WASHINGTON -– Deaths on Pennsylvania’s highways have started to decline again, but safety advocates worry that the progress may be short-lived.
They cite President Donald Trump’s pledge to cut federal regulations at a time when fatalities have started dropping after rising for several years.
“They definitely have a deregulatory bias in how they approach rulemaking,” said Zach Cahalan, executive director of the Truck Safety Coalition. “They’ve made public comments about it. There's also a concern that enforcement is going to be less rigorous than it has been in the past.”
Traffic deaths dropping
Preliminary figures from the National Highway Transportation Safety Administration showed a 5.9% drop in traffic fatalities in the Keystone State, from 1,139 in 2023 to 1,211 in 2024, after a 2.7% rise from 2022 to 2023.
Deaths in crashes involving large trucks also declined, from 185 in 2022 to 180 in 2023, the first drop in three years. Even then, Pennsylvania had the seventh largest number of fatalities in large truck crashes among among the 50 states
“I don’t know whether we’ll be celebrating this reversal if we don’t move forward on some of these safety measures,” veteran safety advocate Jackie Gillan said.
Read More
Highway deaths spiked during the coronavirus pandemic as fewer drivers took to the roads and those that drove fast. The number stayed high even after the economy rebounded and traffic returned to normal.
President Joe Biden and Congress responded by including new safety measures in the bipartisan infrastructure law, and the White House separately rolled out a national safety strategy to reduce fatalities.
Some of these proposals had langushed for years, such as requirements to install devices on large trucks to limit their top speed.
The National Transportation Safety Board first recommended speed limiters way back in 1995. The U.S. Department of Transportation announced in 2011 that it would look at requiring them, and proposed a rule requiring them in 2016. Then nothing until 2022, when the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration, citing the safety strategy, announced it would look at requiring speed-limiting devices in large trucks.
A safety hazard
Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy announced last week that the department would drop its proposed rule.
“Mandating speed limiters on heavy-duty trucks isn't just an inconvenience — it is a safety hazard when drivers are forced to go slower than the flow of traffic,” DOT said.
The Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association argued that the devices would make driving more dangerous, not safer.
“Forcing trucks to drive below the flow of traffic only creates more dangerous interactions between vehicles,” OOIDA President and CEO Todd Spencer said. “It turns our highways into obstacle courses, especially for passenger vehicles. The unintended consequences of this regulation would be deadly.”
Cahalan argued that not having speed limiters in place leads to more crashes.
“Trucks that use speed limiters are in 50% fewer crashes than those that don’t,” Cahalan said. “DOT’s decision to withdraw speed limit rules that were poised to save thousands of lives puts everyone on the roads at greater risk.”
DOT remains under a congressional mandate to issue rules requiring automatic emergency braking systems on large trucks. That’s still under consideration, but proponents wonder what the final rule will look like — or when it will be released.
“The biggest safety advance out there right now is AEB,” said Peter Kurdock, general counsel for Advocates for Highway and Auto Safety. “That’s just sitting there unfinished. We have not gotten any indication when they plan to finish it. Certainly, all the indications we’ve gotten from the administration is that their focus is on deregulation, not regulation.”
The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration estimated that the proposed rule would prevent more than 19,000 crashes, save 155 lives, and prevent 8,814 injuries every year.
Calahan said he believed the administration was in no hurry to move ahead, though.
“They can't withdraw it but they could weaken it, they could drag their feet,” he said. “Those are certainly valid concerns. AEB is a game changer. There is no proven technology that's going to save more lives or reduce more injuries than this. It is the biggest, most consequential safety rule for large trucks in decades.”
A place to rest
Still, one safety proposal embraced by both industry and safety advocates is part of the Trump administration’s transportation agenda: More truck parking.
DOT said it would provide more than $275 million for new parking spaces and provide additional grants to build even more.
Federal regulations allow truckers to drive up to 11 hours during a 14-hour window, and an additional two hours due to bad weather or something unforeseen such as a major crash. Then they have to pull off the road and rest.
DOT said 40% of truck drivers spend more than an hour a day looking for a place to safely pull over and rest for the night before they reach the number of hours they’re allowed to be on the road. The industry said there is only one parking space for every 11 trucks on the road.
Truck drivers listed the lack of parking as second to only the economy in the American Transportation Research Institute’s 2023 annual industry survey. More than three-quarters of truck drivers said they’ve had problems in the past year trying to find a safe location to rest at the end of their workday.
Jonathan D. Salant has covered Washington for almost four decades, including for the Post-Gazette. He is a former National Press Club president and a member of the Society of Professional Journalists D.C. chapter's Journalism Hall of Fame. He writes every other Friday. His previous article was “New presidential term, same old budget cuts.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.