The conflict the United States and Israel initiated last weekend will probably rage on for years to come. Not the actual war taking place in Iran and throughout the Middle East — the conflict between those debating whether the war was necessary. Iran was not an imminent threat, but it was an inevitable one.

How and when it ends will greatly influence these debates in the future. Victory has a way of making the rashest decisions seem rational and reasonable in retrospect.

Having started the war, President Donald Trump will have that debate in mind as he makes two important decisions: when to end it and what to do then. It would be a shame if he got both wrong, but there will be pressure to do just that.

An inevitable war

Some will argue the war should be ended immediately because it is unconstitutional and illegal. That’s probably true, but it does not mean it was unnecessary.

Advertise with us

When Trump backed out of the nuclear deal with Iran negotiated under President Obama, he made war just a question of time. The deal had put reasonable safeguards on Iran’s nuclear program and delayed missile development mainly based on the premise that over time the regime in power in Tehran might become more moderate. The recent slaughter of tens of thousands of protestors in Iran demonstrated how false that hope was.

In addition, Iran’s leaders had three examples to guide how they developed their nuclear program and they did not point to restraint.

Read More

Iraq stopped its programs of weapons mass destruction and was invaded by the U.S. nonetheless. Libya surrendered its nuclear equipment and was quickly held up as a success story by the architects of the Iraq invasion. North Korea developed nuclear weapons during the 1990s, even though it agreed not to.

Both Saddam Hussein and Muammar Gaddafi may have wondered before they were killed whether a real WMD program might have saved them. That is because North Korea’s dear leader gets treated as a world power and gets courted by the president of the U.S. instead of deposed.

Iran, since the end of the nuclear deal, had amassed hundreds of kilograms of uranium enriched to near weapons grade for which it had no legitimate use. But it would make the time needed to put together a nuclear weapon potentially a matter of days in the future.

Advertise with us

Iran and Israel

Again, Iran was an inevitable if not an imminent threat. The talks underway had no prospect of success. Iran was not going to end its nuclear program, stop developing greater missile capability or cease supporting terrorist organizations. And if the U.S. had been willing to accept anything less, it would have only delayed the crisis and not prevented it.

The debate about whether war could have been avoided is now theoretical. The questions that matter is when to end it and what to do after that. According to a Fox News journalist, Trump is going to use Venezuela as a “template” for Iran. When President Maduro was removed from power by American troops, his vice president was allowed to take over. She made some cosmetic changes and gave Trump access to her country’s oil.

The same thugs are still in power, however. Nevertheless, that was enough for Trump, who lost interest in seeing democracy restored and settled for stability instead. That approach won’t work in Iran. Leaving the regime 99% intact, even if its military capability is severely diminished, won’t change Iran’s behavior in the region.

The war should therefore continue until Iran has leaders who are willing to live with other countries in the region and not threaten them. That does not mean American boots on the ground, but it does mean an air war that will last longer than many will like.

That won’t earn Trump the Nobel Peace Prize, but the second thing he should do might. In addition to ensuring Iran has leadership that is will to accept peace, he needs to do that in one other country.

Advertise with us

Over its history Israel has been constantly plagued by threats to its security from three sources: a conventional military attack by its neighbors, weapons of mass destruction launched from another country, and the internal threat of terrorism as most horrifically demonstrated by the Hamas attacks of October 7, 2023.

Jimmy Carter eliminated the conventional military threat when he got Egypt and Israel to agree on peace. No other combination of Israel’s neighbors could then contemplate success in such an assault. If nothing else, American wars against Iraq and now against Iran have limited the possibility of an attack using WMD.

Trump and Netanyahu

Only Israel can eliminate the third threat by engaging in serious discussions with Palestinians that will lead to creation of a state of their own.

While he signed Trump’s 20-point peace plan for Gaza, Prime Minister Netanyahu is violating at least three key points. He continues military attacks, asserts the Palestinian Authority will never be allowed to govern there again and refuses to discuss any future that includes a Palestinian state. In other words, he is rendering initiatives vital for Trump’s legacy like the Abraham Accords, the Board of Peace, and his peace plan for Gaza meaningless.

No president has done more for Israel than Trump, including the current war, which Netanyahu dragged the U.S. into. It is now time for Trump to insist that Netanyahu make all America has done worthwhile by making peace in the Middle East possible.

Dennis Jett, former American ambassador to Mozambique and Peru, was a professor of international affairs at Penn State University. A contributing writer for the Post-Gazette editorial page, he writes every other Friday. His previous article was “Marco Rubio makes nice with Europe.”