We take for granted that when we vote as citizens, we do so in a way that only the individual voter knows for whom their votes were cast. Reasons for that are to prevent vote-selling, and to remove fears of intimidation or retribution.
Yet when the people we choose to represent us in Congress vote, it is nearly universally accepted that they do so in the public eye. The rationale is that their constituents have a right to know how the people they send to Congress vote on the issues they care about.
All very well and good — but only if you assume that the people elected are really voting in the interests of the people who elected them. We can't.
Money is cancer
Enter the role of money in U.S. politics, grown like a cancer, courtesy of a Supreme Court that has essentially eliminated any limits on campaign financing and spending, and opened the floodgates for dozens of state laws that have made voting more difficult for large segments of our population.
It should be clear by now that candidates know it's not the voters they have to please, it's the funders who will help them get enough votes to be elected. That is what Lawrence Lessig, in his book “Republic, Lost: How Money Corrupts Congress — and a Plan to Stop It,” has described as dependence corruption.
Somewhat surprisingly, to me at least, is that the subject of voting by secret ballot in the U.S. Congress has been rarely brought up, even though rules provide for some exceptions. So why shouldn't Congress vote by secret ballot? Fears of vote-selling, and fears of retribution also apply when it comes to voting in Congress.
That is not to say that the proceedings of Congress should be in secret. With certain exceptions, open debate and deliberation by Congress should be required.
Depending on whom you ask, current approval ratings of Congress range from mid-20%, and disapproval ratings tend to be over 50%, with a few exceptions. Gallup has figures of under 20% approval and over 70% disapproval. These ratings belie the simplistic concept that if you don't like what your representatives in Congress are doing, you can vote them out.
If the funders of political campaigns can't verify the return on their investment, they would likely give less and spend less for campaigns. Lobbyists would spend less time and money as well. Candidates would likely be spending more time listening to and interacting with their voter-constituents, and less time with lobbyists and on the phone with campaign funders.
Which is how a democratic republic is supposed to work.
Voting for funding
Stephanie Grace of the New Orleans Advocate has described the role reversal of Senators Bill Cassidy (who voted to convict in the Senate trial of impeachment) and Mitch McConnell (who did not) since the 2021 impeachment trial.
Cassidy's recently voted to confirm RFK, Jr. Cassidy is a physician and should know better, just as 18,000 physicians did in signing a letter condemning the nomination. McConnell voted no.
The difference is readily explained if you consider that Cassidy intends to run for reelection and McConnell will not. Everyone knows that to win elections you have to have the support of party leadership and of donors. Liz Cheney doesn't have to tell you that.
If the voting for confirmation were by secret ballot, Cassidy would almost certainly have voted not to confirm RFK, Jr., and perhaps other nominees as well. And it is not unlikely that McConnell and enough other senators would have voted to convict in the 2021 impeachment trial.
I have little doubt — well, maybe more than a little since some members of Congress have substantial wealth and outside income — that a Congress voting by secret ballot would enact sensible, responsible, and direly needed tax reform. I think that would include a wealth tax and a top income bracket of 91% like we had in the 1950s, closure of loopholes and crackdown on offshore asset-protection and tax evasion or avoidance schemes.
This issue is exceedingly important because most economists and political scientists agree that the enlarging wealth gap in the U.S. (and elsewhere) poses a real threat to democracy — something that is proving to be true in real time.
Start with a straw vote
How do we get to secret ballots in Congress? Perhaps such a rule is too much to achieve under current rules, i.e., open vote/roll-call vote, for reasons that should be obvious.
So I propose straw votes by secret ballot in the House and Senate to see what members of Congress really think about the issue of secret ballots on legislative proposals so they won't be under the eye of lobbyists and potential donors; and that the results of those votes be made public.
If you think that's a challenge, it is. Let's see.
Bruce Wilder is a former long-time resident of Oakland and a graduate of the University of Pittsburgh School of Law. His previous article was “Republicans want America to evade accountability.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.