Many smart people told us that Mr. Trump’s New York “hush money” case was the weakest and least important of his four cases. But that case’s first days gave us David Pecker, the former publisher of the National Enquirer, describing his deal to try to “catch and kill” stories unfavorable to Trump and to concoct and spread lies about Trump’s competitors, first other Republicans and then Hillary Clinton.
The key purpose of “catch and kill” in the closing weeks before the 2016 election was to prevent stories — or facts or truths — unfavorable to Mr. Trump from coming to the attention of the voters. But do we not now see how a remarkable and seemingly quite intentional judicial “catch and kill” program is being perpetuated in the slow-down in the scheduling of the other three Trump trials?
A deprived country
This slow-down is almost certainly going to deprive the country of critical information — testimonies, evidence and facts of profound national importance — being aired regarding Mr. Trump’s and others’ actions before the upcoming elections.
The Fulton County presidential election interference case involves the allegation that Trump and eighteen others conspired illegally to overturn the 2020 election. The first delays in the case came when it was discovered that Fani Willis, the Fulton County District Attorney bringing the case, had a romantic relationship with the prosecutor she hired to run the case. While Willis’s judgment and actions were deeply unprofessional, they change none of the serious charges against the Fulton defendants.
Though the trial judge rightly held that Willis can continue to lead the prosecution, recently the Georgia Court of Appeals put a stay on the trial until an appellate panel rules on whether or not Willis should be disqualified because of some “conflict of interest.”
They have set a tentative date for oral arguments on Oct. 4. Clearly this case will not see trial before the November election.
The same glacial pace of judicial dithering is evident in Judge Aileen Cannon’s handling of the Mar-a-Lago classified documents case, the one with the boxes of papers — some top secret — piled in a bathroom.
The case was filed a year ago and Judge Cannon recently wasted more time in a wide-ranging hearing to take up Mr. Trump’s remarkable contention that the Department of Justice’s appointment of Jack Smith as a special counsel isn’t even valid. So this case is going nowhere before November.
The most significant case
On what many hold is the most significant case, Trump’s role in the Jan. 6, 2021 insurrection, Jack Smith, the Department of Justice’s special prosecutor, has argued the case in the Washington, D.C., court of Judge Tanya Chutkan. Chutkan ruled forcefully against Trump’s lawyers’ claim that the former president enjoys complete immunity from prosecution.
Trump’s lawyers appealed. Meanwhile the trial court was frozen. Jack Smith, who can actually read a calendar, appealed to the Supreme Court to take it up and bypass the appellate court. The Supreme Court refused so the appellate court deliberated,
The U.S, Circuit Court of Appeals three judge panel — in a decisive holding — ruled that a former president is not immune from prosecution. Trump’s lawyers appealed again. The Supreme Court could have chosen to simply not take up the case, which would have allowed Judge Chutkan to move the case with some possibility of the trial starting this summer.
But no. The Court decided to take up the case of Trump’s far-fetched claim of immunity and scheduled their hearing for the very last day of the Court’s term. At that hearing we heard a number of justices express worry about future implications of the finer points regarding possible rulings on the immunity of presidents out of office.
Some voices tried to refocus on the actual concrete case before the court and the impending presidential election. A majority of the Court has clearly felt no urgency in getting Trump v. U.S. to trial before the 2024 election.
It is most likely that we voters will be deprived of any clear, judicially-vetted, evidence-based airing of Mr. Trump’s and others’ actions regarding the 2020 election, the Jan. 6 insurrection or the classified documents case before we must vote this coming November.
A polarized citizenry
Accordingly, citizens will go to the voting booths with vastly polarized, media-shaped understandings of who Trump and Biden are, what Jan. 6 was and what sort of nation we should be going ahead.
It is one thing for Pecker and the National Enquirer to try to prevent voters from hearing stories harmful to Mr. Trump. It is quite another when we see now how judges’ decisions in these three Trump cases are functioning similarly to prevent any definitive, adjudicated findings regarding the nature of Mr. Trump’s and others’ actions from being aired before the upcoming 2024 election.
We the people are being profoundly ill-served by these judicial delays.
William French is an associate professor of theology at Loyola University Chicago, where he directs Loyola’s Peace, Justice & Conflict Studies program.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.