The Allegheny County property tax system is “a slow-motion disaster,” as a recent Post-Gazette editorial stated. As the chair of the county’s Board of Property Assessment Appeals and Review (BPAAR), and a decades-long participant in the policy and politics of assessments, I know this only too well.

To understand what to do about it, however, we have to go back to the 1990s.

Beginning a reform

In 1996, the county’s three commissioners promised to reform the property tax system. Their remedy: Freeze assessments for five years and lay off 46 county assessors. (There are currently only 15 assessors.)

One year later, a judge ruled that in making this move, the commissioners had unlawfully interfered with the administration of the county assessment system. The opinion stated: “The legislature has determined that an assessment system is likely to have greater integrity, consistency and stability if the assessment system is operated by an independent board rather than the … commissioners, or another county official.”

Advertise with us

That independent board was the predecessor to BPAAR. But it had much more authority, and was much more independent, than the version I chair today.

It also only lasted for three years. When Allegheny County adopted home rule in 2000, the new charter scrapped the court-ordered independent system in favor on one under the authority of elected officials. It’s a 25-year mistake that haunts the county to this day.

Prior to home-rule, the seven-member full-time Assessment Board heard all appeals with its county assessors attending each hearing. The Assessment Board was responsible for the revision and equalization of annual assessments. This assured that an independent body had control of the assessment process from beginning to end.

This is also why state law concerning Second Class Counties (Allegheny is the only one) mandates such an independent board. But when Allegheny County chose home rule, it replaced that mandate.

Restoring independence

Today, the Office of Property Assessments (OPA) is separate from BPAAR, which hears appeals. Further, BPAAR has been dependent on OPA for its funding and staffing, reducing the board’s independence. Plus, OPA reports directly to the county executive, who is incentivized to avoid the political tumult of reassessment by any means necessary.

Advertise with us

That’s exactly what happened under former County Executive Rich Fitzgerald. In 2022, Judge Alan Herzberg ruled that “Allegheny County failed to administer the property tax assessment appeal in a just and impartial manner” by manipulating data and overcharging taxpayers in appeals.

The Post-Gazette editorial suggested that a Government Review Commission can study the present system and make recommendations. They will find that the system is broken and in need of reform.

But county leaders don’t have to wait for this commission to make essential reforms.

After all: The answer is already in the Pennsylvania state law that was superseded by home rule in 2000: Restore the administration of the county assessment system to an independent board, rather than the all-too-political executive branch. Assessors can independently make assessments. Elected officials create budgets and establish millage rates.

Making a stronger system

Early in her campaign, County Executive Sara Innamorato courageously promised to order a countywide reassessment to place the taxation system on a firmer and more just footing. She can and must fulfill that promise, with County Council approving funding.

Advertise with us

But she, and council, can also make the system stronger going forward by restoring the independence of BPAAR. That means freeing the board from dependence on the executive branch and giving the board authority over the entire assessment process.

Mike Suley is chair of Allegheny County’s Board of Property Assessment Appeals and Review. His previous article was “That day, thousands of adults cried openly,” about the Kennedy assassination.