Because we are in a Presidential election year, our national obsession with aging has shifted into high gear. Both President Biden and former President Trump are now taking flak for their respective ages, which are not that far apart.
But exactly what is being blamed on the candidates’ age?
A recent article in the Atlantic reported that young voters are frustrated with Mr. Biden’s positions on Gaza and fossil fuels and attribute his priorities to cognitive inflexibility due to his age. People have seen both candidates memory lapses as evidence of their mental decline.
In both cases, the focus on “age” is misplaced.
Age does not equal disability
We really must stop conflating age and aging with disease and disability. Aging itself is not a disease. Even if half of people over 90 have dementia, the other half don’t.
At any age, a person’s observed difficulties might be related to a specific illness or injury or situation, rather than to “age.” A person with a certain genetic predisposition to Alzheimer’s disease may develop dementia as early as his 30s. Another person could have a stroke or head injury at any age, and in some cases those conditions could lead to dementia.
Read More
The process of aging is part of normal human growth and development. In the first year of life, babies are all so similar that we know to the month when we expect them to smile in recognition, roll over, crawl, and so on. But the more we grow, the more we diverge.
As a result, there is no such thing as an average 50 year old or 80 year old. The only meaningful comparison is between a given older person and himself at an earlier age. How much and in what way has the person changed? Some things do get better with age; some people are late bloomers who do their best work in their later years.
With normal aging, most people experience a gradual decline in physical strength and speed, but not everyone does so at the same pace. In most sports, elite athletes start to age out in their mid-30s, ironically around the time they would be eligible to run for the US presidency!
With aging, many people develop arthritis that can slow them down physically. But think about the 93 year-old rower who has been in the news recently and who only took up rowing at age 73. Think about some 80-year old pickleball players who put the rest of us to shame.
Slow, gradual and not dramatic
Normal aging-related cognitive decline is also a slow and gradual process that does not occur at the same pace in everyone, and is not dramatic. We all know of famous people firing on all cylinders well into their 90s.
To be sure, even a little cognitive slowing could be a problem for an air-traffic controller who has to make split-second decisions. But our CEOs and heads of state do not, and probably should not, make split-second and possibly impulsive decisions. They should study the facts, consult with advisors and make considered decisions, even if we don’t always agree with those decisions.
In a leadership role, we are looking for maturity, knowledge, and experience. Perhaps even wisdom, which the writer Atul Gawande defined as the ability to deal with uncertainty
To assume that anyone over a certain age is cognitively impaired (“senile”) is just as bigoted as assuming anyone of a certain race is lazy or anyone of a certain sex is weak.
As a society, we have realized why it is wrong to be racist or sexist. Why do we still think it’s OK to be ageist? Cartoonists, birthday card designers, comedians still have carte blanche for cheap shots about older people waving their canes and yelling “Get off my lawn!”
But most older people we personally know don’t fit that description. The comedian Steven Colbert who routinely jokes about Joe Biden’s age recently interviewed, with great awe and respect, film director Martin Scorsese, who is exactly the same age.
What do we fear?
Our personal concerns about age and aging are driving a burgeoning market. Everywhere we look, we are besieged with ads and testimonials about products to reverse aging — or at least the appearance of aging. These range from skin and hair products to so-called nutritional supplements to hormones and brain-stimulation programs. I read recently that Gen Z (those born between 1997 and 2012) believes it is “aging like milk.”
The markets don’t lie: according to Yahoo Finance, “the global anti-aging market grew from $50.1 billion in 2022 to $54.5 billion in 2023 at a compound annual growth rate of 8.8%.” Are manufacturers simply capitalizing on our collective fear of aging? Or are they normalizing — or even driving — these fears?
What exactly it is that we fear about our own aging? And is that why we project our fears on to others?
Mary Ganguli is professor of psychiatry, neurology, and epidemiology at the University of Pittsburgh. Her previous article was “What J.D. Vance forgets.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.