The up­shot of the Supreme Court’s re­cent rul­ing on pres­i­den­tial im­mu­nity in Trump v. United States is that the Con­sti­tu­tion is now un­der­stood to pro­vide the pres­i­dent with a high de­gree of pro­tec­tion from pros­e­cu­tion for bad acts com­mit­ted while in of­fice. It is not a stretch to say that the only thing stand­ing in the way of such acts is the of­fice holder’s char­ac­ter — “the way some­one thinks, feels, and be­haves,” as one dic­tio­nary de­fines it.

Thus the is­sue of pres­i­den­tial char­ac­ter is some­thing the elec­tor­ate needs to se­ri­ously con­sider be­fore cast­ing their votes in the No­vem­ber pres­i­den­tial elec­tion.

Lead­ers with­out char­ac­ter

The warn­ings about hav­ing a leader lack­ing ade­quate char­ac­ter is noth­ing new. Ac­cord­ing to Ed­mund Burke, the 18th cen­tury Brit­ish states­man and ac­knowl­edged founder of the mod­ern con­ser­va­tive move­ment, “of all things, we ought to be the most con­cerned, who and what sort of men they are that hold the trust of ev­ery­thing that is dear to us.”

More­over, he goes on to say, “Noth­ing, in­deed, but the pos­ses­sion of some power can with any cer­tainty dis­cover what at the bot­tom is the true char­ac­ter of any man.”

Advertise with us

Some may dis­count the is­sue of char­ac­ter be­cause of the be­lief that our Con­sti­tu­tion’s sep­a­ra­tion of pow­ers will al­ways be there to pro­tect us. But that has al­ways been a very naïve un­der­stand­ing of how gov­ern­ment works. As Burke warned over two cen­tu­ries ago, valu­ing the struc­ture of gov­ern­ment over char­ac­ter will not pro­tect us from di­sas­trous re­sults:

“The laws reach but a very lit­tle way,” he wrote. “Con­sti­tute Govern­ment how you please, in­finitely the greater part of it must de­pend upon the ex­er­cise of the pow­ers which are left at large to the pru­dence and up­right­ness of Min­is­ters of State. Even all the use and po­tency of the laws de­pends upon them. With­out them, your Com­mon­wealth is no bet­ter than a scheme upon pa­per; and not a liv­ing, act­ing, ef­fec­tive con­sti­tu­tion.”

This warn­ing has be­come even more im­por­tant given what the Supreme Court said in Trump v. United States: Speak­ing of the pres­i­dent’s pow­ers as com­mander-in-chief (among other executive powers) under Ar­ti­cle II of the Con­sti­tu­tion, the ma­jor­ity de­clared that “Under our con­sti­tu­tional struc­ture of sep­a­rated pow­ers, the na­ture of Pres­i­den­tial power en­ti­tles a for­mer Pres­i­dent to ab­so­lute im­mu­nity from crim­i­nal pros­e­cu­tion for ac­tions within his con­clu­sive and pre­clu­sive con­sti­tu­tional au­thor­ity.”

That means the pres­i­dent “is en­ti­tled to at least pre­sump­tive im­mu­nity from pros­e­cu­tion for all his of­fi­cial acts.” The Court dra­mat­i­cally re­duced the odds that the pres­i­dent will be found guilty of com­mit­ting a crime af­ter leav­ing of­fice.

What good char­ac­ter re­quires

With­out the chill­ing ef­fect of pos­si­ble pros­e­cu­tion, a Pres­i­dent who lacks char­ac­ter will be more in­clined to com­mit bad acts while in of­fice.

Advertise with us

Vot­ers in a na­tion where pres­i­dents have that strong de­gree of im­mu­nity must el­e­vate char­ac­ter as a nec­es­sary pres­i­den­tial at­trib­ute to the high­est level of im­por­tance. We should heed the ad­vice of Cic­ero, the fa­mous Roman states­man and phi­los­o­pher.

He said we should be look­ing for a par­tic­u­lar kind of char­ac­ter in our lead­ers: “A se­ri­ous and cou­ra­geous cit­i­zen wor­thy of pre­em­i­nence in the com­mon­wealth” — like be­com­ing pres­i­dent of the United States — “will sur­ren­der him­self com­pletely to the com­mon­wealth, and will pur­sue nei­ther in­flu­ence nor power.”

That kind of ruler will both “pro­tect the whole com­mon­wealth” and “take into con­sid­er­ation the in­ter­ests of ev­ery­one.” He will “so com­pletely ad­here to justice and hon­or­able­ness that ... no mat­ter how griev­ous the set­back to him­self, he would rather meet death than aban­don those things I men­tioned.”

While all can­di­dates will fall short of Cic­ero’s ideal, it is crit­i­cally im­por­tant for vot­ers to know how much they fall short. This re­quires vot­ers to eval­u­ate a can­di­date’s char­ac­ter with­out be­ing in­flu­enced by that can­di­date’s pol­icy po­si­tions.

It is easy for vot­ers to dis­miss a can­di­date sim­ply be­cause he or she holds pol­icy views that they dis­agree with and vote for the can­di­date whose views align with theirs. How­ever, it needs to be noted that a can­di­date’s pol­icy po­si­tions will as­suredly be mod­er­ated by a leg­is­la­tive pro­cess that ei­ther sti­fles such ini­tia­tives or pro­motes com­pro­mise.

Advertise with us

Thus, a pres­i­dent with bad pol­i­cies should not be ex­pected to in­flict the level of harm that a pres­i­dent lack­ing char­ac­ter can in­flict on this coun­try through un­en­cum­bered ex­ec­u­tive ac­tion.

How we must vote

The Supreme Court’s pres­i­den­tial im­mu­nity rul­ing re­quires us to have a high de­gree of trust in our pres­i­dent.

The only way for vot­ers to es­tab­lish if a can­di­date is wor­thy of that trust is through an un­der­stand­ing of the can­di­date’s char­ac­ter. It is crit­i­cal for vot­ers to thought­fully es­tab­lish such an un­der­stand­ing be­fore vot­ing.

Bernard S. Sharfman is a research fellow with the Law & Economics Center at George Mason University’s Antonin Scalia Law School. The opinions expressed here do not represent the official positions of the Law & Economics Center.