The election of Zohran Mamdani as mayor of New York City created a rising political star, whose victory may lead the Democratic Party closer to abandoning its endorsement of Israel as a Jewish homeland and diminishing its ability to offer a “Big Tent” of political views, an inclusiveness that allows it to compete with the Republican Party in national elections.

It is no secret that Mamdani is uncompromising in his belief that the State of Israel should not be a Jewish homeland, but a “single, secular democratic state.” That is a radical departure from the over eighty years’ worth of Democratic Party support for Zionism — an international movement advocating for a Jewish homeland.

Mamdani’s radical departure

He has held his views consistently since college, when he called the U.S. the “primary accomplice in the Israeli occupation of Palestine.”

As a new member of the state assembly, he promised to hold everyone in power accountable “for their incomprehensible fealty to the Israeli state.” He introduced legislation “threatening to strip New York nonprofits of their tax-exempt status if their funds were used to support Israel’s military and settlement activity,” the New York Times reported.

Advertise with us

“Since Hamas’s Oct. 7 attack tipped the region into all-out war,” the Times report continued, “he has accused Israel of committing genocide, vowed to arrest its leader and said he could not support the country as long as it is an officially Jewish state that gives lesser rights to Palestinians.”

This is an almost complete break with the Democratic Party’s position of over eight decades.

In 1944, the Democratic Party platform included the language: “We favor the opening of Palestine to unrestricted Jewish immigration and colonization, and such a policy as to result in the establishment there of a free and democratic Jewish commonwealth.” In 2024, the party platform reaffirmed that original commitment with its strong support of Israel as a “Jewish and democratic state.”

When less than 1% of the electorate can swing a presidential election, the ramifications of reversing this long-standing position would be catastrophic for the Democratic Party. Jewish voters make up approximately 2% of the electorate and even more so in the important swing states of Pennsylvania and Arizona.

Most importantly, close to 70% of the Jewish electorate still identify themselves as Democrats, 73% still view Israel favorably, and 80% to 85% turn out to vote.

Advertise with us

Losing centrists and progressives

Withdrawing support for a Jewish homeland may not only encourage Jewish voters to leave the Democratic Party, but also centrists and, ironically, some progressives.

Centrist Democrats may view this withdrawal as a symbolic shift toward a party where only progressive views hold sway. Outside the party, this may discourage independents and centrist Republicans from supporting Democratic candidates.

Progressives who support Israel as a Jewish homeland, yet fervently disagree with the actions of its government, may also be driven away if the party accepts Mamdani’s argument of intolerance: “You can’t be progressive anymore on everything but Palestine.”

To hold the coalition together and avoid a voting catastrophe in the next Presidential election, the party needs to make a compromise within itself by endorsing Israel as a Jewish homeland, an endorsement that must be unwavering, while at this same time feeling free to criticize the government of Israel in its use of military force. It is fair for party leaders to strongly disagree with the government of Israel in how it uses its military forces.

Reclaiming the presidency

Mamdani’s intolerant thinking on Israel must not permeate the Democratic Party. Instead, the party should continue its unwavering support of Israel as a Jewish homeland while at the same time engaging with the Israeli government in its use of force.

Advertise with us

Does this compromise approach sound like a return to a Biden-era policy? Perhaps it does. But it is the one policy that will help the party maintain its traditional coalition and thereby allow it the opportunity to reclaim the presidency in 2028.

Bernard S. Sharfman is a research fellow with the Law & Economics Center at George Mason University’s Antonin Scalia Law School. The opinions expressed here do not represent the official positions of the Center. His previous article was “Socialism will not save the Democratic Party. Its historic centrism will.”