Seven justices serve ten-year terms on our state’s highest court and this year Pennsylvania voters must decide whether to keep three of them, all Democrats. I urge a ‘no’ vote on all three.
The Pennsylvania Constitution allows sitting justices to be retained or removed with a simple “yes” or “no” vote without reference to political affiliation, in a system was designed to remove justices from political pressures. This is not to say that individual justices lack a party affiliation.
Justices are initially elected in partisan elections. Pennsylvania is one of only eight states that elect justices that way. Five justices are Democrats and two are Republicans. Your vote, on November 4, 2025, will determine our future. The three Democrats up for vote are Christine Donohue, David Wecht, and Kevin Dougherty.
How the court has ruled
Consider Court several rulings:
• Ruling that undated ballots must be rejected under state law. But, 2022 mail-in and absentee ballots would be counted if dated in a period of days before and after the election. (Ball v. Chapman) Permitting correction of ballot errors. (In re: Canvassing of Absentee and Mail-In Ballots of 2024 Primary Election, 2025)
• Reversing a lower court’s order halting the 2020 general election certification. Republicans argued Act 77, permitting voting by mail, violated the state constitution. (November 21, 2020). It allowed mail-in ballots to be counted. (Boockvar, 2020)
• Replacing the Legislature’s district voting map. (League of Women Voters of Pennsylvania, 2018)
• Allowing the Governor to close businesses and schools during the COVID epidemic. (Friends of Devito, 2020)
• Upholding state law preventing municipalities from passing gun control laws. (Langer v. Philadelphia, 2024)
The court’s political effects
One clear political effect of the court’s rulings has been its pivotal impact on the 2020 elections. For example, the U.S. Constitution provides, “The times, places, and Manner of holding Elections for Senators and Representatives, shall be prescribed in each State by the Legislature thereof.”
Our Court ignored this constitutional mandate when it allowed the redrawing of electoral districts created by the legislature and approved in its place a new gerrymandered map favoring Democrats. It ignored Article I again when it chose to modify Act 77 ballot provisions using the COVID epidemic as a basis for doing so. Democrats took control of both the U.S. House of Representatives and the Pennsylvania House.
The Public Interest Law Center has lawsuits pending on Pennsylvania’s election process. The Court’s rulings will affect the 2026 and 2028 Pennsylvania and national elections. Given the majority’s prior opinions, it will likely favor few limits on our election process.
Another likely effect is the court’s ruling on our state’s abortion laws. Based in part on a 2024 ruling on Medicaid, Justices Donohue and Wecht are seen as favoring the view that the Pennsylvania’s Constitution protects the right to abortion.
A third possible effect is future government action in an “emergency.” During the COVID epidemic, the court upheld emergency powers shuttering “non-essential” businesses and stay-at-home orders. The state arbitrarily determined which businesses were “essential.” Schools, churches, small business were closed. Large businesses like “big box” stores and casinos were allowed to stay open.
The effectiveness of such closures on protecting the public against the disease remains contested, but the educational, economic and social impacts were clearly devastating. Should we have another epidemic, or something like it, a Democrat-controlled court would likely approve such restrictions — over the wishes of the people of the state and their elected representatives.
As the Pennsylvania Commonwealth Leaders Fund recently noted, in 2015, “unions, trial lawyers, and Democrats spent millions of dollars to place Donohue, Dougherty and Wecht in the three open seats on the Pennsylvania Supreme Court, securing a 5-2 Democrat majority.”
It was a very political election. Now, thanks to our state constitution, Pennsylvania voters have a chance either to ratify or to reverse it.
What “yes” and “no” votes mean
Judges are limited in expressing their views outside their written decisions and their votes. But their supporters have made clear what positions those voting “yes” are voting for.
The Democratic Legislative Campaign Committee calls the justices’ continued service “essential for safeguarding elections and redistricting fairness.” Gov. Josh Shapiro says they “stand up for all our freedoms” and protect access to abortion and contraception.
According to the State Court Report, “Pro-retention group Pennsylvanians for Judicial Fairness, which has received funding from national Democratic groups, is running an ad saying the ‘PA Supreme Court protected women’s reproductive rights’ in its 2024 ruling.”
A “yes” retention vote will allow a Democrat majority to eliminate abortion restrictions, uphold restrictions on citizens during epidemics or “emergencies,” and modify election laws. A “No” vote could reign in such decisions and would open up the opportunity for challengers to run for those seats.
Richard Morgan spent 20 years as an Air Force judge advocate, working as a prosecutor, military judge, and legal advisor to the U.S. National Communications System, retiring in 1998, and then served as the District Chief Administrative Law Judge, Pittsburgh, until retiring in 2018. His previous article was “The kind of commander in chief America needs.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.