Imagine that someone tells you they have deep regard for all the members of your family as individuals, but they can’t abide the idea of your family continuing to own a home in the community. How would you feel? Notwithstanding the affirmations that this person has nothing against you, the refusal to allow your family a place to call home obviously carries a clear and direct disdain.
That’s how most Jews feel when they’re confronted with anti-Zionism. Anti-Zionism, after all, promotes a straightforward proposition: that Israel, the homeland of the Jewish people, has no place among the community of nations and that it should cease to exist. Anti-Zionists don’t pretend to have a list of nations they want to remove from the international community. It’s only Israel.
False accusations
Let’s be clear: More than 7 million Jews live in Israel, constituting the world’s largest Jewish community. Those Jews have no other place to go. But anti-Zionists don’t care one bit about those 7 million Jews or their fate. When anti-Zionists advocate for ending Israel, while at the same time exhibiting a cavalier disregard for the fate of Israel’s 7 million Jews, that feels hateful to the majority of Jews.
Likewise, when anti-Zionists target local Jewish communities with threatening graffiti and speech, it is construed by most Jews as hate.
There are, of course, those who have various objections to the policies of the state of Israel, or to Israel’s military strategy, or to Israel’s leadership. Criticizing Israel because you fervently want Israel to be the best it can be is not an anti-Zionist stance. To the contrary, it is an approach — taken by more than a few Jews — that aspires to strengthen the Jewish state.
By contrast, anti-Zionists have concluded that the Jewish state is altogether unworthy of preservation. And what is it that makes Israel uniquely heinous? According to their viewpoint, Israel is guilty of three repugnant sins: colonialism, genocide, and apartheid.
Any quick internet search will show that anti-Zionists didn’t need Oct. 7 to come up with these fevered accusations. They have been persuaded of Israel’s guilt on these counts for years.
Through the centuries, Jews have been accused of being ritual murderers, well poisoners, spreaders of disease, out to dominate the world, polluters of racial bloodlines, traitors, purveyors of depravity, controllers of the media or the money supply, and many other things.
Every one of these antisemitic libels proved to be a lie. Every one of them unjustifiably condemned Jews for behavior deemed to be odious and served as an excuse to attack Jews.
The same pattern continues today. The accusations of colonialism, genocide, and apartheid are monstrous canards — never similarly hurled at any other state — that are utilized purely as pretexts to demand the end of the Jewish state.
Modern libels
It is worth recalling just three facts to puncture these modern libels:
First: The Jewish people is the only people ever to have established a state centered on the land of Israel. Jews built such a state three times. The first Jewish state came into existence in the land of Israel approximately 1,600 years before any Arabs arrived in the area. It is no accident that Israel is the internationally recognized homeland of the Jewish people given that the land has been continuously connected to the Jews for 3,000 years.
Second: The Palestinians were offered a state alongside the Jewish state in 1937, in 1948, in 2000, and in 2009. Each time they refused. Had the Palestinians accepted, no Palestinians would ever have died in a war against Israel. The genocide accusation is patently absurd: if the Palestinians were to lay down their weapons, no Palestinian need fear any harm from Israel.
Third: Israel is the most racially diverse country in the Middle East. One quarter of Israel is Arab, and all Israeli citizens enjoy the full right to participate at every level of society. Freedom House, an independent research organization, rates Israel in the top category of free nations in terms of political rights and civil liberties for all. Not one of Israel neighbors comes close to that top category.
Despite these facts, anti-Zionists want us to believe that you can repeatedly pronounce fabricated libels aimed at destroying the world’s only Jewish state and not be considered part of a campaign designed to vilify Jews. It stretches credulity.
Keeping company with terrorists
Anti-Zionists might also contemplate the company they keep. After all, the world’s most prominent anti-Zionists are to be found in the leadership of the Iranian regime, among the terrorists of Hamas, and in Yemen’s Houthi faction.
Each of these groups has proven that their form of Jew hatred is lethal. If the club you join encourages Jew hatred to flourish in its ranks, then making the case that your approach is different requires convincing evidence.
Anti-Zionists, therefore, would do well to consider that history will one day view their positions in much the same way it regards ideas from previous ages that conveyed dark, abhorrent, deadly theories about Jews. Perhaps the end of the Oct. 7 war should similarly prompt anti-Zionists to cease their campaign against Jews before history’s devastating verdict is rendered.
Danny Schiff is the Gefsky Community Scholar at the Jewish Federation of Greater Pittsburgh. He is the author of “Abortion in Judaism” and “Judaism in a Digital Age” and a former member of the City of Pittsburgh Ethics Board.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.