More than a decade before the United States Supreme Court used the Dobbs case out of Mississippi as the vehicle for overturning Roe, some of my fellow Mississippians proposed an amendment to our state constitution to establish the moment of conception as the beginning of “life.”
I was one of the lawyers who fought unsuccessfully to keep the amendment, called Initiative 26, off the ballot. I assumed our defeat in the courtroom meant the so-called “Personhood Amendment” would be swept to victory by our extremely conservative electorate.
I was as shocked as anyone when nearly 60% of Mississippians proved me wrong. What brought about such a surprising outcome in the most religious state in America? Conservative women.
Can they make a difference in Pennsylvania and other swing states and tip the scales in favor of Kamala Harris? Judging from Mississippi’s experience, yes.
Christian Mississippi
To understand why, one must first appreciate just how overwhelmingly “Christian” we are down here.
According to the Pew Research Center, 83% of people in Mississippi identify as Christian (non-Christian faiths make up less than 2% of the population), 82% of the adult population say they believe in God “with absolute certainty,” and 74% say religion is very important to them. More than 40% of Mississippians identify as Evangelical Protestant.
Read More
I am a Southern Baptist refugee with family and friends who are devout Evangelical Christians. Like them, my Sunday School teachers taught me that wives should obey their husbands and submit to their leadership. I heard pastors proclaim from the pulpit that the Bible requires a family structure in which husbands are the “spiritual leaders” and wives serve as their “helpmates.”
While my spiritual journey long ago led me to a different place, I do not doubt the sincerity of those who espouse such beliefs.
And that is what makes the defeat of a Personhood Amendment pushed and supported by Christian men from places like the American Family Association, Mississippi Baptist Convention, and Mississippi Republican Party all the more remarkable.
Why the amendment failed
The amendment failed because Mississippi women, including Republican Evangelicals, weren’t having it.
Despite what they had been taught in Sunday School, from the pulpit, or at the kitchen table, they banded together and pushed back against the men who sought to limit their healthcare options and threaten them with criminal prosecution for putting a “life” at risk through “unhealthy” behavior.
Women-led groups with names like “Grassroots Mamas,” “Mississippi Parents Against 26,” “Hell No! on 26,” and “Mississippians for Healthy Families” appealed to women voters across the state face-to-face and through videos of Mississippians sharing emotional personal stories of difficult decisions and devastating loss. Their grassroots campaign focused almost entirely on persuading women to rise up.
Undergirding the work of these local organizers was a clear and consistent message from Mississippi doctors and activists that the Personhood Amendment could very well limit or deny access to certain birth control and in vitro fertilization, and deny a doctor’s ability to provide care for pregnant women.
While passage of the amendment looked certain eight weeks out from the election, the combination of relentless appeals by women to women and warnings from physicians about the practical consequences of a system that would give zygotes the same status as preschoolers began to quietly chip away at support.
All that work was undertaken in the face of overwhelming odds. The day before the election, then Lt. Gov. Phil Bryant, co-chairman of Personhood Mississippi — who was elected governor with over 60% of the vote on the same day the Personhood Amendment was voted down — compared opposing Initiative 26 to supporting the genocide of Jews in Nazi Germany.
He said opponents to Personhood wanted the right to end life. If the measure failed, he said, “Satan wins.” On the Sunday before the vote, Mississippi preachers hailed the amendment as consistent with biblical teachings and a vital part of the anti-abortion movement.
The women’s defiance
But on Nov. 8, 2011, tens of thousands of women marched into voting booths at local fire stations, high school auditoriums, and community centers and defied politicians and preachers.
And in this world where so many families proudly embrace traditional Christian teachings about the authority of men, it is clear that Mississippi women used the privacy of the voting booth to defy their husbands as well.
It remains to be seen whether Dobbs and the subsequent state abortion bans and criminal enforcement laws will motivate conservative women of faith in swing states like Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, Michigan, and Arizona to similar defiance, but the lesson of Mississippi should make conservative politicians and controlling husbands across the country very nervous.
Cliff Johnson is a civil rights lawyer, director of the MacArthur Justice Center Mississippi’s office and clinical professor of law at the University of Mississippi School of Law.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.