Aside from some speeches by Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, the bloody war between Ukraine and Russa has produced little by way of the iconic speechmaking. The principal speech about the conflict is often confusing, contradictory, and self-congratulatory.

It’s nothing like the rhetoric of the past that defended democratic government against its enemies. Memorable rhetoric that evoked watershed moments in America's great struggles against authoritarianism and its respected place in world affairs.

British Prime Minister Winston Churchill's sobering “Iron Curtain" oration is one very good example.

An eloquent defense

Even as he forged a pragmatic relationship with his ally, Joseph Stalin, to defeat fascism during World War II, he never trusted the Soviet leader. After the war, he remained a staunch enemy of Soviet communism and a fully committed Cold Warrior.

Advertise with us

Delivered on March 5, 1946, at Westminster College in Fulton, Missouri, Churchill’s speech warned the American public about the increasingly dangerous threat posed by the Soviet Union in Eastern Europe while urging closer relations between the U.S. and Great Britain to counter this threat.

Both the content and form of Churchill’s message represent a substantive, unequivocal and eloquent defense of democracy. Churchill argued that it would be “unwise” for the free peoples of the world to ignore the “somber facts” or fail “to face them squarely while time remains." The facts led to the undeniable conclusion that the Soviets sought total domination of Eastern Europe, perhaps of the entire European continent.

Churchill bolstered the facts through his style — namely, the gripping “iron curtain” metaphor, which efficiently summed up the ominous situation: "the facts" he had presented demonstrated, for all to see, that "an iron curtain has descended across the Continent,” behind which the peoples of once free states were now under stifling Soviet control.

For Churchill, successfully confronting this harsh reality demanded openly acknowledging the costs — that is, the inevitable suffering and endurance: “Anyone can see ... that our path will be difficult … but if we persevere together ... we shall achieve our common purpose in the end."

What must be fought for

Churchill also recognized the importance of establishing, in no uncertain terms, foundational principles over appeasement, disarmament, or other approaches to international security. "Before we cast away the solid assurances of national armaments for self-preservation, we must be certain that our temple is built not upon shifting sands or quagmires” but on solid, democratic foundations shared by other nations.

Advertise with us

Churchill strengthened his argument by reminding listeners of what they were fighting for and what could be lost. Mainly, the constitutional "right" to vote in "free unfettered elections," "to choose or change the character or form of government under which they dwell," and to be administered by "laws which have received the broad assent of large majorities."

Because he understood the complexities of geopolitics and what the Soviets’ real intentions were, Churchill sharply criticized those who kowtowed to tyrants. In a stark portrayal of events in Eastern Europe under Soviet rule, Churchill urged, “We cannot be blind to the fact that the liberties enjoyed by individual citizens are not valid in a considerable number of countries," which were enforcing authoritarian rule through oppressive police states.

Still, Churchill’s oration softened its brusque tone but added to the overall argument by issuing a conciliatory moral appeal for peaceful coexistence. He acknowledged the Soviet Union’s "rightful place among the leading nations of the world.” Yet, as we said, Churchill tempered his moral appeal with hard logic and alarming facts.

Churchill's speech is a relic of a bipolar world to which few reasonable people, let alone our students, wish to return. However, few can pretend that, as much as history changes, it stays the same. Many commentators have argued that threats to democracy today are as serious as they were in Churchill's time.

The cost of freedom

Vladimir Putin's unrelenting and devastating assault on Ukraine represents one such menace. A major lesson to be drawn from envisioning a Churchillian rhetoric for this conflict is that speakers must unreservedly and vividly describe how the Russians are — using a fresh image suited to the conflict — imposing another “iron curtain” on a free people and make it unambiguously clear that speakers and the nations they represent stand with those resisting oppression.

Advertise with us

Perhaps the most important lesson of Churchill’s “Iron Curtain” speech is how it unapologetically evoked common themes once shared by all great democratic orators. One in particular, the understanding that freedom is hard to gain but always at risk of being lost, and thus must always be defended, sometimes at great cost.

Eleven years later, Gov. Ronald Reagan put it this way in his 1967 inaugural address as governor of California: “Freedom is a fragile thing and it's never more than one generation away from extinction. It is not ours by way of inheritance,” but “must be fought for and defended constantly by each generation.”

Kenneth Zagacki is a professor of communication at North Carolina State University. Richard Cherwitz is professor emeritus at the University of Texas at Austin. Their previous article was “The world would be safer if Donald Trump talked like John F. Kennedy.”