The upshot of the Supreme Court’s recent ruling on presidential immunity in Trump v. United States is that the Constitution is now understood to provide the president with a high degree of protection from prosecution for bad acts committed while in office. It is not a stretch to say that the only thing standing in the way of such acts is the office holder’s character — “the way someone thinks, feels, and behaves,” as one dictionary defines it.
Thus the issue of presidential character is something the electorate needs to seriously consider before casting their votes in the November presidential election.
Leaders without character
The warnings about having a leader lacking adequate character is nothing new. According to Edmund Burke, the 18th century British statesman and acknowledged founder of the modern conservative movement, “of all things, we ought to be the most concerned, who and what sort of men they are that hold the trust of everything that is dear to us.”
Moreover, he goes on to say, “Nothing, indeed, but the possession of some power can with any certainty discover what at the bottom is the true character of any man.”
Some may discount the issue of character because of the belief that our Constitution’s separation of powers will always be there to protect us. But that has always been a very naïve understanding of how government works. As Burke warned over two centuries ago, valuing the structure of government over character will not protect us from disastrous results:
“The laws reach but a very little way,” he wrote. “Constitute Government how you please, infinitely the greater part of it must depend upon the exercise of the powers which are left at large to the prudence and uprightness of Ministers of State. Even all the use and potency of the laws depends upon them. Without them, your Commonwealth is no better than a scheme upon paper; and not a living, acting, effective constitution.”
Read More
This warning has become even more important given what the Supreme Court said in Trump v. United States: Speaking of the president’s powers as commander-in-chief (among other executive powers) under Article II of the Constitution, the majority declared that “Under our constitutional structure of separated powers, the nature of Presidential power entitles a former President to absolute immunity from criminal prosecution for actions within his conclusive and preclusive constitutional authority.”
That means the president “is entitled to at least presumptive immunity from prosecution for all his official acts.” The Court dramatically reduced the odds that the president will be found guilty of committing a crime after leaving office.
What good character requires
Without the chilling effect of possible prosecution, a President who lacks character will be more inclined to commit bad acts while in office.
Voters in a nation where presidents have that strong degree of immunity must elevate character as a necessary presidential attribute to the highest level of importance. We should heed the advice of Cicero, the famous Roman statesman and philosopher.
He said we should be looking for a particular kind of character in our leaders: “A serious and courageous citizen worthy of preeminence in the commonwealth” — like becoming president of the United States — “will surrender himself completely to the commonwealth, and will pursue neither influence nor power.”
That kind of ruler will both “protect the whole commonwealth” and “take into consideration the interests of everyone.” He will “so completely adhere to justice and honorableness that ... no matter how grievous the setback to himself, he would rather meet death than abandon those things I mentioned.”
While all candidates will fall short of Cicero’s ideal, it is critically important for voters to know how much they fall short. This requires voters to evaluate a candidate’s character without being influenced by that candidate’s policy positions.
It is easy for voters to dismiss a candidate simply because he or she holds policy views that they disagree with and vote for the candidate whose views align with theirs. However, it needs to be noted that a candidate’s policy positions will assuredly be moderated by a legislative process that either stifles such initiatives or promotes compromise.
Thus, a president with bad policies should not be expected to inflict the level of harm that a president lacking character can inflict on this country through unencumbered executive action.
How we must vote
The Supreme Court’s presidential immunity ruling requires us to have a high degree of trust in our president.
The only way for voters to establish if a candidate is worthy of that trust is through an understanding of the candidate’s character. It is critical for voters to thoughtfully establish such an understanding before voting.
Bernard S. Sharfman is a research fellow with the Law & Economics Center at George Mason University’s Antonin Scalia Law School. The opinions expressed here do not represent the official positions of the Law & Economics Center.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.