The third Republican presidential debate lost 20% of its viewership from the previous debate, from 9.5 million to 7.5 million. That number is still amazing, at least to me. The 2024 presidential election is still almost a year away.
A lot can happen in a year, even in a calcified political system. Think how much global politics has changed in recent weeks.
The first debate drew 12.8 million viewers. The fall-off in viewership is stunning, yes.
Looking for alternatives
But also the initial interest. It shows that millions of Americans are looking for constructive alternatives in 2024. And also that many of those who tuned into the GOP debates concluded that positive alternatives would not be found there.
Concurrently, we are looking at the possibility of four independent or third-party candidates — the most in the last 100 years: Robert F. Kennedy Jr., environmentalist turned populist; Cornel West, prophetic social critic; Jill Stein of the Green Party; and possibly Sen. Joe Manchin, in league with ex-Sen. Joe Lieberman and the group No Labels. And there may be more.
Read More
It reminds me of the old story about a judge giving a criminal defendant a choice between two attorneys, both present in the courtroom, and the defendant replying: “I’ll take the one who’s not here.”
We are a spoiled and unhappy country right now, unhappy with our choices and befuddled as to how to expand them. But we want to expand them.
Yet the extra-constitutional selection process we once had has given way to a new extra-legal arrangement that constantly narrows our choices. The party and boss system has been replaced by big donors and big media. They do the initial screening. The second screening is done by primary voters, who tend more toward the extremes than general election voters.
So, not only is the wider choice denied us, but the more centrist and moderate choices.
The initial GOP field consisted of thirteen candidates. Two who are still in the race were never admitted to the debates – not enough money or media chatter. Donald Trump has refused to debate. Mike Pence was dispatched, despite being qualified to be president. And five remained in the most recent debate.
Of those five, one more, Tim Scott, has now “suspended” his campaign. Two more, Chris Christie, and Vivek Ramaswamy, can almost certainly not be nominated. Mr. Christie, the former governor of New Jersey, is qualified, can think and articulate, and mostly makes sense. Hence his lack of political viability.
Left with Trump
This leaves us with Mr. Trump who has proven he cannot govern anything, including his own mind and heart; Ron DeSantis (aka DeSanctimonious or Trump Lite); and ex-South Carolina Gov. Nikki Haley, who has a lean and hungry look. (She has called Mr. Ramaswamy “scum” to his face and said her high heels could be weapons.)
Is narrowing the field to these three really what we seek? Is there any way to reform the selection process?
The bosses and back rooms are not coming back. But I wonder if real conventions, extending the super-delegate concept that Democrats have embraced, would shift the sifting power to congressmen, governors, party chairs and state legislators.
This would not save the GOP from Mr. Trump in 2024. But it might have spared us in 2016.
What we ought to want from a presidential nominee is three things: 1) government know-how and experience; 2) vision; and 3) ability to speak to and unify the nation in the great and hard moments.
Ronald Reagan had all three. He had governed the largest state. He had a vision — of smaller government and personal freedom. And he could speak to the entire nation as leader and friend. After the Challenger tragedy in 1986, in which the lives of seven astronauts were lost, Reagan gave a national address. He said he and his wife Nancy were “pained to the core.” And: “We know we share this pain with all of the people of the country.”
John F. Kennedy had all three: Experience, despite his youth. A vision that imagined the Peace Corps, NASA, and the Moon shot. And a unifying articulation of patriotism. Plus wit and verve.
Joe Biden has all three: Experience sufficient to finally pass an infrastructure rebuild and also to reassemble NATO. A vision of a tolerant and fraternal nation. An economic policy seeking work and opportunity for all. (He incorporated the high tariff, angry populism of Mr. Trump into that policy.)
The remaining Republicans
Of the remaining Republicans, Ms. Haley shows the most promise. She is pragmatic. She has dealt with common public tragedy. She took down the Confederate flag in her state. But none of the Republicans remaining (especially with Messrs. Pence and Scott out), offer much hope for the country or much faith in it.
The danger, and the fear, is that the country loses hope and faith in itself and we are left with only competing modes of demonization.
Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers: burriscolumn@gmail.com. His previous article was “Mike Pence dropped out because no one can be Ronald Reagan anymore.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.