The deportations, the chaos, and the fear, have begun. We are told that immigration is a major issue of this moment and that it was central to the election of Donald Trump.
Well, no and yes.
It is not an issue we actually grapple with — discuss and debate in a serious and practical way. But it certainly did help Mr. Trump, because of the clever and ruthless way he exploited it.
A symbol and a wedge
Immigration is a symbolic issue, and a wedge issue as a symbol — like trans athletes and soldiers, and, actually, also like abortion.
We strike poses regarding these matters. We use them as rallying points, and even talismans. We do not think them through; discuss them and listen; look for ground that is both solid and common; or seek proximate remedies.
What is actually true about immigration and what would be a sane and humane public policy? Mr. Trump’s rhetoric and his policies have zero to do with those two questions.
What is true: Immigrants are not “poisoning our blood,” or “ruining our country”; they are not kidnapping pets and eating them; they are not generally criminals; criminality among immigrants, legal and illegal, is lower, statistically, than the general population;
Further: illegal immigrants are not taking our jobs (high illegal immigration and the lowest unemployment of the last 100 years have coexisted simultaneously); immigrants do jobs the rest of us will not or cannot do, like roofing and farm labor.
And finally: illegal immigrants are not “coming for the freebies” — government benefits they did not earn. The opposite is true. They pay taxes, including the highest tax, the Social Security tax, which they can never collect. In this way, they bolster SSI and help to pay down our national debt.
Robert Reich calls immigration “the secret sauce” of our economy. Immigrants help grow the economy — a more realistic type of growth than annexing foreign territories. Most immigrants, legal and illegal, as Washington Episcopal Bishop Mariann Budde had the courage to say directly to Mr. Trump, are hard workers and good neighbors.
These are facts, realities.
Mr. Trump has long engaged in intentional scapegoating of immigrants. And now he is engaged in intentionally reckless and cruel policy. The deportations were perfectly characterized by Pope Francis as “a disgrace.”
The truth: Immigrants built the nation. We periodically forget that we are all immigrants, save the Native American. Moreover, this is who we are supposed to be — a people of and for immigrants.
Sometimes we have forgotten this and bigotry has prevailed. Jews, Italians, and Irish have all been victims of prejudice and discrimination, often vile and violent, and sometimes from their immediate migratory predecessors.
Trump’s real target
And — profound irony or profound delusion — our current leading anti-immigrant politicians are themselves the children and grandchildren, and spouses and ex-spouses, of immigrants. In Trump Times, only hypocrisy can trump stupidity and only barbarism can trump hypocrisy.
What is also true:
The Biden Administration was inexcusably slow to face the border problem and a nation must be able to control its borders. This is the one truth behind all the lies that have sustained Mr. Trump for a decade.
In the end, also ironically, Joe Biden deported more people between 2021 and 2025 than Donald Trump did between 2019 and 2021. For he and his party never figured out a way, politically, to convert maximum illegal immigration to maximum legal immigration.
And Mr. Trump’s real target is legal immigration. He is now attempting to deport American citizens — sons and daughters of illegal immigrants who were born here — which is unconstitutional. (See the 14th Amendment.) The gist of a sane and humane policy:
• The border must be secure.
• But mass deportations are evil sideshows. They do not secure the border.
• Huddled masses will keep coming to the United States because there are jobs here and we have the most robust economy in the world (propaganda mythology to the contrary and wealth inequality notwithstanding).
• We should welcome most of them. We need immigrants to grow the economy. We need them for skilled labor. We need them for population growth.
• Immigrants must also do it “the right way” – legally. That’s what most legal immigrants say, and they are right.
• But that means a policy of maximum legal immigration, especially for political refugees.
• And it means a brief period of amnesty and then a “second chance” for illegals who are already here.
Welcome the stranger
Legal immigration should not be easy. It should be welcoming and wide. We must counter deportation with maximum legal immigration.
And counter demonization by helping to convert the neighbor to full citizenship.
Most people who applauded Bishop Budde’s sermon, heard it as a human and transpartisan plea. But that’s not quite right. To acknowledge truth, perhaps complex, has a policy implication. To welcome the stranger has a policy implication.
Democrats and the press take note and copy.
Truth and humanity can, eventually, change everything.
Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers: burriscolumn@gmail.com. His previous article was “Trump meant it all.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.