Sometimes really dumb ideas never die. When some people can profit from them, they will be resurrected and recycled. Take missile defense, for example.

Being safe from an enemy attack is something anyone would want, especially given the devastation nuclear weapons cause. Any American born after August 29, 1949 has not spent one minute of their lives free from the nuclear threat. That is the day the Soviet Union detonated its first nuclear bomb. And that threat is never going to be eliminated, regardless of what the politicians say.

That reality does not slow down the fearmongers for a minute.

It didn’t work then

Take for instance a bizarre video posted in June by the Director of National Intelligence, Tulsi Gabbard. In it, she said she had visited Hiroshima and was deeply moved by the fact that 300,000 people died after the U.S. dropped an atomic bomb on that Japanese city.

Advertise with us

Using a figure for the death toll that is over twice what other estimates are wasn’t enough. She stoked more fear by claiming we are “closer to the brink of nuclear annihilation than ever before.” Then she added, “political elite and warmongers are carelessly fomenting fear and tensions between nuclear powers.”

Gabbard’s pitch could have been just another of her attempts to see Ukraine abandoned and left to Putin. But it also sounded like she was trying to please her boss by indirectly praising his resurrection of the idea of missile defense.

The hope for finding a way to shoot down enemy missiles began during World War II, as unstoppable German V-2 rockets killed thousands of people in England. After the Cold War began, efforts were made to come up with interceptor rockets. None of them offered more than very limited protection.

Fast forward to 1983, when President Reagan proposed the Strategic Defense Initiative, which quickly acquired the nickname “Star Wars.” He claimed new technologies could create a multi-layered shield that would include space-based weapons capable of tracking, intercepting, and destroying ballistic missiles.

Part of SDI was a project called “Brilliant Pebbles.” It was a plan to put thousands of small, weaponized satellites into orbit and let them autonomously detect the launch of Soviet missiles and shoot them down.

Advertise with us

Despite spending what would be over $800 million today, Brilliant Pebbles went nowhere. The technological challenges were insurmountable, the costs too high, the end of the Cold War reduced the concern about an attack, and there were few credible scientists who thought the system had any chance of ever meeting its goals.

It won’t work now

Now this same idea is back and sounding just like it did 40 years ago. President Trump’s new executive order directed the Pentagon to develop and deploy an “Iron Dome,” thus “forever ending the missile threat to the America homeland.” Using language that seems cribbed from Reagan’s initiative, he ordered the creation of a system that will protect against any aerial attack from any foreign country.

He claimed it will be ready before he leaves office and only cost a $175 billion. It might even be less. Trump also said Canada wants in, but he intends to charge them $61 billion to join. It seems no one told him the system can’t be effective without basing parts of it in our northern neighbor’s territory.

None of this militaristic fantasy is even remotely possible. The technology required is and always will be somewhere in the future. Such an extensive system would cost many trillions of dollars.

One study by the American Physical Society estimates that 16,000 interceptors would be required to counter a salvo of just ten North Korean rockets. Russia and China have hundreds of them. Any system America constructed could easily be overwhelmed. And it will set off an arms race in space making us far less safe.

Advertise with us

Trump was apparently inspired by Israel’s Iron Dome, but that system only protects against short to intermediate range missiles, not the intercontinental kind. And it is not foolproof. Between June 13th and 23rd, Iran launched 532 unsophisticated ballistic missiles at Israel. Thirty-five of them got through, killing 28 people.

Additional proof that missile defense is a dumb idea is that the rightwing Heritage Foundation never gave up on SDI. In 2009, it put out a video entitled “33 Minutes,” named for the time a Russian missile would take to reach the U.S., that was full of bogus claims and dubious endorsers. Its Project 2025, the plan to dismantle the U.S. government being implemented by Trump, insists that missile defense must be a top priority.

Shilling for the industrial-military complex that President Eisenhower warned us about has always been part of Heritage’s business model. That complex is not small. When the Pentagon solicited ideas from companies interested in Iron Dome in February, they got 360 proposals.

But it will squander billions

Reagan claimed SDI could make nuclear weapons “impotent and obsolete” and free the world from the threat of nuclear war. Does anyone really think that Putin and Xi will go along and trust in America’s benevolence? Or will they do whatever is necessary to overcome any defense America puts up?

So, while an estimated 51,000 Americans will die each year because of the loss of healthcare thanks to the One Big Beautiful Bill, hundreds of billions will be squandered on a system that will never save a single life.

Dennis Jett, former American ambassador to Mozambique and Peru, was also a professor of international affairs at Penn State University. He writes for the Post-Gazette every other Friday. His previous article was “Pennsylvania should become part of Canada.”