You may find the massive number of political ads you will see in the next couple of weeks annoying, infuriating or even despicable, but you can also find them entertaining if you look at the way most attempt to draw connections between bits of information in ways that simply make no sense, and lead voters to conclusions no rational person could draw from the data.
Here are 10.
The old tricks are the best
Guilt by association (or “cooties”). Regularly used but hardly new. In his 1950 run for the Senate, Richard Nixon attempted to portray his opponent, Helen Gahagan Douglas, as a communist by stating that as a congresswoman, she had supported many of the same bills as a left-leaning seven-term New York congressman. Nixon held up her voting record as “evidence” that she was a communist sympathizer and tagged her "The Pink Lady.”
Extreme consequences (or the “slippery slope”). This tactic portrays an opponent’s ideas as inevitably leading to irreparable disaster. A dramatic example was the “Daisy” TV spot for Lyndon Johnson’s 1964 presidential campaign showing a child counting down to a thermonuclear explosion, followed by an appeal to vote for LBJ. While never mentioning opponent Barry Goldwater, the message was clear. Elect Goldwater and mushroom clouds will follow.
Similarly, in 1800, Federalist opponents of Thomas Jefferson portrayed him as an atheist and warned that if he were elected, “the Bible will be burned.”
Straw man. This approach involves mischaracterizing or wildly exaggerating your opponent’s ideas so yours seem solid by comparison. The “welfare queen,” employed by Ronald Reagan in his 1976 bid for the presidency, was a classic straw man tactic used to attack social programs favored by Democrats. Such abusers of the welfare system are very rare, but the widely peddled image of such a person (invariably African-American) has been used to make any government assistance program look like a scam.
Read More
False Equivalence. Ralph Nader provided an excellent example of this fallacy with his characterization of the two major American political parties as "Tweedledee and Tweedledum." Certainly, if you are promoting a third party, suggesting that there is no real choice between the others is an understandable though desperate strategy.
Problem Without Solution. One exceptionally successful political ad promoted the U.K.'s Conservative party in 1978 with a picture of a long line of people waiting at an unemployment office and the headline “Labour isn’t working,” referring to the British Labour party.
The ad never says what the Conservatives would do to alleviate unemployment — which actually increased under Conservative Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher. But this memorable play on words eclipsed anything the Labour party said on its own behalf.
It’s all sleight of hand
Tradition! This type of argument suggests that an approach must continue because it is already being used — regardless of outcome. Lincoln’s 1864 slogan pleaded, “Don’t switch horses in the middle of the stream." But as mutual fund ads always caution, past performance is no guarantee of future results, and if past performance isn't great, that's even less reason to be persuaded by this appeal.
Diversion (or the “red herring”). This approach sidetracks discussion of highly substantive and somewhat technical issues, like the economy, crime, infrastructure, or health care by focusing on subjects that are intended to inflame emotions (which is why I’m not going to cite any examples of them here).
Missing Link (or “false cause"). The suggestion that because one event precedes another, the first event must be the cause of the second. Take for example, a statement such as “we cut taxes and the economy grew 3%.” Many will unfortunately fail to notice the exclusion of the fact that many other forces affect the economy, usually much more so than tax policy.
Ad Hominem. These tactics commonly focus on an opponent’s personal life rather than qualifications, policy record, or issue positions. Personal character is of course a vital consideration. But too often, the distinction between, say, an illegal activity, such as bribery or business fraud, and a non-professional transgression such as marital infidelity, is severely blurred.
Overpromise. Not actually a fallacy, but rhetorical sleight-of-hand nonetheless. Campaigns inevitably overpromise by implying that candidates can accomplish things no single government official ever could. Without a cooperative Congress, for example, presidents are quite limited in what they can achieve, particularly in domestic affairs (that includes lowering gasoline prices).
Who’s the target
One other thing to be mindful of is that the targeting of political advertising is often as crucial as what the ads say. Noticing where ads run can tell you a lot about what a campaign wishes to accomplish. Do they focus on women? Men? Younger voters? Business executives? Hispanics? NASCAR fans? Follow the media plan to see who is pandering to whom.
It only takes very basic critical thinking skills to dismantle political marketing messages expertly and entertainingly. It’s also easier than ever these days to do your own fact-checking.
But here’s one more amusing thing. Political-science research has shown consistently that campaign communications have only a tiny effect on elections, if any. So for most voters, these ads — for which massive amounts of money have been raised and spent — will not matter much.
Arthur Beckman is an advertising copywriter and political scientist who has taught at The George Washington University and The City University of New York. His previous article was “What is the ‘swing voter,’ and how do they vote?”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.