Pittsburgh has marked a significant but under-appreciated milestone — the end of major tent encampments downtown. Consider where the city stood just three years ago.

Tent encampments had spread across the city, lining the Allegheny riverfront, overtaking the Mon Wharf, and encroaching on key boulevards, bike trails and public spaces in the Golden Triangle.

Encampments placed the harsh realities of street life squarely in the public eye. Local media chronicled this issue, already a familiar story in many American cities. Pittsburgh was not alone in facing this challenge.

What set Pittsburgh apart is how it responded.

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh’s response

Initially, the city reacted slowly, frustrating many stakeholders. But with growing resolve over the past 18 months, the city restricted camping. This culminated in February when city and county officials announced the closure of downtown’s last major encampment.

That milestone was remarkable. By upholding camping restrictions, Pittsburgh has restored public access to its most iconic spaces.

This was about more than appearances. Encampments had become centers of open drug use and trafficking. Syringes and drug debris littered the ground. Police operations confirmed what downtown workers and trail users already suspected: these sites were more than makeshift shelters. They put everyone, including their residents, at risk. Many Pittsburghers avoided using certain trails, concerned for their safety.

But today, the heart of our region looks dramatically better. And much of this progress comes down to leadership and coordination.

Mayor Ed Gainey made downtown’s recovery a regional priority, increasing police presence and tightening enforcement of the city’s camping policy. At the same time, County Executive Sara Innamorato expanded the region’s shelter capacity and increased the supply of supportive housing.

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh’s powers

The city exercised its public safety powers decisively, and the county delivered essential services. That division of labor worked — and worked well.

But that wasn’t all it took. The mayor conferred regularly with downtown stakeholders. Every Tuesday, key leaders, from public safety to human services, still meet to troubleshoot these issues. This momentum must not be lost, regardless of who steps into key roles next.

Pittsburgh’s strategy was also thoughtful and phased. Encampments weren’t just swept aside. They were cleared gradually, in tandem with the creation of real housing alternatives. As new shelter beds and supportive services came online, outreach teams returned to encampments with credible options.

This ensured that enforcement wasn’t just firm — it was fair, offering people a way forward before dismantling the camps. Pittsburgh showed that resolve and compassion are not mutually exclusive; in fact, they’re most effective when combined.

The results are clear. While some encampments persist elsewhere, they no longer dominate downtown. Everyone benefits. Families can once again enjoy Pittsburgh’s riverfronts and trails. And many who once occupied tents now have safer, more stable places to live.

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh’s example

Other cities might take note. Across the country, many urban areas have faltered, paralyzed by political gridlock or caught between extremes of neglect and overreach. Pittsburgh’s approach — grounded in clear rules, consistent enforcement and coordinated care — offers a viable model.

Yet this progress must be safeguarded. Tents will reappear, seasonally, or when conditions shift. Pittsburgh cannot afford to let these gains slip away. This effort remains a work in progress. A steady commitment to keeping public spaces safe for all will allow the city to thrive.

Bill Benter is a downtown business owner and the president of the Benter Foundation.