Many smart peo­ple told us that Mr. Trump’s New York “hush money” case was the weak­est and least im­por­tant of his four cases. But that case’s first days gave us David Pecker, the for­mer pub­lisher of the Na­tional En­quirer, de­scrib­ing his deal to try to “catch and kill” sto­ries un­fa­vor­able to Trump and to con­coct and spread lies about Trump’s com­pet­i­tors, first other Re­pub­li­cans and then Hil­lary Clin­ton.

The key pur­pose of “catch and kill” in the clos­ing weeks be­fore the 2016 elec­tion was to pre­vent sto­ries — or facts or truths — un­fa­vor­able to Mr. Trump from com­ing to the at­ten­tion of the vot­ers. But do we not now see how a re­mark­able and seem­ingly quite in­ten­tional ju­di­cial “catch and kill” pro­gram is be­ing per­pet­u­ated in the slow-down in the sched­ul­ing of the other three Trump tri­als?

A de­prived coun­try

This slow-down is al­most cer­tainly go­ing to de­prive the coun­try of crit­i­cal in­for­ma­tion — tes­ti­mo­nies, ev­i­dence and facts of pro­found na­tional im­por­tance — be­ing aired re­gard­ing Mr. Trump’s and oth­ers’ ac­tions be­fore the up­com­ing elec­tions.

The Ful­ton County pres­i­den­tial elec­tion in­ter­fer­ence case in­volves the al­le­ga­tion that Trump and eigh­teen oth­ers con­spired il­le­gally to over­turn the 2020 elec­tion. The first de­lays in the case came when it was dis­cov­ered that Fani Willis, the Ful­ton County Dis­trict At­tor­ney bring­ing the case, had a ro­man­tic re­la­tion­ship with the pros­e­cu­tor she hired to run the case. While Willis’s judg­ment and ac­tions were deeply un­pro­fes­sional, they change none of the se­ri­ous charges against the Ful­ton de­fen­dants.

Advertise with us

Though the trial judge rightly held that Willis can con­tinue to lead the pros­e­cu­tion, re­cently the Geor­gia Court of Ap­peals put a stay on the trial un­til an ap­pel­late panel rules on whether or not Willis should be dis­qual­i­fied be­cause of some “con­flict of in­ter­est.”

They have set a ten­ta­tive date for oral ar­gu­ments on Oc­t. 4. Clearly this case will not see trial be­fore the No­vem­ber elec­tion.

The same gla­cial pace of ju­di­cial dith­er­ing is ev­i­dent in Judge Ail­een Can­non’s han­dling of the Mar-a-Lago clas­si­fied doc­u­ments case, the one with the boxes of pa­pers — some top se­cret — piled in a bath­room.

The case was filed a year ago and Judge Can­non re­cently wasted more time in a wide-rang­ing hear­ing to take up Mr. Trump’s re­mark­able con­ten­tion that the Depart­ment of Justice’s ap­point­ment of Jack Smith as a spe­cial coun­sel isn’t even valid. So this case is go­ing no­where be­fore No­vem­ber.

The most sig­nifi­cant case

On what many hold is the most sig­nifi­cant case, Trump’s role in the Jan. 6, 2021 in­sur­rec­tion, Jack Smith, the Depart­ment of Justice’s spe­cial pros­e­cu­tor, has ar­gued the case in the Wash­ing­ton, D.C., court of Judge Tanya Chut­kan. Chut­kan ruled force­fully against Trump’s law­yers’ claim that the for­mer pres­i­dent en­joys com­plete im­mu­nity from pros­e­cu­tion.

Advertise with us

Trump’s law­yers ap­pealed. Mean­while the trial court was fro­zen. Jack Smith, who can ac­tu­ally read a cal­en­dar, ap­pealed to the Supreme Court to take it up and by­pass the ap­pel­late court. The Supreme Court re­fused so the ap­pel­late court de­lib­er­ated,

The U.S, Cir­cuit Court of Ap­peals three judge panel — in a de­ci­sive hold­ing — ruled that a for­mer pres­i­dent is not im­mune from pros­e­cu­tion. Trump’s law­yers ap­pealed again. The Supreme Court could have cho­sen to sim­ply not take up the case, which would have al­lowed Judge Chut­kan to move the case with some pos­si­bil­ity of the trial start­ing this sum­mer.

But no. The Court de­cided to take up the case of Trump’s far-fetched claim of im­mu­nity and sched­uled their hear­ing for the very last day of the Court’s term. At that hear­ing we heard a num­ber of justices ex­press worry about fu­ture im­pli­ca­tions of the finer points re­gard­ing pos­si­ble rul­ings on the im­mu­nity of pres­i­dents out of of­fice.

Some voices tried to re­fo­cus on the ac­tual con­crete case be­fore the court and the im­pend­ing pres­i­den­tial elec­tion. A ma­jor­ity of the Court has clearly felt no ur­gency in get­ting Trump v. U.S. to trial be­fore the 2024 elec­tion.

It is most likely that we vot­ers will be de­prived of any clear, ju­di­cially-vet­ted, ev­i­dence-based air­ing of Mr. Trump’s and oth­ers’ ac­tions re­gard­ing the 2020 elec­tion, the Jan. 6 in­sur­rec­tion or the clas­si­fied doc­u­ments case be­fore we must vote this com­ing No­vem­ber.

Advertise with us

A po­lar­ized cit­i­zenry

Ac­cord­ingly, cit­i­zens will go to the vot­ing booths with vastly po­lar­ized, me­dia-shaped un­der­stand­ings of who Trump and Biden are, what Jan­. 6 was and what sort of na­tion we should be go­ing ahead.

It is one thing for Pecker and the Na­tional En­quirer to try to pre­vent vot­ers from hear­ing sto­ries harm­ful to Mr. Trump. It is quite an­other when we see now how judges’ de­ci­sions in these three Trump cases are func­tion­ing sim­i­larly to pre­vent any de­fin­i­tive, ad­ju­di­cated find­ings re­gard­ing the na­ture of Mr. Trump’s and oth­ers’ ac­tions from be­ing aired be­fore the up­com­ing 2024 elec­tion.

We the peo­ple are be­ing pro­foundly ill-served by these ju­di­cial de­lays.

William French is an associate professor of theology at Loyola University Chicago, where he directs Loyola’s Peace, Justice & Conflict Studies program.