The specter of the COVID-19 pandemic lives with all of us. This week, the memories of the people I loved who lost their lives to the virus came flooding back. My heart hurts to see Robert F. Kennedy Jr. on the cusp of being named Secretary of Health and Human Services.

He is a symbol of the drumbeat of scientific and medical misinformation that led to so many needless deaths.

Deadliest vaccine

In December 2021, RFK Jr. famously proclaimed that the COVID-19 vaccine was “the deadliest vaccine ever made.”

Just a few months ago, he stated that he knew early on that the COVID-19 vaccine was “dead in the water” because it “won’t prevent transmission.” Sometimes vaccines prevent transmission, sometimes they don’t. Judging them on this false metric undermines confidence in the vaccine’s efficacy and is highly irresponsible.

Advertise with us

On a 2021 podcast, he said that “no vaccine is safe and effective” and that people should “resist” the childhood vaccine schedule published by the Centers for Disease Control. “When I see somebody on a hiking trail carrying a little baby ... I say to him, better not get them vaccinated.”

In 1974, the World Health Organization (WHO) began its expanded program of immunization to make childhood vaccines against common pathogens available worldwide. The initial goal was to vaccinate all children against a variety of deadly infectious diseases by 1990.

In a May 2024 study published in The Lancet, researchers commemorated the 50th anniversary of the program by quantifying its effect. The results are impressive. 154 million lives were saved, including 146 million children under the age of five years and 101 million children under one year. Imagine that: 154 million lives were saved by a basic vaccination campaign opposed by RFK Jr.

The Department of Health and Human Services oversees 80,000 employees and agencies including the Food and Drug Administration, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institutes of Health, and the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services.

Firings on day one

Regarding the NIH, RFK Jr has vowed to start by firing 600 employees on day one, stating, “Let’s give infectious disease research a break for eight years.” This declaration is in the setting of a potential global bird flu pandemic and  in Kansas the largest tuberculosis outbreak in United States history.

Advertise with us

I doubt we can really trust him to lead the CDC. He will surely stack the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices with advocates who share his anti-vaccine views.

As evidenced from his confirmation hearings this week, he is also completely inexperienced regarding Medicare and Medicaid. He would not be an effective leader in optimizing or improving access to either of these programs that are essential for the healthcare of millions of elderly and underserved Americans.

We should listen to the people who know RFK Jr. and have interacted with him for years, like his cousin Caroline Kennedy. She has urged the Senate not to confirm him and candidly made his compromised character a focus of her assessment. The prospect of his leading the HHS has brought her to declare him a “predator.”

His ethics disclosure revealed that he will still be party to a lawsuit against vaccine manufacturer Merck, and get a share in the cut of settlement fees should his side win the race. Since he will be regulating Merck as HHS secretary, there is a clear conflict of interest. As Sen. Elizabeth Warren pointed out, the nominee is “cashing in” from his anti-vaccine positions.

His confirmation hearings have also not discussed his history of sexual assault, which was investigated extensively in a July 2024 Vanity Fair article. He claimed not to remember the one of the incidents described, but apologized by text to his accuser after the article was published.

Advertise with us

Impending threat

The impending threat of Robert F. Kennedy Jr. leading America’s health and research infrastructure is truly terrifying. His strong anti-vaccine positions have cost lives before and will again. He is overmatched, unqualified, unethical, morally compromised, and has an agenda completely at odds with the “good science” he purports to support.

I was heartened to learn of Sen. John Fetterman’s negative review of his performance at the confirmation hearings. We should keep the pressure on Sen. Fetterman to vote no and let Sen. Dave McCormick know we want a no vote from him as well.

Flavia Mangan Colgan, chief of staff to the lieutenant governor of Pennsylvania, Democrat Catherine Baker Knoll, from 2003-2004, has been a columnist and editorial board member for the Philadelphia Daily News and a freelance writer.