About a dozen years ago, I got into an intense argument with a British friend who insisted that the American “melting pot” approach to the immigrant experience demeans and oppresses pliable immigrants.

If the test of a good friendship is the ability to emerge from arguments with the relationship intact, he was not a good friend. Why? This guy disparaged not only my country, but also my parents, their courage and sacrifices.

My parents’ English

For millions of Americans, the debate over installing English as our national language strikes close to home. Many of us with parents whose primary language was other than English harbor memories of how our families adjusted to life outside the home where English was the language of choice. This was the melting pot in action.

My parents primarily spoke Greek at home. My mother and father varied in their fluency in English. My mother, whose formal education stopped with eighth grade when the Great Depression arrived in 1929, was adept at English and spoke without an accent.

Advertise with us

For my father, who was older and who immigrated to this country following service in the Greek army in World War I, mastery of English was more difficult. He could run his diner while speaking some English with his customers. But it was hard for him to conduct sustained conversations solely in English. Greek was his default language.

We lived in a community with many immigrant families. My mother described my friends generically as “American friends”. The English language and sports were the common bonds among boys from Polish, Italian, Lebanese, Greek and other ethnic families. I thus developed English as my own default language.

It’s clear what my parents would think about the debate over English as the national language. They believed that English was already the national language and made damn sure that I learned it. My name in Greek is Panayoti, but they named me Peter.

Their role as immigrant parents, as they saw it, was to cause us to assimilate into the broader culture, while retaining aspects of their heritage. The Greek Orthodox Church was a big part of that heritage.

They thus viewed themselves as a bridge between their own dangerous and difficult past and their children’s aspirationally bright future. They were practical people. What was the point of coming to America if your kids aren’t primed to succeed in it? They understood that mastery of English is a gating item for American success.

Advertise with us

Thanks to my parents, our family was the apotheosis of the American melting pot.

Britain’s failure

Remember my British antagonist? He thought it better that our country adopt the British “salad bowl” approach to immigration. No melting. Tomatoes remain tomatoes through the generations.

This approach has failed in Britain. Celebrations in the streets of English cities began on the night of the Hamas massacre on October 7, 2023, and massive pro-Hamas demonstrations have been routine ever since.

The “grooming” scandal of Pakistani men preying upon and sexually abusing young English girls is well-documented, widespread and abhorrent. There are dozens of Sharia courts in England. “Muhammad” ranks as the number one male baby name in all of England. That’s quite a salad they have there.

Former British Home Secretary, Suella Braverman, put the matter starkly: “The truth is that the Islamists, the extremists and the anti-Semites are in charge now. They have bullied the Labour Party, they have bullied our institutions, and now they have bullied our country into submission.”

Advertise with us

One wonders whether Winston Churchill’s Britain can be reclaimed. Bobby Jindal — the former Louisiana Governor, a Rhodes Scholar and himself the son of immigrants — said it best: “Immigration without assimilation is an invasion.”

The shattering irony with Britain is that this brave nation fought the monsters of World War II to keep them away from its shores and thereby kept the flame of freedom alive in Europe and the world at large. And now? To its profound detriment, Britain is being transformed by enemies that operate with the protection of its western values to which they themselves do not subscribe.

Our powerful language

There are many centrifugal forces in our own country. These are forces that seek to separate us and to devalue the traditional institutions to which we have subscribed as Americans. There is a paucity of centripetal forces to counteract this destructive trend. Language — the English language — may be the most powerful.

When Churchill inspired the British people during World War II, the American journalist Edwin R. Murrow remarked that Churchill “mobilized the English language and sent it into battle.” We must retain this capacity to inspire the American people. All of the American people.

Peter Kalis was, before his retirement, chairman and global managing partner of K&L Gates. He writes every other Wednesday. His previous article was “Donald Trump's six months report card (he gets an A).”