No country has been more critical of the war in Gaza than Ireland. Irish political figures have condemned it in the Dail Eireann (Parliament) as well as in the International Court of Justice. Why? The obvious answer is that the Irish see in the plight of the Palestinians a reminder of their own history.

The Irish were oppressed by the British for eight hundred years before the creation of the Irish Free State and later the Irish Republic in 1919. For centuries the Irish had suffered occupation, torture, imprisonment and starvation. Except for brutally suppressed revolts, their only options were begrudged submission or emigration. Because of famine and the British refusal to supply food, the Irish population declined from 8,000,000 in 1850 to 4,000.000 by 1903, and even lower after that.

To the Irish the fate of the Palestinians is strikingly similar.

Faith, land and politics

Gaza has been called rightly the largest open-air prison on earth. Imports are restricted. Inhabitants are unable to leave by land, sea or air. Midnight house invasions by the police are routine. United Nations resolutions as well as those of the International Court of Justice are ignored. Food and medical supplies are withheld at Israeli checkpoints. Imprisonment without charge prevails.

Advertise with us

It’s small wonder that the Irish see and have seen their own history reflected in the ongoing suffering of the Palestinians in Gaza and have said so officially and often. When the Israelis initiated a total war of “self-defense” in October of 2023, many wondered how the killing of tens of thousands of civilians, many if not most women and children, qualified as “self-defense.”

When deprivation of food and medical supplies became official Israeli policy, the Irish spokesman at the International Court of Justice called it genocide. This accusation became even more appropriate when the Israel Defense Forces began the successive destruction in Gaza of all hospitals, schools, churches, mosques and libraries.

The fact remains that Netanyahu and his right-wing government are bent on acquiring land for expansion. This recalls why Albert Einstein declined the offer to be Israel’s first president: He believed that faith and geography were not compatible.

Pope Francis was one of the first to identify the onslaught on Palestinians in Gaza as genocide. It is ironic that Protestant leaders, and not the American Catholic hierarchy took a similar position, particularly in light of the fact that American funding and weapons are making this genocide possible.

Ignoring the peacemakers

Those who balk at using the word — genocide — have yet to find a synonym for killing a people simply for being who they are, where they are. President Joe Biden has shown that he is incapable or unwilling to demand an end to the onslaught by a client state on a civilian population.

Advertise with us

Compare that to President Dwight Eisenhower’s stance in 1956 when Britain, France and Israel were collaborating to invade Egypt. Realizing that the plan would be disastrous for the entire Middle East, Eisenhower ordered the plan to stop. And it stopped, because the leader of the world’s major power demanded it.

For Americans, the tragedy of the ongoing invasion and decimation and displacement of Palestinian civilians is that we have been made complicit in it. Billions of dollars as well as munitions have been given to Israel, enabling it to continue its aggression indefinitely.

Meanwhile, considered irrelevant are the anti-Netanyahu views of the most distinguished Jewish thinkers in the world: Noam Chomsky, Norman Finkelstein, Naomi Klein and Tanya Rinehart and Gideon Levy in Israel. Ignored as well is the Jewish Voice for Peace. An expansive nationalism has taken over, proving Einstein’s reservations about the mix of religion and geography correct.

A question of priorities

Israel’s war tactics have been condemned by the World Court, while the United Nations has demanded an end to the Rafah campaign. And again we are considered complicit, because we are complicit. This will not end as long as Israel’s interests take priority over our own.

If the goal of the invasion of Gaza by the Israelis is to facilitate what some have called the “voluntary immigration” of the entire Palestinian population elsewhere, one wonders what the position of the United States will be. Already, there have been instances where Israeli protesters have attacked the truck line and pillaged the packages of food and medical supplies being transported.

Advertise with us

Recently, I thought of this vandalism when I read a statistic published by the International Red Cross. It seems that there are three or more injured children referred daily for life-saving surgery to the last operational hospital in southern Gaza. All too frequently these children arrive when the medical supplies needed for such surgery do not exist. Imagine the consequences for a child who must have one or two limbs amputated in order to save what is left of his life.

Then imagine such major surgery without anesthetic. Finally, imagine such procedures happening two or three times daily on children. Without anesthetic.

Samuel Hazo, Pennsylvania’s first poet laureate, was a professor of English at Duquesne University and the founder of the first International Poetry Forum.