collecting Social Security and Medicare benefits. In 2013, that ratio was only 2.8 workers per retiree and is expected to continue to fall toward two workers per retiree.

Consequently, back in 2016, the trustees of the Social Security and Medicare trust funds were predicting that unless changes in these programs increased their revenues, there would not be enough revenues by the mid-2030s to pay all of the legally promised benefits. As with reducing our debt, since 2016 nothing has changed.

As a result of the pressure of the continuing increase in the nation’s public debt and of the inexorable rise in the percentage of our population that relied on Social Security and Medicare to keep them out of poverty when they could no longer work, the reality I saw post-election in 2016 was that whoever was elected, and the general public, would be forced to do the unpopular thing and raise taxes while also limiting the growth in federal government spending.

Advertise with us

The inescapable reality

Obviously, I was wrong. The Congressional Budget office predicts that without any change in policies, this debt/income ratio will continue to increase. The trustees of the Social Security and Medicare Trust funds continue to forecast that without a change in revenue or benefit policies the government will not be able to meet all of its legal obligations by the middle of the next decade.

Of course, no one could have predicted in 2016 the pandemic that occurred four years later and the havoc that pandemic created in the nation’s economy. There were more pressing problems than concerns for the longer term financial stability of our Social Security and Medicare programs, yet alone the even longer term problem of the financial instability of our entire federal government.

But, the reality is that those remain important issues. Thankfully, the pandemic has passed and the economy is functioning reasonably well. It remains to be seen whether those who are elected this year will face up to the inescapable reality that the federal government does not have the money to do everything it wants to do.

Jack Ochs is professor of economics, emeritus, at the University of Pittsburgh. He lives in Point Breeze. His previous article was “Can the voters tell if the president is mentally fit?.”