One of the things that makes America great is great science, but America will not stay great unless it continues to produce great science, and great science doesn’t just happen. It requires stable, long-term effort and depends on basic scientific research whose practical value is unknown, and this requires reliable funding that only the federal government can supply.
It is not clear that the folks who are now running the White House budget office (OMB) understand this.
Reduced support
In the last few days, they have taken steps to dramatically reduce support for leading medical research facilities all across the country. There has also been talk of asking the National Science Foundation (NSF) to make significant staff reductions.
Many of those men and women, with doctorates in science, work hard to make sure that the grants the NSF makes go to fund the best science. While its budget is just a fraction of a percent of the total federal discretionary budget, there is also a talk of making a dramatic reduction in the level of future funding.
Why is reducing funding for scientific research a mistake?
Consider the rapid development of COVID vaccines, which saved millions of American and other lives. Their development in just a few months was only possible because the companies that created them were able to build on decades of basic biological research performed by dozens of scientists.
Read More
These scientists, in the interests of advancing biological knowledge, had learned the key functions of RNA, one of the fundamental molecules of life. Using that accumulated knowledge, vaccine developers were able to figure out how to latch on to and disrupt the operation of the virus.
Public and private
Cell phones, and the global communication systems to which they are connected, offer another example. These systems are central to building and sustaining our prosperity, and to providing critical services like emergency assistance in times of need.
Just as with the COVID vaccines, the reason that high-tech Silicon Valley entrepreneurs have been able to produce these marvelous systems is that they could build upon foundations laid by decades of research. Some of this research was highly abstract and mathematical research in areas like signal processing. Other research studied basic physical and material science that made it possible to cram billions of transistors on to a single computer chip.
The list of inventions on which modern depends that began in esoteric basic research goes on and on.
The private sector is good at converting science into useful products and services. Sometimes it can also afford to make limited investments in advancing the frontiers of science.
However, if America expects to enjoy the wide benefits of science and technology, it will need to continue to use public monies to keep basic science research alive so that it can produce the knowledge that underpins our health, our prosperous way of life, and our national security.
Is the U.S. system of support for basic and medical science perfect? Of course not. A variety of improvements are possible.
For example, there may be better and more efficient ways to cover some of the indirect cost of research operations — things like the costs of laboratories, running the lights and heat, and maintaining buildings. Rather than simply slash support, the White House could switch to “problem-solving mode” and create a Presidential Task Force charged with identifying and evaluating a range of equitable and affordable alternative approaches.
There may also be better and more efficient ways to conduct the “peer reviews” that are so essential to assuring that the science we fund is the very best.
The U.S. National Academies of Science, Engineering, and Medicine could be commissioned to rapidly identify, evaluate, and recommend possible improvements. Doing that would be a much more constructive approach than simply slashing staff at federal funding agencies.
Keeping America great
Decimating the system, causing disruptions with consequences that could last for many years, will not improve how America does science. This is especially true today with China already leading the world in the quality and quantity of research output in several critical fields of science and technology, and with a variety of the world’s best scientific instrumentation now residing in China.
Sustaining high-quality science that will keep America great should not be a partisan issue. Members of the U.S. House and Senate in both parties must work together to produce more sensible and less draconian approaches to sustaining and improving high-quality U.S. science.
Granger Morgan is the Hamerschlag University Professor of Engineering at Carnegie Mellon University and a member of the US National Academy of Science and of the American Academy of Arts and Science.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.