Gus Faucher, a PNC economist, recently wrote in the Post-Gazette that since mid-2020, when the recovery from the COVID recession began, overall retail prices in the U.S. have increased a total of 22%. And while the rate of inflation has recently slowed, Faucher added that many consumers are disappointed that prices haven’t fallen back to pre-pandemic levels. That isn’t going to happen, he said, mainly because the deflation required would likely wreck the economy.

Deflation may be impossible — but the question is why. This points to the entrenched interests of the same bankers and bureaucrats who caused the post-COVID inflationary bubble in the first place. What of the millions of Americans who saw their prospects for establishing home equity — the foundation of middle-class wealth in America — wrecked after being effectively priced out of the housing market? If deflation is impossible, whose interests are we protecting — and why?

Whose economy?

The immediate response of American financial authorities after the COVID lockdowns was to create massive amounts of money from nothing, and begin handing it out. In the second and third quarters of 2020 alone, the Federal Reserve’s balance sheet increased by 66%, or nearly $3 trillion. Over the same period, annualized federal spending jumped from $4.9 trillion to just under $8 trillion, an increase of 64%.

The lockdowns themselves may have been one of the most ill-advised policy responses in U.S. history, but the efforts on the part of the fiscal and monetary authorities weren’t much better. The predictable result, given an economy operating on only two or three cylinders, was the massive wave of inflation now (mostly) in our rear-view mirror.

Advertise with us

The rate of inflation has slowed, but prices in general remain severely elevated relative to four years ago. And nowhere has the pain been felt more acutely than in the housing market. The average U.S. home price has increased 34% since the first quarter of 2020, 55% faster than inflation, despite 40-year highs in mortgage rates. The double whammy of soaring home prices and 7% rates has locked many buyers — especially first timers — entirely out of the market. In April, according to the University of Michigan index of Homebuyer Confidence, Americans were the least enthusiastic they’ve been about buying a home in almost 50 years.

If we’re not operating the economy and the financial system for the young families who are the future of America, whom are we operating it for? Shouldn’t an economy serve consumers first, with the benefits of rising productivity flowing directly into lower prices? Or have we come so far down the road of asset inflation — in order to protect Boomer retirements — that there’s no going back? Is deflation impossible, as Faucher says?

Risks of deflation

If steady price deflation were to occur, as it would in a properly functioning consumer economy, the world would be quite different today — and far more difficult for bankers and bureaucrats. With steadily falling prices, bankers must do proper credit analysis, set aside ample reserves and run their institutions more conservatively.

Credit analysis is far more difficult in deflation, as borrowers must continuously sell more goods to service their loans rather than relying on boosted prices. Secured loans become problematic as pledged assets devalue. Banking generally becomes a lot more work — and more risky. The period of 1865 to 1910 in the United States was a perfect example of this sort of environment: Record bank failures and enormous financial volatility accompanied steady deflation — and one of the greatest periods of economic prosperity and innovation in our nation’s history.

In short, deflation creates risks for banks, so banks conspire with the government to create enough money so they don’t have to deal with it.

Advertise with us

Inflated away

The other major inflation beneficiary is government. Think of inflation as oxygen for politicians. Steady inflation of around 2% creates a reliable ratcheting effect on tax revenue, and a smooth runway for bureaucrats. And should our benevolent leaders decide the inflation/tax runway isn’t wide or smooth enough? They simply borrow the difference and inflate that away too!

Inflation created by central banks allows government to always have the money it wants — and to be first in line to get it. In a deflationary environment, government would have to explicitly tax, instead of relying on inflation to drive revenue and devalue debt. Politicians’ careers would be much, much shorter.

There’s a reason deflation rarely happens. It makes bankers’ and bureaucrats’ lives much harder, while inflation keeps them in power. The cost of everything from a hamburger to a house would be far lower without ever expanding government and the willful destruction of our money.

So Faucher is right: Deflation won’t happen again, as long as bankers and bureaucrats work in sync to execute a massive skim on the American people.

Charlie Smith is the retired Chief Investment Officer of Fort Pitt Capital Group.