The tax cuts passed in 2017 are due to expire. The federal government is running significant deficits. What can be done?

President Trump likes tariffs. He sees them as a generator of tax revenue. In 2019 he imposed significant tariffs on China.

In a Tweet on May 8, 2019, he claimed “China has just informed us that they (Vice-Premier) are now coming to the U.S. to make a deal. We’ll see, but I am very happy with over $100 Billion a year in Tariffs filling U.S. coffers ... great for U.S., not good for China!” He was sure then that the revenue from those tariffs came out of the pockets of the Chinese.

He likes tariffs even more now.

Advertise with us

Trump’s tariff hopes

In his inaugural address, President Trump said, “Instead of taxing our citizens to enrich other countries, we will tariff and tax foreign countries to enrich our citizens ... It will be massive amounts of money pouring into our Treasury coming from foreign sources.”

Peter Navarro, the White House Counselor for Trade and Manufacturing, supports the view that when tariffs are imposed, it is the exporter who bears the cost of the tariff by reducing their prices. This reflects his belief that because the U.S. is the largest market in the world economy, an exporter cannot afford to see a significant reduction in its sales to the United States.

In an interview on CNBC, Navarro claimed that was what happened in 2018–19, when the first Trump administration raised tariffs on imported goods from China. Unfortunately, that is not what happened.

Harvard Business School professor Alberto Cavallo and his associates conducted a careful study of what happened to prices charged by exporters to importers and the prices paid by consumers of the goods imported from China that were subject to those tariffs. They found “that the tariffs were almost fully passed through to total prices paid by importers.”

That is, American importers and their customers together bore the full burden of the cost of the tariff. While the tariffs imposed in the first Trump Administration were more limited that the tariffs now being contemplated, the experience of those tariffs does not support the hope that more tariffs will produce a bonanza of tax revenue that will be paid by foreigners through reductions in the prices they charge American importers.

Advertise with us

The common folk

If, as the evidence suggests, the cost of tariffs will be borne by Americans, then the use of tariffs as a source of revenue is a tax policy. Do Americans wish to see this as a way to keep in place the reductions in tax rates passed in 2017 that are due to expire? Or would they prefer to increase the tax rates on high income individuals to their pre-2017 level?

Given that the burden of the tariffs will be spread over commodities that every American buys, while an increase in income tax rate on high income individuals will affect relatively few people, It’s doubtful that most people would choose to pay the tariffs.

In that CNBC interview Mr. Navarro noted that in the 19th century the United States relied almost exclusively on tariffs as a source of revenue for the federal government and that America became an economic power during that time. He suggested that the President’s proposals to expand tariffs as a source of tax revenue would “take us back to the future.”

What Mr. Navarro neglects to mention is that in those “good old days,” people were well aware that it was Americans who were bearing the cost of those tariffs. They hurt when they went to buy goods.

Exporters, like farmers, hurt because tariffs reduced the dollars foreigners could earn. So they bought less of the product exporters could sell.

Advertise with us

Common folk believed that the tariffs benefited the robber barons, not them. They lived through the “Gilded Age” and they fought for the substitution of an income tax for tariffs as the principal source of the federal government’s revenue.

Burdening consumers

It took a long fight, but in 1913 the 16th Amendment to the Constitution, allowing for the use of an income tax, was passed. The income tax soon replaced tariffs as the principal source of federal revenue.

The distribution of wealth and income is once again highly skewed in favor of the wealthiest 1% of our population. Do we really want to increase the tax burden of ordinary consumers in order to save a tax cut that predominately benefits the richest segment of our population?

Jack Ochs is professor of economics, emeritus, at the University of Pittsburgh: jochs@pitt.edu. He lives in Point Breeze.