How many Jews are in the world? Have a guess? Answer: Just about 16 million, and that’s if you count every single Jew from the devout who connects to everything Jewish to the assimilated who connects to the everything bagel.

Another question: How many Americans claim Italian ancestry? The U.S. Census Bureau puts it as around 16 million. In other words, there are as many Italian Americans in our country as there are Jews on the entire planet.

Surprised? Despite what the haters fear, there simply are not that many of us.

The story of the Jewish people is the story of a very small minority just trying to live life without being hassled or murdered for being a Jew. Hanukkah, which we celebrate this week, the week of the horrible massacre on Bondi Beach, has that message as well.

Advertise with us

The real story

The real story of Hanukkah is not often told. We like the simple story of the miracle of the oil because it safely sets Hanukkah with God instead of the messy truth of the battlefield. But tell it we must (if carefully for younger ears).

At the time of Hanukkah, the Greeks were the Empire of the day. Jews living in the Land of Israel (there were always Jews living in the Land of Israel) lived a Jewish life, prayed in a Jewish way and more or less got along with the Empire.

Jews spoke Greek and ate spanakopita. Actually, I’m guessing about the spanakopita but they did speak Greek and in all sorts of ways embraced Greek culture. And who wouldn’t? Greece had any number of wonderful things: philosophy, commerce, the Olympics, and all the things we still admire about them including, for sure, the food.

The only challenge for the Jews was to figure out how much of Greek culture they wished to embrace. That challenge has been the same challenge Jews have faced everywhere we have lived.

How much should we be like everyone else and how much should we live uniquely Jewish lives? Finding that balance is what every Jew does every day.

Advertise with us

This all ended in 167 BCE when Antiochus IV became the king of the region. He named himself Epiphanes meaning “God Made Manifest.” When a king decides he is God, it’s never good for the Jews.

Soon enough Antiochus started banning Jewish practices small and large. Every religion has members who do a whole lot and those who don’t do so much, so when Antiochus started banning elements of Jewish life, we just took it. And then he went too far.

He started doing things that made it impossible for Jews to be Jewish and that is when the rebellion started. Is it so much to ask that we simply not be wiped out? Were we really a threat to the mighty Greek empire? Then why were we being crushed? Are we really a threat to anyone? Then why are we being murdered?

A common story

Bondi Beach, Australia, and Manchester, England, and Athens, Greece, and Rouen, France, and Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania — and those are just the ones that are so outrageous they make the news. We are being murdered for being Jews. Once again somebody thinks he’s Epiphanes, God, allowed to decide what Jews are allowed to do.

I can hear you saying it’s about Israel. It’s not about Israel. It’s not about Palestinians. There is a desire for justice in that conflict that is shared by every Jew I know. The details might be up for discussion, but the Jews I know would love to see peace for everyone.

Advertise with us

And I know a lot of Jews. What I don’t see are Jews using the October 7 attack as an excuse to murder Palestinian civilians wherever they may be.

Outside of the West Bank, I don’t see Muslims fearing that Jews will start shooting up their mosques wherever they live around the world (and it is wrong and criminal when it happens in the West Bank). I don’t see Jews blowing up Halal food shops. What I see are Jews trying to live as Jews and a whole bunch of other people not really minding so much when we get murdered.

We are in good company. There were a whole lot of people who didn’t seem to mind when 6500 black people were lynched between 1865 and 1950. There were a whole lot of people who were okay with the physical and cultural attacks on Native Americans. You are following the Carlisle Indian Industrial School story, right?

We can go on and on with minorities doing nothing more than trying to live their life with their own customs and being hated for it.

But I don’t want to teach victimhood to my students. Despite the fact that Jew haters just insist on keeping us victimized, I don’t want my students to feel oppressed.

Advertise with us

The true story

I want them to feel proud of the meaning and value behind our customs and traditions. I want them to know our mitzvahs can bring a little holiness into a very angry world. I want them to know that the Hanukkah menorah in the window tells the neighbors that pride is good, that resilience is good and that being a Jew is a wonderful thing.

I want them to know that the Jews who fought against Antiochus back then wanted the same thing we want: to use our 3000 year old heritage to make the world a better place and make ourselves better people.

That’s it. And though they murder us, that is what we will continue to do.

Rabbi Larry Freedman is director of the Religious School for Rodef Shalom, Beth Shalom, and Temple Sinai congregations.