If Kamala Harris ekes out a victory over Donald Trump in November, one former Democrat in particular will deserve a large portion of the credit — Sen. Joe Manchin, now Independent, of West Virginia.

This statement will come as a surprise to many, but Manchin is one of the main reasons that inflation was not even worse during the past three years.

The Democrats’ weak point

Inflation is the weak point for Harris and the Democrats. Voters may be angry about immigration, but that issue is not personal for most Americans. And, anyway, Democrats have an answer for the border. They can rightly point out that if Republican presidential candidate, former president Donald Trump, had not killed the bipartisan border bill, immigration problems would be greatly alleviated. You can blame Trump.

But there is no real Democratic response on inflation, which is a personal threat to any American who has money concerns — and that’s almost every American. You have to be pretty wealthy to think that inflation will add more value to your stock portfolio than higher prices will cost you.

Advertise with us

Even if true, it is just not good enough to say to the voters that inflation was not the fault of the Biden Administration — that it was the residual effect of the pandemic and affected the entire world.

Fortunately for Harris’s chances, inflation was never actually all that bad historically speaking — inflation peaked at around 8% and will probably average 5.7% under President Biden versus, for example, 4.6% under President Reagan — and is receding just in time for voting. So, Harris may scrape by in November with a win.

Inflation could have been worse, which would probably have doomed her chances. Manchin is the major reason that it was not.

At the beginning of the Biden Administration, the president proposed a $3.5 trillion bill, the Build Back Better Act, which would have provided funding for a variety of social welfare and environmental goals. The Democrats at the time had a narrow majority in both Houses of Congress and spending bills are not subject to the filibuster, and could have passed the measure with simple majorities.

But, in the Senate, the Democrats could not afford the loss of a single vote. That is what gave Manchin his leverage.

Advertise with us

Manchin opposed Build Back Better from the start, partly because he viewed it as hostile to fossil fuel interests in his home state of West Virginia and partly because of the effect the spending would have on the national debt. By December, 2021, Manchin had forced the level of spending in the bill down to $2.2 trillion. At that point, negotiations failed and he announced his opposition, effectively killing the bill.

By that point, however, inflation was already being recognized as a threat — in 2021, the inflation rate was already more than 4%. The Fed started raising interest rates to fight inflation in March, 2022. Portions of the bill were then reconfigured as the Inflation Reduction Act, which passed in August, 2022, with Manchin’s support.

That bill’s title was misleading — it was really a climate change bill — but it was crafted to pay for itself and not add much, if at all, to the national debt. Because of that, and its slow rollout, the Inflation Reduction Act probably did not contribute to inflation.

But what if the original $3.5 trillion bill had passed, or even the smaller $2.2 trillion version? The economy was already running hot in 2022. That greater level of deficit spending might have raised the inflation rate to 10% or 11%, or worse. It might then have taken longer to rein in inflation and the effort might have led to a recession.

Or maybe the Federal Reserve just would not have started to reduce interest rates. Certainly, one way or another, things would have gotten worse on the inflation front. In a close election, worse is all you need to lose.

Advertise with us

So, hats off to Manchin. He knew that supporting the Inflation Reduction Act would doom his chances for reelection. That likely loss is presumably at least part of the reason he decided not to run for reelection.

We can surmise that Manchin supported the Inflation Reduction Act anyway because he thought overall, it was good for the country.

Democratic benefactor

Joe Manchin has his flaws. He clearly enjoyed being the center of attention the past few years. He has tried to cripple the Biden Administration’s regulatory efforts to reduce American reliance on coal and natural gas. He has obstructed other Democratic Party initiatives. He changed his Party registration to Independent.

And now, because Harris supports getting rid of the filibuster, he is not even supporting the Democratic ticket.

Advertise with us

Manchin is no angel. But when it counted, he was right and the Democratic Party was wrong. He stood firm and was vilified for doing so. But, in a strange twist of fate, the Democratic Party is now the beneficiary of his actions.

If Harris wins in November, the arty should thank Joe Manchin. Somehow I don’t believe that will happen.

Bruce Ledewitz is a professor of law at the Thomas R. Kline School of Law of Duquesne University. His previous article was “Trump and Biden are both wrong about democracy.” The views expressed do not represent those of Duquesne University.