The Democratic party is still searching for a path forward after suffering devastating losses in the November 2024 election. Embracing socialism is not going to make the party any more appealing to those who consider themselves to be to the right of the progressive left. That is, the great majority of the electorate.
That majority does not believe that socialism will make their lives better, but the reverse. And the nomination of Zohran Mamdani as the presumptive mayor of New York City just worsens the electorate’s perception that the Democratic party is too focused on social issues such as abortion, LGBTQ, transgender rights, and climate change and that the party ignores the issues more important to the majority of voters.
For example: protecting our borders, lowering the cost of living and enhancing real wage growth, reducing government regulation in our business and personal lives, balancing the federal budget so that our children and grandchildren will not be burdened with our debt and controlling medical costs. And what may be considered more niche issues, too, like providing medical care in rural areas.
Out of the wilderness
To find a way out of the political wilderness, the Democratic party needs to look back at its historical roots. The actions taken by the presidential administrations of Roosevelt, Carter, Clinton and Obama provide excellent examples of when the Democratic party focused on a more centrist approach to the issues facing our country.
It may be hard to believe, but President Barack Obama was referred to as the “deporter-in-chief” during his time in office. Obama’s deportation strategy focused on criminals and those who had recently crossed into the U.S.
He also emphasized the use of removal hearings that provided illegal immigrants with due process rights. At the same time he deemphasized the removal of illegal immigrants “who had established roots in U.S. communities.” Obama showed that being tough and fair on immigration can be a positive for the Democratic party.
During the Great Depression it became apparent that a high tariff policy was constraining the ability of the economy to grow. A high tariff policy increases the cost of living, leads to a scarcity of items that people want, constrains employment, disrupts supply chains, and leads to lower economic growth. A low tariff policy reduces the cost of living, raises the economic standard of living, and expands the ability of the economy to grow.
To mitigate the harm caused by high tariffs, President Franklin D. Roosevelt, in 1934, signed into law the Reciprocal Trade Act. This statute allowed the president to enter into reciprocal trade agreements with individual countries as a means to dramatically lower tariff rates. It also ushered in a decades-long practice of using presidential authority, by both parties, to lower tariff rates.
Of course, President Trump is now trying to completely reverse the progress made in international trade. This provides the opportunity for Democrats to strongly advocate for the party’s historic low tariff policy that will benefit the great majority of Americans.
Improving the economy
Deregulation is one of the hallmarks of Trump’s second term. While one could say he is following in the footsteps of President Ronald Reagan, it was President Jimmy Carter, not Reagan, that was the “Great Deregulator.”
During the Carter Administration, multiple statutes were enacted that focused on deregulating various sectors of the U.S. economy, including the Airline Deregulation Act of 1978, leading to lower fares and more Americans able to fly. There is no reason why the Democratic party cannot follow in Carter’s footsteps and identify those areas of administrative law where deregulation would be beneficial.
Contrary to popular belief, the Democratic party has a better record of fiscal responsibility than the Republicans. Democratic president Lyndon Johnson balanced the budget in 1969. The next President to do so, and the last, was Bill Clinton.
It began with Clinton signing into law the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1993. The law reduced the federal deficit through spending cuts and tax increases. By 1998 the government was running a surplus and it did so through 2001.
Concern for the quality of rural life is not outside the purview of the Democratic party. In 1977 President Carter signed the Rural Health Clinic Services Act.
In his words, the act corrected a “defect in our public health insurance programs by requiring that the Medicare and Medicaid programs pay for the services of physician assistants and nurse practitioners in clinics and rural areas without adequate care.” Focusing on meeting the health care needs of rural America would be a major positive for the Democratic party.
The party has time to change
For the Democratic party to find its way it must look to its historical roots formed by past Democratic administrations. There is still time to do so before the mid-term elections and especially before the Presidential election in 2028.
Once those past policies are selected for prioritization, the next step is to identify the right messenger to communicate them to the electorate. Senator Fetterman and Governor Shapiro, are you listening?
Bernard S. Sharfman is a research fellow with the Law & Economics Center at George Mason University’s Antonin Scalia Law School. The opinions expressed here do not represent the official positions of the Law & Economics Center. His previous article was “The complicated Trump tariffs will hinder more than help the economy.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.