After former President Donald Trump was shot, some in the media, and a few in politics, said, “this changes everything.” In fact, it changed nothing.
The Republican convention also changed nothing. The tone and volume of rhetoric was dialed down a bit, in some cases. But the nutty and irresponsible substance was the same.
Christian nationalism? It was on full display. The “2025” plan to re-constitute the government, and the country, is still the Trump plan. Do we want or need a so-called second American revolution? Does a majority of the country think the United States is a failed or failing country that needs to be remade?
And J.D. Vance as Mr. Trump’s running mate? He’s a strange combination of Robespierre and Eddie Haskel. One cannot tell if he is actually nuts or if it is all an act.
Nothing has changed
No. The race is not changed. We are not changed. At least not in the sense of “unity” about fundamentals, or coming together somehow as a people, after the politics is over.
The politics are never over. We are a 50/50 nation. Deeply divided and proud of it. All certain that the other side will ruin the country. We are in a state of “cold,” civil war and constant cultural combat. Few are listening and no one is budging. And there is no end in sight.
Both candidates are old. Too old. So, both their veeps matter. A lot.
Mr. Biden is inarticulate but able. Good at his job. He acted like a president after the Supreme Court decision on presidential immunity, when he said, In this land, we are all equal before the law; after his son was convicted, when he said we must respect the rule of law and I am also a dad who loves his son; after the NATO summit, when he said free people stand together for free peoples; after Donald Trump was shot, when like Ronald Reagan, he spoke for us all, for a shocked, concerned and compassionate America.
Donald Trump is really good at running for president. He was God-awful at being president. Mr. Trump is a good communicator, but he communicates either nonsense or rage. He is trapped in a persona he created for himself. He simply cannot now do the classy, generous, or selfless thing.
I suspect that, inside, he may be a better man than this persona. But he is captive now, and cannot be a unifying and conciliating voice.
The candidate of extremism
Donald Trump is the candidate of extremism. Jan. 6 proved that. He didn’t have to choose that path, but he did. J.D. Vance is extremism squared.
And extremism does not diffuse discontent, it exacerbates it. Rage only multiplies itself. Nihilism — and the Republican convention was an orgy of nihilism — is a cul-de-sac.
Eventually, we will have to come back to real politics, to cope and to modestly progress. We will have to reinvent the middle and cultivate a citizenry and a press that can order and distinguish.
That would change us. Our politics would, once again, be about something – problems and issues and how we address them: How to protect clean water and air, reduce gun violence, manage trade and immigration, not just deplore or ignore such problems, address unequal access to higher education, decent housing, good jobs and health care.
Tell me what the Republican convention was about. None of those things. Nothing. Nothing but rage and entitlement.
Tell me what Republicans are for. What is Mr. Trump for? Not even bringing back coal and steel, this time.
One issue matters more than any other in 2024: American democracy (liberty under law) versus autocracy – the strong man without legal restraints. This is the paramount issue.
The one thing Mr. Trump is for, is autocracy. He openly proposes to align our nation with Putin and Viktor Orban. Mr. Trump’s proposed alliance, with almost all the dictators of the world, and the selling out of Ukraine, would be a break with American political and presidential tradition.
A speech on “unity” cannot hide that. At least we ought not to let it hide such a shocking idea. Autocracy is not who we are. At least it is not who we have tried to be for 250 years.
Reinvent politics
Democrats and the media can no longer afford parlor games: The media playing “gotcha” with Old Uncle Joe and the Democratic Party dithering and self-dividing.
We need to wake up and to grow up. We have real problems. Deep problems. Problems far more profound than age.
We need to reinvent a pragmatic politics of moderation and measure and talk about issues, policy, legislation, and “grand bargains,” that strike proximate solutions. Otherwise we are stuck in an absurd cycle of rage, reaction, posture, and wrecking balls. No progress; no exit.
Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers: burriscolumn@gmail.com. His previous article was “There is no shame in getting old, Mr. Biden.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.