I’m an up­land bird hunter. I keep in prac­tice by shoot­ing pi­geons. My son tosses them into the air for me. I miss some of the ones that fly di­rectly over my head. But when I cen­ter them with my 12-gauge Ithaca, it feels great to blow them apart.

These are clay pi­geons, a.k.a. “skeet.” For tar­get prac­tice, clay pi­geons have lots of ad­van­tages over live ones. You don’t have to catch, raise, feed, or trans­port them. And you don’t have to en­gag­e in an­i­mal cru­elty.

En­gland banned live pi­geon shoots in 1921, Monaco in 1966, Italy in 1970, Por­tu­gal in 2021, Spain in 2023. But they’re on­go­ing in the U.S.

I live in Mas­sa­chu­setts, but I hunt in Penn­syl­va­nia. This state was one of the first states to pass a ro­bust anti-cru­elty stat­ute, but, as in many oth­ers, live pi­geon shoots are still le­gal. This will change if a bill (House Bill 1475) that cleared the state House April 29 is en­acted to law.

Advertise with us

When pos­si­ble, a group called Show­ing An­i­mals Respect and Kind­ness records the shoot­ing with drones le­gally flown un­der Fed­eral Avi­a­tion Ad­min­is­tra­tion cer­ti­fi­ca­tion. Their drones are rou­tinely blasted out of the sky by pi­geon shoot­ers who bring ri­fles spe­cif­i­cally for that pur­pose be­cause the drones fly above shot­gun range. A $15,000 drone was shot down at one Penn­syl­va­nia event.

The prob­lem

What’s the prob­lem? A big one is that lead is a neu­ro­toxin. Only two in­gested shot­gun pel­lets can fa­tally poi­son a hawk, ea­gle, or vul­ture. Lead pel­lets also poi­son foxes, coy­otes, fish­ers, bob­cats, cou­gars, bad­gers, rac­coons, and opos­sums.

Many wounded pi­geons fly too far for work­ers to col­lect. Any bird flap­ping on the ground is a din­ner in­vi­ta­tion for pred­a­tors. Rap­tors and vul­tures poi­soned by con­sum­ing lead pel­lets droop their heads, strug­gle to breathe, and con­vulse.

The Del­a­ware River Keeper Net­work un­suc­cess­fully sued the Phil­a­del­phia Gun Club for re­peated Clean Water Act vi­o­la­tions in which it pol­luted the river with lead shot, plas­tic shell wad­dings, and pi­geon car­casses. “I’ve had the pel­lets rain down on me and my vol­un­teers,” says Del­a­ware River Keeper Maya van Ros­sum.

Another is the cru­elty. Work­ers, of­ten chil­dren, grab wounded birds, make no ef­fort to dis­patch them, then throw them into gar­bage cans where they take hours or days to die.

Advertise with us

Some fair-chase hunt­ers le­gally shoot and eat pi­geons in the wild. I’m not one of them. I don’t ob­ject. I’m just spooked by the dis­eases and ec­to­par­a­sites pi­geons carry and spread to hu­mans and wild­life — Bird Flu, Psit­ta­co­sis, His­to­plas­mo­sis, Cryp­to­coc­co­sis, E. coli, Sal­mo­nel­lo­sis, bed­bugs, pi­geon ticks, and red mites, to men­tion a few.

If you can push past that is­sue, pi­geons make fine ta­ble fare. Eth­i­cal hunt­ers eat what they kill. But pi­geons killed at live pi­geon shoots rot or get eaten by scav­en­gers.

My fel­low hunt­ers sit mute while slobs trash our rep­u­ta­tion. It grieves me that the only ob­jec­tions to live pi­geon shoots is­sue from the an­i­mal rights/​well­ness com­mu­nity. Not a peep from the Na­tional Wild­life Fed­er­a­tion, the The­odore Roosevelt Con­ser­va­tion Part­ner­ship, Back­coun­try Hunters and An­glers, or any other out­fit pro­mot­ing and de­fend­ing fair-chase hunt­ing.

“There is noth­ing eth­i­cal or sport­ing about close-range shoot­ing of me­chan­i­cally launched, de­hy­drated and dis­ori­ented birds,” says Natalie Ah­wesh, Penn­syl­va­nia di­rec­tor of An­i­mal Well­ness Ac­tion. “The es­sence of what hunt­ers con­sider ‘eth­i­cal hunt­ing’ lies in pur­su­ing a fair chal­lenge in har­mony with na­ture, which is en­tirely ab­sent in this hei­nous prac­tice.”

Ted Wil­liams, a life­long hunter, is a for­mer in­for­ma­tion of­fi­cer for the Mas­sa­chu­setts Divi­sion of Fish­er­ies and Wild­life.