The weather isn’t the only thing heating up this May. Negotiations are underway for Pennsylvania’s Fiscal Year 2025­­­–26 state budget. These negotiations determine how Pennsylvania uses the dollars in its General Fund, the state’s version of a checking account.

Most state revenue flows into the General Fund, and most state spending comes from it, making budget negotiations an annual, and inevitably contentious, highlight of the year in Harrisburg. But this annual tradition, which always results in increased spending, has pushed Pennsylvania into a fiscally untenable situation.

More than taxpayers can pay

Since 2019, state spending has increased by over 35%, far outpacing inflation, personal income growth, and population growth — key economic indicators measuring taxpayers’ ability to pay for spending increases. Last year, lawmakers passed a $47.6 billion General Fund budget, creating a $3.6 billion budget deficit.

This deficit overshadows the current negotiations. Gov. Josh Shapiro’s budget proposal, unveiled in February, would increase spending by 8.1%, to $51.7 billion. If enacted, his proposal would increase the budget deficit to $4.8 billion, drain the General Fund balance, and require multibillion-dollar tax hikes on working families in the coming years.

Advertise with us

Rather than continuing with “business as usual” spending increases, lawmakers should address Pennsylvania’s fiscal woes head-on. Without substantial spending restraint, the budget deficit will continue to grow, necessitating significant tax increases.

To do this, lawmakers must make structural reforms to how Pennsylvania spends money. Since 2019, state spending on Medical Assistance, Long-Term Living, and public education accounts for 63% of all spending increases.

Entitlement reforms can help rein in this spending. Lawmakers must require employment for healthy, childless, working-age adults receiving Medicaid benefits. Pennsylvania enrolls more than 800,000 healthy adults in its Medicaid program, diverting valuable resources from those who need the most help: low-income children, seniors, the disabled, and pregnant women. As Pennsylvania ages, more and more individuals will need to access these benefits.

Research suggests that work requirements foster economic independence. The Foundation for Government Accountability (FGA) found that Medicaid work requirements help healthy, able-bodied, childless adults become self-sufficient by gaining meaningful employment, raising their incomes, and transitioning away from public support. When states like Tennessee and Arkansas implemented similar work requirements, they experienced immediate expansions in labor force participation, employment, and private health care coverage.

Though Medicaid is a polarizing issue, lawmakers can rest assured that the public is eager for reform. Recent polling shows that over 80% of Pennsylvania voters support work requirements.

Advertise with us

Expensive education

Education is also a big-ticket line item in the state budget. Pennsylvania public schools spend more than $23,000 per student, the seventh-highest nationally and about $4,100 more than the national average. Though education funding has increased, performance still lags. About seven in ten Pennsylvania eighth graders are not proficient at math and cannot read at grade level.

To control education costs and improve academic performance, lawmakers should directly fund students, not systems. Programs like the Pennsylvania Award for Student Success, also known as Lifeline Scholarships, will provide students trapped in underperforming schools with the funding they need to get the great education they deserve.

These scholarships would also control costs without cutting existing public education funding. Considering the scholarship values ($5,000 for K–8 students, $10,000 for 9–12, and $15,000 for special-needs students), these scholarships provide a significant discount compared to current per-pupil spending.

While education and human services costs make up a significant portion of state expenses, other opportunities exist to control spending and cut costs. For example, lawmakers must resist the pleas to bail out mass transit agencies like the Southeastern Pennsylvania Transportation Authority (SEPTA). Rather than writing a multimillion-dollar, no-strings-attached check to SEPTA, legislators must consider more cost-effective measures, such as vouchers for low-income bus and train riders to offset fare increases.

Additionally, lawmakers should opt for broad-based tax and regulatory relief. Keeping the current corporate net income tax reduction on schedule is key, as Pennsylvania still has one of the nation’s highest corporate net income tax rates. Meanwhile, states like North Carolina, which drastically cut their corporate income tax rate in 2016, have earned the status of “the stronger-performing state economies in the past few years,” according to the Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond.

Advertise with us

Making Pennsylvania work

Along with protecting the Rainy Day Fund to prevent tax hikes during economic emergencies, these measures will ensure that Pennsylvania is an attractive and affordable place to live, work, run a business, and raise a family.

The status quo is not working. Years of excessive spending growth created a $3.6 billion budget deficit, and Pennsylvania’s working families now stare down the barrel of multibillion-dollar tax hikes. As budget negotiations continue, confronting Pennsylvania’s spending problems is the only way to climb out of the state’s fiscal hole.

Andrew Holman is a policy analyst with the Commonwealth Foundation. His previous article was “Union political spending doesn't represent all their members.”