Wouldn’t it be great if we could place millionaires and billionaires who get elected to public office in a simulator before they begin, like we require of pilots before they fly a commercial aircraft with three hundred people on board?
Unfortunately, no such thing exists. Also unfortunately, unlike an aircraft with clear instruments that tells pilots everything they need to know to fly their plane, what to do about the economy, crime, foreign policy, everything a politician does, is open to subjective interpretations.
Is the interest rate too low or too high? Which inflation rate are we relying on the Consumer price index (CPI) or Personal Consumption Expenditures. How much is a trillion dollars really? Many of the results that politicians take credit or blame for are beyond their control.
But they need a simulator. They really do.
They don’t understand
Have you ever felt the insensitivity of someone making more money than you, telling you that you go to this fabulous restaurant unmindful of the fact that you can’t afford a $200 meal?
Or a neighbor who recommends a great vacation in a spot they just visited, while you’re just hoping to have enough gas in the car to get to work this week?
It doesn’t feel good, but it’s not intentional. It’s just someone with $30,000 or $40,000 more a year in income losing touch with how other people live — maybe how they used to live. So how can billionaires understand our economic situation?
What we need from millionaires and billionaire politicians is empathy. They often claim to understand us, but do they? Can they? I maintain they can’t.
That is why I’m suggesting a different kind of simulator for millionaires and billionaires before they take office. It’s quite simple.
My proposed simulator — let’s call it a Real Life Simulator — is an apartment in an undisclosed location in one of Pittsburgh’s neighborhoods like Greenfield, Stanton Heights or the West End. Our billionaire couple will enter their 700 sf one bedroom apartment. I expect this will come as a shock, as they are asked to live in a space not much larger than the walk-in closets in one of their current homes.
They will be asked to live for 60 days on an annual income of $83,730, the median income in Pittsburgh according to the U.S. Census bureau.
One of them works as a retail clerk at a jewelry store downtown for $15 an hour and the other drives for a package delivery service in Robinson Township. Their direct deposit for one month after Federal and PA state taxes, Social Security tax, Medicare tax, and finally local Pittsburgh tax leaves (drum roll please!) $5341!
In their old billionaire life, they could spend this amount every day for over five hundred years and still not run out of money. But in our simulator, this must last one month.
They need to see
Most rental companies will only lease to those who’s rent, and utilities are at 30% or less of their income so they can pay $2093 a month in rent and utilities.
Because their employers do not offer health insurance the couple buys a plan on Pennie for $630/month less an ACA advanced 540-tax credit of $298/month. It’s the least expensive plan and they’ll hope not to need it because the deductible is $13,400!
The USDA estimates their average grocery costs are $790 every month. Just last week our couple may have enjoyed the chef’s tasting menu with the wine pairing at Le Bernardin in NYC for $1060 plus the tip.
He needs a car to get to work. According to Experian, a used one will cost $772 a month, including payment, insurance, and gas. But not repairs. He hasn’t driven in years. His driver takes him or her to the airport where their private plane costing over $700,000 per year is waiting for them.
We’ve left a child out of this scenario. (Never mind two or three.) They have no relatives in Pittsburgh to watch a child for free, and childcare averages $1000 to $2000 every month. Impossible on their income.
That means $1357 remains for cable, cell phones, dentist, health insurance deductibles and copays, car repairs, credit card payments, restaurants, movies, vacations, and savings.
It’s called living paycheck to paycheck. And remember, one-half of households here live on less than this. If life is tight on the median salary, it’s much harder on less than that.
I grew up in a family of eight in Robinson Township and when I was 11 years old, my dad pulled into the local gas station on the corner of Siver Lane Road and Clever Road where he always bought his gas. This was before self-serve and ubiquitous credit cards.
He asked Huey, the owner, if he could get $1 worth of gas and pay him on payday. Of course, Huey agreed, but it struck me that my dad did not even have one dollar to his name. Sometimes the paycheck doesn’t stretch until the next one.
They need to act
I don’t want to demonize the rich. In fact, I would be happy to enter a billionaire simulator and live like one for 60 days so I could better understand them.
Would a billionaire about to take public office emerge from this simulator with more empathy for the people who elected them? Would they make sure better health care and lower drug prices make their way through congress? Could our leaders imagine rescinding the tax cuts and closing loopholes afforded to millionaires and billionaires?
I don’t have an answer, but I’d love to find out.
James Tasillo is retired after a career in the floorcovering industry and resides in Mt. Lebanon. His previous article was “Once there were animals. Now there are parking lots.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.