Driving my daughter to school along Penn Avenue, I pass many of the same "uremic yellow" brick houses that H.L. Mencken savaged so eloquently back in 1927. The Baltimore journalist’s description of the region as containing "the most loathsome towns and villages ever seen by mortal eye" and "human habitations so abominable that they would have disgraced a race of alley cats" remains reasonably accurate.

The houses still "lean this way and that, hanging on to their bases precariously," still sport "dead and eczematous patches of paint peeping through the streaks."

Yet Pittsburgh just climbed 16 spots in PwC's national real estate rankings, reaching No. 29 among America's most attractive markets. My software engineer acquaintance who bought a $500,000 Lawrenceville property with cash and called Pittsburgh a nice "starter city" would probably find Mencken's prose quaint.

Affordable for whom?

Mencken wrote that from East Liberty to Greensburg, "there was not one in sight from the train that did not insult and lacerate the eye." Today's East Liberty hosts Google offices and "five of Pittsburgh's 33 best restaurants," but venture beyond the gentrified corridors of the "AI Avenue" and many of his observations hold.

Advertise with us

The PwC report celebrates Pittsburgh's "rare combination of innovation, quality of life and cost efficiency," noting our affordability "creates an attractive environment for both businesses and individuals looking to grow." Translation: tech workers priced out of actually vibrant cities or driven out by fear of incoming left-wing mayoral regimes can buy our ugly houses cheap.

Dallas/Fort Worth, which as a former resident I can confidently state is the ugliest metro in the entire country, topped the list, but Pittsburgh's 16-spot jump represents the year's biggest movement. The report credits Carnegie Mellon, UPMC and tech firms for fueling "steady economic expansion and renewed national appeal."

That’s true, but there’s plenty missing from this analysis: local workers earning 8% below national average while median home prices hit $250,000-$275,000, creating price-to-income ratios of 7.8 to 8.8 times salary for an underemployed reserve army of service workers struggling to earn $30,000 annually.

Owning the ugliness

The ugliness Mencken documented wasn't accidental but deliberate, what he called "a positive libido for the ugly." Pittsburgh's current leaders share this aesthetic masochism. We tear down old affordable housing to build mixed-use apartments above yuppified retail stores and "innovation districts" that look like airport terminals.

We celebrate converting old schools and factories into loft apartments while ignoring that the conversions end up emphasizing the worst architectural features of the old and new: fortress-like facades, windowless walls, the general appearance and charm of a minimum-security prison.

Advertise with us

Mencken suspected "the vast majority of the honest folk … actually admire the houses they live in and are proud of them." He was right, though not how he imagined. We natives don't admire our ugliness so much as own it, for more than a century in the case of my mother’s family homes in Ellsworth and Scenery Hill.

These leprous hills and clapboarded horrors constitute our inheritance, our patrimony. My family died in their beds in these ugly houses across generations. Their ghosts haunt our aluminum-sided row houses, not those Victorian painted ladies who disembarked for New York when class war heated up after the Homestead strike of 1892.

Pittsburgh’s endurance

Surviving is about all many of us are doing inside the city limits: The Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland ranks Pittsburgh second-worst nationally for regaining pandemic-lost jobs, behind only dysfunctional San Francisco.

Limited by onerous regulations governing construction and laws governing annexation, Pittsburgh manages to be both economically stagnant and aesthetically offensive, but that offense is ours to claim. The city’s schools hemorrhage students — enrollment dropped during three years of COVID lockdowns to 18,500, and is projected to hit an unsustainable 12,000 by 2031 — while former family homes become Airbnbs for visiting Google contractors.

Neighborhood schools are threatened with closure in areas where childless, cash-buying carpetbaggers can renovate kitchens worth more than the displaced families' annual incomes.

Advertise with us

The remote workers bidding $50,000 over asking don't understand that our ugliness isn't incidental but essential. They see degradation where we see endurance. They mistake our architectural blight for opportunities to gentrify rather than monuments to persistence. When they call Pittsburgh a "starter city," they reveal their fundamental misunderstanding: This city finishes people, buries them in those cemetery-gravestone houses Mencken described.

Mencken called our architecture "grotesqueries of ugliness that, in retrospect, become almost diabolical." The diabolic persists, now wrapped in marketing speak about "emerging markets" and "opportunity zones" seemingly better-suited to Poland emerging from the Warsaw Pact in 1989 than Pittsburgh during Trump’s second term.

But this ugliness belongs to those of us who've earned it through generations of residence, who understand that beauty isn't the point when survival is the question. Woe to those who come merely for value extraction, who see our scars as bargains to flip rather than biographies to read.

They'll never understand why we guard our ugliness so fiercely — it's all we have left that the market can’t and won’t put a price on.

Oliver Bateman, a contributing writer for the Post-Gazette editorial page, is a historian and widely published journalist and author of the Substack, Oliver Bateman Does the Work. He grew up in Washington County and lives in Pittsburgh. His article appears every other Thursday, and his previous one was “Pittsburgh's construction chaos is our topographical destiny.”