WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump, through an executive order, and House Republicans, through legislation, have moved this year to enact new rules designed to prevent noncitizens from voting in U.S. elections.
Arguments in favor of the new rules, however, ignore three things:
1. It’s already illegal for noncitizens to vote.
Congress enacted the Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act in 1996, which said noncitizens who register or vote could be fined, imprisoned or deported.
2. Noncitizen voting rarely happens.
A study by Brennan Center for Justice at New York University’s School of Law found that of 23.5 million votes overseen by election officials in the 2016 elections, just 30 votes might have been cast by noncitizens. That comes out to 0.0001% of the votes cast.
Read More
Pennsylvania officials found 544 votes cast by noncitizens from 2000 through 2017 — 0.0005% of the 93 million overall votes — according to NPR. And the Post-Gazette reported in September 2017 that three ineligible legal immigrants had voted in the 2016 presidential election — 0.00046% of the more than 650,000 people in Allegheny County who voted then.
3. The proposals could prevent millions of legal voters from casting ballots.
A different Brennan Center study found that 21.3 million Americans couldn’t quickly get their hands on their needed documents, including 3.8 million whose papers were lost, stolen or destroyed.
Those provisions disproportionately affected voters of color, the Brennan Center said. While a little over 8% of white American citizens didn’t have the documents readily available, that number jumped to close to 11% for citizens of color.
Trump’s mind
The issue of noncitizen voting has been on Trump’s mind since he was elected president in 2016 and claimed that he really won the popular vote over Hillary Clinton because millions of noncitizens voted illegally. Trump never produced evidence to back up his assertions, even creating a voter fraud commission that disbanded without finding any proof.
The president last fall made continued to claim without evidence that the 2020 election was stolen from him, and House Republicans last fall responded with the new bill, the Safeguard American Voter Eligibility (SAVE) Act, even though noncitizen voting already is illegal. Trump told House Republicans to shut down the government rather than pass a spending bill without including the SAVE Act, but they refused to go along.
The Republican-led House passed the bill again this spring, also primarily along party lines. All three Western Pennsylvania Republicans co-sponsored the measure.
“This is a cornerstone of our democracy,” said Rep. Mike Kelly, R-Butler. “American citizens — and only American citizens — should decide American elections."
Others supporting the legislation, however, cite the once-fringe great replacement theory, which contends there is an effort to illegally bring in millions of people of color to outvote the white population.
“What we’re seeing is the mainstreaming of conspiracy theories,” said Pamela Nadell, director of the Jewish Studies Program at American University.
Many supporters of this theory are blaming Democrats or Jews. That’s what the neo-Nazis and white supremacists marching in Charlottesville, Va., in 2017 meant when they chanted, “Jews will not replace us.”
Pittsburgh shooting
That’s also the rhetoric that led to Robert Bowers’ attack on a Pittsburgh synagogue in 2018, killing 11 worshippers, according to both the Anti-Defamation League and the Global Project Against Hate and Extremism.
“It absolutely contributed to the Tree of Life shooting,” said Halie Soifer, CEO of the Jewish Democratic Council of America. “It’s an incredibly dangerous and antisemitic ideology that has been fully embraced by right-wing extremists and has found its way into the rhetoric of mainstream Republicans. It has become a MAGA talking point.”
Bowers had targeted the Hebrew Immigrant Aid Society on the alt-right social media website Gab shortly before beginning the massacre. "HIAS likes to bring invaders in that kill our people,” he wrote. “I can't sit by and watch my people get slaughtered. Screw your optics, I'm going in.”
Right-wing media firebrand Tucker Carlson, whom the ADL calls a “key promoter” of “the racist, antisemitic and xenophobic conspiracy,” received one of the loudest applause of any speaker during his prime-time appearance at the Republican National Convention in Milwaukee last July. GOP vice-presidential nominee JD Vance later joined him at an event in Hershey during the fall campaign
And more recently, entrepreneur Elon Musk, who is playing an outsized role in the new Trump administration, reported that he and his Department of Government Efficiency found proof of massive voting by noncitizens. But Factcheck.org said Musk didn’t offer evidence to back up his claims.
The issue of noncitizen voting, meanwhile, isn’t going away.
While Democratic Party leaders and several voting rights groups try to overturn Trump’s executive order in federal court — parts of which were blocked on Thursday — congressional Republicans continue to push for their bill.
“The fact that Democrats are all in on letting illegal immigrants sway our elections is outrageous,” Mike Marinella, a spokesman for the House GOP’s political arm, said just last week.
Jonathan D. Salant has covered Washington for almost four decades, including as assistant managing editor, politics, for the Post-Gazette. He is a former National Press Club president and a member of the Society of Professional Journalists D.C. chapter's Journalism Hall of Fame. He will be writing every other Friday. His previous article was “Why there won't be a competitive U.S. House race in Western Pa. next year.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.