WASHINGTON — Whether or not President Donald Trump and congressional Republicans can pass their massive tax bill comes down to four letters: S-A-L-T. That’s shorthand for the federal deduction for state and local taxes, which had been part of the Internal Revenue Service code dating back to the first income tax, but was capped at $10,000 in the 2017 tax law that Trump now is trying to renew and expand.
The SALT deduction cap, along with many other provisions that were made temporary in the first Trump tax law, expires this year. And a number of Republicans from states hardest hit by the law’s limits on deducting state and local taxes have threatened to oppose the new tax bill unless it either removes or raises the $10,000 cap.
Even the president has called for restoring at least part of the tax break he took away eight years ago.
“Something’s going to happen with SALT,” said Rep. Jeff Van Drew, R-N.J.
Now these Republicans have clout
Those pro-SALT Republicans have something they lacked in 2017: clout. Even with 12 House Republicans voting no, the last Trump tax legislation passed with votes to spare. But now only four GOP no votes would be enough to scuttle the president’s “one big beautiful bill,” the top legislative priority of his second term in the White House.
The question is whether pro-SALT Republicans are willing to use that clout.
Read More
“I don’t know how they can show their faces back in their districts if they don’t get SALT relief,” said New Jersey Democratic Rep. Josh Gottheimer, co-chair of the bipartisan Congressional SALT Caucus.
It’s not that simple, though. Repealing the cap would add $1.2 billion to the federal debt over 10 years, according to the Committee for a Responsible Budget. Paying for that means cutting spending more, curbing other tax breaks, or increasing the federal debt. So even if you win the votes of pro-SALT Republicans, four other GOP lawmakers looking to shrink rather than increase the debt could kill the tax bill. And this is even before it gets to the Senate.
The SALT deduction had three things that made it a juicy target for Republicans in 2017.
First, it cost the U.S. Treasury $100 billion a year, so capping it allowed lawmakers to fund other tax breaks.
Second, a SALT cap affected the wealthiest taxpayers the most, refuting the Democratic argument that the tax bill favored the rich.
Third, it targeted high-tax, Democratic-run states the hardest and could be a cudgel to force social spending cuts since wealthier taxpayers no longer could offset state tax increases with a larger federal tax deduction.
But the cap wound up ensnaring millions of middle-class homeowners even as the 2017 tax bill, according to the Tax Policy Center, gave almost two-thirds of its benefits to the wealthiest 20%.
In Pennsylvania, 1.8 million households -- 29% of taxpayers -- used the SALT deduction before it was capped, a higher percentage than 27 other states, according to the National Association of Realtors. More than half, 53%, earned $100,000 or less.
In addition, a study by the State University of New York’s Rockefeller Institute of Government showed that the states benefitting the most from the SALT deduction subsidized low-tax red states.
New Jersey and New York received a combined $39 billion less from the federal government than their residents paid in taxes to Washington in federal fiscal year 2022.
Meanwhile, Louisiana, home state of House Speaker Mike Johnson and Majority Leader Steve Scalise, got $33 billion more from Washington than its residents paid in federal taxes. (Pennsylvania received $50.2 billion more.)
Unpopular legislation
The tax law proved to be so unpopular that Democrats captured 41 Republican-held House seats in the next midterm elections --- 14 of them in high-tax New Jersey, New York and California -- and won the majority. One of the Democratic district flippers was Van Drew, though he switched parties after voting against impeaching Trump.
Democrats also won three GOP-held seats in Pennsylvania, though the state’s court-ordered redistricting also played a major role.
“If they pass a tax bill without SALT relief, it’s obviously going to kill them again,” said former Democratic Rep. Tom Malinowski of New Jersey, who captured a Republican-held district in 2018.
Still, the passage of time hasn’t dimmed Republicans’ ardor for renewing the tax bill and even expanding it, though the new legislation would add trillions of dollars of red ink and give the biggest benefits to the richest taxpayers, according to independent studies.
"In the coming weeks and months, we will pass the largest tax cuts in American History—and that will include No Tax on Tips, NO Tax on Social Security, and No Tax on Overtime. It's called the one big beautiful bill,” Trump said last week on X.
But nothing will happen without addressing SALT.
“If I had my way, there wouldn't be such a thing as a SALT deduction,” House Appropriations Committee Chair Tom Cole of Oklahoma said. “Having said that, if I was from New York, California, or New Jersey, I would see the world a little differently. And I understand they have legitimate needs to be accommodated. …If it can produce the votes we need to pass the bill, I can certainly vote for it.”
Jonathan D. Salant has covered Washington for almost four decades, including as assistant managing editor, politics, for the Post-Gazette. He is a former National Press Club president and a member of the Society of Professional Journalists D.C. chapter's Journalism Hall of Fame. He will be writing every other Friday. His previous article was “Debate over noncitizen voting mirrors Pittsburgh synagogue shooter's rhetoric.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.