Earlier this fall, universities around the country learned that money appropriated by Congress through the Title VI program would not be released. The money funded studies centers that focused scholarly attention on Latin America, East Asia, the Middle East and Africa.
These programs were deemed “inconsistent with Administration priorities and do not advance American interest or values” according to the notice of cancellation.
The idea that producing expertise about regions of the world where America has political, security and economic interests is “inconsistent with Administration priorities” might be fodder for a few good jokes — of course, this administration doesn’t want to produce expertise.
Plenty of people in Trump’s orbit think this kind of expertise is “useless.” They are the same people who thought on Sept. 10, 2001, that there wasn’t any point to learning Arabic. And then there was.
That’s the thing about experts: you never know when you really need them.
Knowing Russia
Title VI also funded Russian and East European centers as well and canceling those centers seems particularly obtuse at this moment. As Vladimir Putin’s war against Ukraine drags on, and as Donald Trump’s attempts to deal with Putin pinball from tough-talk to appeasement, we need the experts who know that part of the world more than ever.
Full disclosure: my wife is a professor of Russian and director of the Slavic, East European, and Eurasian Studies Center at Ohio State, so I know a fair bit about this. Over the years, graduates of her programs have gone on to serve in the military, in the CIA, the State Department.
Take Ben Nathans, as just one example. A Soviet historian, Nathans also benefited from Title VI funding as an emerging scholar. His new book, “To the Success of Our Hopeless Cause,” the definitive history of Soviet dissidents, could not be more timely. And it just won the Pulitzer Prize.
While he was at it, Trump also defunded the Kennan Institute in Washington. The Institute was founded, and funded, by Congress in 1974 and takes as its motto: “Congressionally Chartered, Scholarship Driven, Fiercely Nonpartisan.”
In its 50 years of operation it became America’s most important center for the analysis of Soviet, and then post-Soviet affairs. The Institute brought together historians, political scientists, economists, journalists, policy makers, and diplomats all focused on understanding Russia.
America will feel the loss
And not just Americans. The Institute also brought people of significance from the region to Washington to meet with Congressional leaders and policy makers. As a leading Russian historian put it: Kennan “got the right people to talk about the right things” for decades.
Earlier this year, for example, the Institute brought exiled Russian political dissident Vladimir Kara-Murza to talk about the state of political repression inside Russia. He offered a perspective on current events in Russia that no one else could give.
The Institute also sent people to the region as well. In 1998, for example, Kennan opened an office in Kyiv, Ukraine, which worked to broaden American understanding of that newly independent country.
Over the course of its 50 years, Kennan fellows and staff met regularly with Congressional leaders, the State Department, and policy-makers from all administrations. Its public programs, extensive publications, and visiting fellows served as an unparalleled resource.
What has been lost is knowledge, expertise, experience, even a certain kind of wisdom in a way that scholars have that others, including those serving in government, usually don’t. On Sept. 12, 2001, America discovered we needed more people who knew Arabic.
The loss will hurt America right now. It may well hurt us worse later. By closing the Kennan Institute and university-based area studies centers, this administration is turning off a pipeline of people who will know anything about the places they go to serve.
America and its allies will feel the loss — probably soon, but certainly in five years, in 10, in 30. As the song goes, “you don’t know what you’ve got till it’s gone.”
Expertise and ignorance
Trump has always resented expertise. He needs to believe that he’s the smartest guy in the room. No one knows this better than Vladimir Putin. The only time the otherwise stone-faced Putin ever smiles is when he’s with Donald Trump?
Expertise can’t solve all our thorny problems. But ignorance solves none of them, and what Trump has done amounts to a huge own-goal against American interests around the world.
Steven Conn is the W.E. Smith Professor of History at Miami University in Oxford, Ohio, and author of “The Lies of the Land,” on the myth of rural America. His previous article was “Jerry Jones shows how in today’s economy you can win by losing.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.