Last week, more than a year after an eastbound Norfolk Southern freight train jumped the tracks, smashing 50 cars that contained hazardous materials and exploding in a towering fireball, President Biden finally visited the tiny town of East Palestine, Ohio. The President was there because of a promise that he made to visit the site “at some point” and, more importantly, to point the finger of blame squarely at Norfolk Southern.

But, by waiting twelve long months to visit, he is sending another, more important, message: the federal government doesn’t own the disaster.

Who owns the job?

Federal officials believe, and often say, that “all disasters are local.” This is based on the concept of home rule, meaning that municipal and township governments — nearly 36,000 of them at last count — bear the primary responsibility for disasters. So, from the federal government’s perspective, local government “owns the job.”

Most of the time, this approach works. The problem is on those rare occasions when the job gets too big, too fast, as it did on the night of Friday, Feb. 3, when an urgent need arose to organize and activate a multitude of complex operations, including firefighting, hazardous materials containment, environmental sampling, public notification and evacuation. Since East Palestine owned the job, it was responsible to do all of these things.

Advertise with us

In that moment of truth, the East Palestinians faced the hardest job in the world. As Friday night turned into Saturday morning, it was not enough for them to do a lot of things very quickly, they were forced to try and do everything all at once. The weaknesses of the President’s approach are thus laid bare, as are the results: fear, confusion and chaos.

From Lahaina, Maui to Paradise, California to Boulder County, Colorado to East Palestine, Ohio, we see this time and time again as our expectations — about what government can do and when it can do it — are dashed. After every catastrophe presidents tell us that the local government owns the job and that the White House (i.e., FEMA) is leaning forward to support them with anything they might need.

The reality is that, beyond the big cities like New York, Los Angeles and Houston, few local governments can come close to doing what is needed.

Speaking truth to power

Even though your local government has a department called emergency management, it cannot do all of those things either. Believe me when I tell you that your emergency manager understands this better than anyone. And because they know that they don’t have the bandwidth they need, the prospect of a catastrophe is daunting. Most keep this to themselves and labor in obscurity, dreading the day when the black swan will come.

Just as it did on the afternoon of Aug. 8, 2023, when brush fires, stoked by bone dry, hurricane-force winds, roared into the historic town of Lahaina on the island of Maui.

Advertise with us

That local emergency manager, Maui Emergency Management Agency (MEMA) administrator Herman Andaya, has been a target of withering criticism. Andaya controlled a state-of-the-art siren warning system that remained silent as the fires burned. After the fires were out, he defended his decision in a press conference, and resigned the next day.

In the aftermath, the new emergency manager is not keeping his fears to himself. In a virtual interview last week the new MEMA administrator, Amos Lonokailua-Hewett, said that he doesn’t believe his agency should take the lead in future emergencies.

“My staffing situation is dire,” he said. “There are not enough people to accommodate all the positions and function effectively.” According to press reports, “it wasn’t entirely clear which agency would take the lead if MEMA doesn’t.”

A recent investigation found at least a dozen natural disasters in the United States during the last decade where local emergency managers failed to issue alerts in time to save lives or, in some cases, didn't issue an alert or evacuation order at all, with Maui being only the most recent example. Woe to any community who expects otherwise, because when the time comes, it’s expectations too will be dashed.

The feds should own it

As a working emergency manager, I am grateful to Lonokailua-Hewett for speaking the truth, a profound truth with massive implications in these dangerous times. Local governments, from Maui to East Palestine to thousands of communities across the nation, do not have an ability to own the disaster.

Advertise with us

This means that during the next catastrophe we will again fail to deliver the kind of organized, compassionate outcomes disaster victims deserve. Somebody should tell this to the president, and remind him that the disasters that nobody owns are the ones that will inevitably roll right back up to the White House.

Kelly McKinney, a former deputy commissioner at the New York City Office of Emergency Management and chief disaster officer at the American Red Cross in Greater New York, is now chief of emergency management at NYU Langone Health in New York City. His previous article was “Despite our vulnerability, America prefers complacency to vigilance.” His previous article on this subject was “How America can handle disasters like East Palestine’s.”