Former president Trump generated a lot of controversy recently with his comparison of the Presidential Medal of Freedom to the Congressional Medal of Honor. The first, he said at an event with a Republican megadonor to whom he’d awarded the medal is “the equivalent of the Congressional Medal of Honor, but civilian version.”

“It’s actually much better,” he continued, “because everyone gets the Congressional Medal of Honor, they’re soldiers. They’re either in very bad shape because they’ve been hit so many times by bullets, or they’re dead. She [the megadonor] gets it and she’s a healthy, beautiful woman.”

The two medals

The Medal of Honor was created a bit over 160 years ago and is the highest award for military valor in action. It has been given to 3519 individuals. It has been granted posthumously less than 19% of the time. 1525 of those awarded it fought in the Civil War, including the only woman to receive the medal (who was actually a civilian) and its youngest recipient, a 12-year-old drummer boy. Sixty recipients are currently alive.

The Medal of Freedom was established by President Kennedy in 1963 to recognize contributions in the arts, academia, and public service. It is the nation’s highest civilian honor and is given to someone who has made “an especially meritorious contribution to the security or national interests of the United States, world peace, or cultural or other significant public or private endeavors.” It has been granted 655 times to a wide range of people for a wide range of reasons.

Advertise with us

In addition to the difference between a member of the military getting a medal for bravery in combat and a civilian receiving one for a contribution in any of a wide variety of activities, there is a stark difference in how those so honored are chosen. The Medal of Honor is given only after a long and rigorous vetting process conducted by the military before the president is asked to approve it. Who gets the Medal of Freedom is entirely up to the discretion of the president alone.

As with the granting of the title of ambassador in exchange for campaign contributions, all presidents have used the Medal of Freedom some of the time for purely political purposes instead of merit. It often reflects mainly the interests and outlook of the president who grants it rather than deserved recognition.

The contribution some of the recipients have made is in politics rather than the arts, academia, public service or other fields. Trump has given the Medal of Freedom the fewest times of any president, and with the highest percentage of awards given for political reasons. Of the 24 times he bestowed it, there was no one from education, humanitarian work, activists, religion or science, which have been categories where previous presidents have found many people worthy.

Trump’s interests

The awards Trump did grant offers some insight into what matters most to him. The only person from the arts was Elvis, who did not accept it in person, though some no doubt hoped he would.

From business, the only one was Arthur Laffer, the man who invented the theory that cutting taxes makes government revenue increase because of the growth the cuts stimulate. No one who can spell economics actually believes that, but it is a handy argument for relieving the suffering of millionaires and billionaires.

Advertise with us

The only person from the media was Trump’s favorite broadcaster, Rush Limbaugh. Even though it is a civilian award, Trump also gave one to a retired general presumably because he is a frequent commentator on Fox News.

Among the four politicians who were granted it were disgraced former Attorney General Ed Meese and two congressmen, Jim Jordan and Devin Nunes. They are known mainly for being among Trump’s staunchest defenders in Congress and using their committees, Judiciary and Intelligence, for that end. Nunes left Congress at the end of 2021 to become CEO of the Trump Media and Technology Group.

Trump also distinguished himself from other presidents by giving the Medal to figures from sports far more than any other president. Over half of his went to athletes. Four were golfers, which is not surprising for a president who lives in a country club. A billionaire former race car driver, three football, two basketball and two baseball players, and one each from track and wrestling made up the rest in the sports category.

The wrestler was the first from that sport and had won a gold medal at the Olympics. Well known in Iowa, his award was announced at a campaign rally in Des Moines shortly before the 2020 election.

The gender and ethnicity of those to whom Trump gave the medal is also of interest. The only president who gave it to fewer women and minorities was Nixon. Of the four from ethnic minorities, all were male athletes. Two of the three women were golfers.

Advertise with us

Winning billionaires

The third woman provided the occasion for his remarks comparing the two medals. Miriam Adelson is the widow of a casino billionaire who was by far Trump’s largest donor, including $5 million chipped in for his inauguration festivities.

Trump has repeatedly indicated that his decision to move the U.S. embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem, something every president since Truman has contemplated and rejected as unwise, was a decision made to please Adelson.

Mrs. Adelson, an Israeli citizen, has reportedly pledged to spend at least $100 million to support Trump’s reelection. Apparently, her goal this time is to get him to endorse the Israeli annexation of the entire West Bank, thus eliminating any chance for a country named Palestine and any hope of peace in the Middle East.

$100 million may sound like a lot of money, but for the fifth richest woman in America it amounts to only a small fraction of one percent of her net worth.

Trump entered the White House with a very checkered record as a businessman. As his awarding of the Medal of Freedom demonstrates, however, he has figured out how to profit from public office.

Dennis Jett, former American ambassador to Mozambique and Peru, is professor of international affairs at the Pennsylvania State University.