As I’ve been a teacher and school administrator for the past 35 years, it might surprise you that I support dramatically reducing the scope of the Federal Department of Education. My reasons are not ideological. They're practical.
The closer decisions are made to the students they affect, the more responsive and effective those decisions tend to be. When the Department of Education was established in 1979, its mission was to improve outcomes and ensure equal access for all students.
More than four decades and billions of dollars later, it is hard to argue that federal oversight has delivered on that promise.
Stagnant results
Despite ever-increasing expenditures, student achievement has remained stagnant. According to the National Assessment of Educational Progress, often referred to as the Nation’s Report Card, math and reading scores for 13-year-olds are now at their lowest levels in decades. Meanwhile, countries with more decentralized education systems frequently outperform American students in key areas like literacy, math and science.
In fiscal year 2024, the Department of Education spent an estimated $268 billion. Many of the federally funded programs included in that budget, such as Title I, IDEA, and school nutrition initiatives, play an important role in serving students and schools.
However, these programs often come with extensive reporting requirements, audits, and other administrative demands that place a heavy burden on local school districts. The cost of compliance is significant and multifaceted, encompassing personnel, training, administration, legal fees, and the expense of tracking data to meet federal funding mandates. With so many dollars entangled in bureaucracy, local educators are left with less flexibility and fewer resources to meet the actual needs of their students.
Imagine if even a portion of that money were returned directly to local districts without federal strings attached. We could expand developmental programs, special education services, and career and technical initiatives that are tailored to local communities.
Rural schools face different challenges than urban ones. Local control allows school leaders to respond with strategies that fit their students, not a one-size-fits-all approach dictated by distant policymakers.
The federal role
This is not to say the federal government has no role in education. Civil rights protections must be upheld. Under-resourced districts deserve support. Oversight of student loans and national education data collection are also important. But these responsibilities do not require a massive bureaucracy. They can be managed by streamlined, efficient agencies.
One of the Department’s most frequently cited goals is promoting equity. But we need to ask whether equity is better achieved through federal mandates or by empowering local communities to address their unique challenges. Despite decades of federal involvement, achievement gaps persist. In many cases, Washington’s rules limit schools’ ability to innovate or adapt.
Ronald Reagan once said, “Government is not the solution to our problem; government is the problem.” That is not always true, but when it comes to education, there is wisdom in his words. A top-heavy federal system has made it harder for schools to focus on what matters most: teaching students.
This is not a partisan issue. Across the country, parents, teachers, and school leaders, both Republicans and Democrats, want greater autonomy. They want less time spent on paperwork and more time focused on students. They want the freedom to innovate without being burdened by federal red tape.
Real progress
The federal government should safeguard rights and ensure basic accountability. But real progress will come from local leadership. Rethinking the role of the Department of Education offers an opportunity to strengthen our schools. By reducing its scope and restoring control to states and communities, we can build an education system that better serves America’s students.
America’s educational system needs to move beyond a top-down model and toward one that trusts local decision-making, fosters innovation, and restores confidence in American education.
Christopher Brueningsen retired from The Kiski School in Westmoreland County in June 2024 after serving 22 years as Head of School.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.