He was an unlucky president and sometimes he made things worse. He could be rigid and self-righteous.

He was only 52 when he was elected president and green. Nothing prepares you for the presidency but the presidency. But some things help, like being vice president, or being around presidential politics for a while.

His mistakes

Carter had never worked in Washington; never served in Congress. He understood neither. Jerry Ford, whom he defeated, understood both.

Carter didn’t understand the presidency, either. At least not at first. He didn’t grasp, as Ronald Reagan did, that the president is head of state.

Advertise with us

So there were lots of mistakes — sometimes bending to the establishment when he should have held firm. He fired Andy Young, for example, and let the Shah of Iran into the U.S. for medical aid. Yes, the Shah was our ally. But Carter understood that admitting him would further inflame the Iranian revolution against us.

Yet when he should have listened and compromised, he often didn’t. Deregulating the airlines didn’t turn out well. Boycotting the Olympics got us nothing. He had to punt on tax reform and health insurance reform.

His greatest mistake was the handling of the hostages. He was right and gutsy not to bomb the daylights out of Iran. But wrong to make the crisis the focus of his presidency.

In the end, he negotiated the release of the hostages (after a disastrous rescue attempt). He should have pursued patient diplomacy on the back burner and gotten on with the nation’s business. It sounds cold, but a president can’t be held hostage.

And yet …

Advertise with us

His vision

He was an often visionary president — “green” before we had the term or knew the stakes. And his emphasis on human rights should have made us proud. Carter got a Russian dissident out on a prisoner exchange and it turned out that the man had for years kept a picture of Jimmy Carter in his shoe heel.

For four years, the United States stood for the Declaration, and for human rights, in the world again. He actually respected our neighbors and allies. So a second term might have been better, even very good.

But there was no way to overcome the combination of his inexperience and terrible luck. High inflation, high interest rates, long gas lines, and a hostage crisis. A maelstrom.

But then came the next nearly 50 years. And the greatest Ex-Presidency in the nation’s history.

Carter conceived of the former presidency as a public trust with which one could do much good. And good he did. Virtually single handedly, he has nearly eliminated Guinea Worm Disease, a horrific plague on the poor and the young. He promoted peace. And free and fair elections. And he brought to the public square qualities that we needed and need now more than ever: Service, intellectual honesty, and civility.

Advertise with us

It was important to him to make peace with his enemies — like Ted Kennedy, the Clintons, and Jerry Ford, with whom he became close friends. The Carter Center was important to him. It concretized what he hoped would be his legacy: Peace and human rights. Building houses for people who needed housing was important to him.

To be up and about and doing. Doing good. For good is actually not so hard to identify.

His post presidency is not less than his presidency. And not less than the eight years of Bill Clinton or Barack Obama. It is more.

Jimmy Carter was a rooted man — physically, intellectually, and morally. He went home to Plains and the little house he and Rosalynn built in 1961. His people had been bound to the land in that region of Georgia for generations. He went home to teach Sunday School at Maranatha Baptist Church.

Most politicians do not have roots. Modern presidents do not. They get rich on the presidency and they don’t go to church. Carter was not a humble man, and he knew that about himself. But he lived simply and prayed to find grace.

Advertise with us

His genius

Sometimes he was simplistic. But the genius of his simplicity was this: He thought, why have values if you do not live them?

He became the public servant, and human being, he always wanted to be.

His state funeral at the National Cathedral was a requiem for a good man, but also an ideal, a hope, a creed. Jimmy Carter’s passing reminds us of something we have lost, I hope not for good: Hope that we can do and be better. Practical idealism.

I felt the same way after watching the new Bob Dylan movie: Something is lost. I came home and put on a Joan Baez record. I wanted to hear that crystalline, dark and deep voice. The voice of one who cared and believed and stuck with it.

“Growth is the only evidence of life,” said John Henry Newman.

Advertise with us

Jimmy Carter grew. Persevered. Lived his values.

Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers: burriscolumn@gmail.com. His previous column was “Be like Belichick.”