On a crisp winter day about 50 years ago, I shivered and could see my frosty breath. Unremarkable, you say? Well, at the time I was sitting in a bathtub full of tepid water. This was my introduction to socialism as practiced in Britain prior to the election of Margaret Thatcher.
Coal supplies across Britain were dwindling in 1974. The country was rife with strikes and other industrial action. The socialist leaders of the mining union pressed their advantage and backed the Conservative government into a corner.
To conserve power, the government reduced the country to a three-day work week. My student housing was cold, and hot water was in short supply. My only heat was a small bar heater into which I could insert shillings at designated times to buy myself a few minutes of warmth.
What Britain had become
In 1974, the socialists, through the Labour Party and major trade unions, fomented industrial chaos across Britain. For the first time in its history, the country endured two general elections in the same year. Labour ultimately prevailed.
In 1975, Britain’s inflation rate soared to 25%. In our country, we’ve seen how the 9% inflation rate in 2022 has created a persistent affordability challenge. Imagine what 25% inflation did to the ordinary British family.
My first dissertation supervisor was a socialist. I proposed a dissertation topic of union democracy and the rights of individual workers in Britain. He rejected it, he said, because individual rights and democratic unions were at odds with the broader socialist aims of the trade union movement.
Back in West Virginia, I had been schooled on union democracy by observing Jock Yablonski’s heroic fight against Tony Boyle for leadership of the United Mine Workers. Boyle eventually enlisted three henchmen to assassinate Yablonski, his wife and daughter in their Clarksville home.
Jock’s insurgent movement, which came to be known as the Miners for Democracy, survived and ultimately prevailed because of the courage of individual miners and a legal strategy invoking the protections of the federal Landrum-Griffin Act.
If workers’ rights against oppressive union leadership could succeed in Appalachia, why not in Britain? I found a new dissertation supervisor.
In the summer of 1975, I set off across Britain — to Yorkshire collieries, Midlands factories and other sites of union life — to talk to workers about their jobs and their unions. These were not curated interviews. They were conversations in pubs frequented by union members.
Subject to my promise of anonymity, some conversations were sufficiently detailed to be cited in my dissertation. But most were informal interactions with workers.
What the socialist narrative claimed
Although they were Labour Party voters, they were not socialists in a doctrinaire sense. They were hardworking guys trying to get it done for their families. Their workmates were like brothers to them.
Did they resent their bosses? Yes, but no more than I came to resent some of mine. And no more than I was resented when I became a boss.
What really struck me were their comments about union leadership. My pub friends saw the socialist narrative as a pure power play. They reminded me that their families also suffered because of strikes and industrial action. They figured that either the bosses or the union heads would have power. Better the union heads but not because a socialist utopia beckoned.
The heads of the national unions were not invested in British democracy. Hugh Scanlon of the Amalgamated Engineers, Arthur Scargill of the National Union of Mineworkers, Jack Jones of the Transport and General Workers, and others were devoted to their socialist pathway to power more than the success of their country.
Even their loyalties were in question. Jones, who led the largest union in the country, was later revealed to be a KGB asset who fed government secrets to the Soviets.
When I left Britain in 1976, I saw the country’s future not as a modern economy but as a destination for American and Japanese tourists. Margaret Thatcher proved me wrong — another story for another day. Suffice it to say, with former Prime Minister David Cameron, that Baroness Thatcher “not only served Britain. She saved it.”
Socialism has never worked. Russia, China, North Korea, Cuba, Venezuela. The claims of Bernie Sanders and others that it has worked in Scandinavia are rubbish purveyed by the willfully ignorant. Sweden, Norway and Denmark are market-based economies with private ownership of the means of production and exchange, strong economic freedoms, and social safety nets.
With merit as its polestar, capitalism distributes power and rewards through diffuse market decisions. Socialism centrally allocates power and rewards regardless of merit and stifles prosperity, innovation and growth.
What will the Democrats be?
The savants of political commentary say that the 2026 mid-term elections and the 2028 presidential election are important, and they’re right.
But of greater importance is the Democratic Party’s primary election season in 2028, when we will learn whether one of our two major parties has morphed into a socialist party controlled by the likes of Bernie Sanders, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and Zohran Mamdani.
Like their socialist forebears worldwide, they and others seek power for themselves. They do not love or wish to promote this country for what has made it great — capitalism, freedom, Judeo-Christian ethics and the Anglo-American legal tradition.
Democrats have a choice in the coming years. Learn from history or seek to impose its most grievous errors on the American people. I lived under socialist rule, and I learned to hate it.
Peter Kalis was, before his retirement, chairman and global managing partner of K&L Gates, and is now an independent commentator. He writes every other Monday. His previous article was “Ranking the vice-presidents.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.