As an immigrant watching Minnesota from afar, I feel like news I’m seeing America slipping out of reach. The raids. The sudden presence of federal agents in neighborhoods that were, until recently, just places where people worked, raised kids, ran restaurants, paid rent. The deaths. On paper, this is enforcement. In real life, it feels like something else entirely.
The saddest part isn’t only what’s happening to immigrants in Minnesota. It’s what this moment says about America. The America I have seen and loved for many years, including my years in Pittsburgh as a student at Pitt.
A strange and painful turn
For a country built by immigrants, this is a strange and painful turn. Immigrants aren’t supposed to feel hunted here. We came — legally, illegally, temporarily, permanently — because America sold itself on something bigger than paperwork: fairness, rules that apply to everyone, dignity under the law. Watching Minnesota from afar, that promise looks thinner than it used to.
And yet Minnesota is also showing something else. Something else that is characteristically American. A quality that also attracts immigrants: the kindness and concern of so many of the American people with the lives of their neighbors.
At the same time federal agents are pouring into the state under Operation Metro Surge, Minnesotans are showing up — for their neighbors, for workers, for businesses, for communities that suddenly feel exposed. Cities are pushing back. Community leaders are speaking plainly. Ordinary people are refusing to pretend this is normal. Minnesota is showing two versions of America at once.
That tension matters, because the harm isn’t theoretical. It’s already here.
Economically, this crackdown isn’t some abstract policy debate. Immigrants aren’t a footnote in Minnesota’s economy. They’re part of its spine. One in five workers comes from African, Latino, Asian, and Native American (ALANA) communities. One in ten businesses.
One dollar out of every five earned. Nearly 60% of Minnesota’s labor force growth in recent years came from foreign-born workers. Remove people at that scale — even briefly — and the economy doesn’t politely adjust. It stumbles.
You can see it without a spreadsheet. Restaurants with empty tables during what should be a lunch rush. Businesses slashing hours after losing staff overnight. Shops closing altogether. Even a month of fear-driven absence can ripple into missed rent, stressed property markets, and shrinking local tax bases.
This isn’t “open borders” ideology. It’s hard-headed business math.
And that math doesn’t stop at state lines. Nationally, immigrants generate roughly $2.1 trillion in economic output. They pay hundreds of billions in federal, state, and local taxes. Even undocumented immigrants (so often painted as burdens) pay tens of billions each year while being excluded from many of the benefits those taxes support. These aren’t talking points. They’re line items.
A loss of democracy
But this moment isn’t really about economics. It’s about democracy.
What’s most unsettling to watch is how easily democratic norms are being stretched and the definitions normalized. Deploying thousands of federal agents into a single state — so many they outnumber local law enforcement — changes the relationship between the federal government and the states and local communities.
It stops feeling like governance and starts feeling like control. In a democracy, the line between the two matters.
Minnesota seems to understand this instinctively. That’s why the resistance there feels different. It isn’t flashy or performative. It’s civic. It says: we can argue about immigration policy, but we don’t discard basic principles of proportionality, accountability and humanity along the way.
As an immigrant watching from outside the state, that matters more than symbolism. It tells me that parts of America still remember what they’re supposed to be.
At the same time, the fear is impossible to miss. Immigrants are being reminded clearly that belonging is conditional. That the law they obeyed can be reinterpreted. That obeying the law and contributing to America doesn’t guarantee protection. This is how trust erodes. And when trust goes, democracy doesn’t collapse overnight. It thins. It frays. It becomes optional.
America isn’t failing because immigrants are here. It’s failing because it’s growing comfortable with an administration treating entire communities as expendable in pursuit of political theater.
Questionable credibility
Right now, Minnesota is showing the country two paths. One where enforcement overwhelms democracy and fear replaces law. Another where communities push back, insist on dignity, and refuse to let power go unchecked.
The rest of the country will have to decide which Minnesota it wants to follow.
Immigrants are watching, not just because our lives are affected, but because America’s credibility is. This country taught much of the world how democracy is supposed to look in practice. The question now is whether it still believes its own lesson.
Monik Bhatta, a graduate of the University of Pittsburgh, has worked in international development for a decade and recently graduated from the Harvard Kennedy School of Government. His previous article was “America must use its soft power.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.