The “Fetterman Rule” episode, as trivial as it may seem to some, was more than a fashion flap. As many readers will know, two weeks ago, Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer instructed the sergeant at arms to cease enforcement of the unofficial yet highly respected business-dress code, effectively allowing senators to dress down in the chamber. Way down.
The change, which made Pennsylvania Sen. John Fetterman’s affinity for shorts and hoodies acceptable on the chamber floor, didn’t sit well with Senate colleagues or many members of the public regardless of political affiliation. The code is taken so seriously that it’s common practice for senators at risk of violating protocols to register their “aye” or “nay” voice votes from an adjacent cloakroom, where casual dress is allowed.
That’s what Mr. Fetterman was routinely doing. He recently presided over the Senate sporting a short-sleeve shirt and baggy shorts, and that may have been the tipping point in a ballooning controversy.
A Senate resolution introduced Wednesday and passed by unanimous consent reversed the policy change and reinstated the longstanding dress code. That means, at minimum, a tie, jacket and long pants for men. And it means that senators must show up on the Senate floor at a sartorial standard at least as polished as the dress requirements for guests and other non-senators in the chamber.
Personal and public
Here’s why the episode was more than a fashion flap. Few things are as deeply personal and profoundly public as what we choose to wear and how we present ourselves, from the routine mundaneness of a Saturday afternoon grocery run to the formality of a cathedral wedding to the environs in which we earn our paychecks.
Read More
There is a rhetoric of dress, and cultural norms, context and audience are as real and as relevant as the fit of a trouser or the height of a hem. Each time we get dressed and groom ourselves, we present the result of a series of choices that began, in many ways, at a subconscious level.
And those choices have consequences. Our attire, like facial expressions and body language, sends unspoken cues that others pick up and filter through their culture-informed expectations, usually subconsciously. And their perceptions, whether right or wrong, influence how they interpret and respond to what we say and do.
Imagine three final candidates for an associate attorney position at a law firm. When they arrive for their job interviews, one shows up in overalls, another in a sequin top and the third in a business suit. All other things equal, there’s likely to be little debate about which is offered the position.
But it’s about more than what they wore. It’s what their wardrobe choices reflected and projected about them and whether they can understand and successfully navigate a given cultural context to achieve the desired results.
Dress always speaks
How we dress is always speaking, and it speaks volumes. Although we can’t control how others interpret the visual cues we send, we can influence those perceptions by using our sartorial messaging to convey respect and good judgment — qualities that can promote effective interactions and, on a more selfish level, help us achieve an objective.
At a time when public confidence in Congress and virtually every other U.S. institution may be at an all-time low, Mr. Schumer’s decision, though probably well-intended, was an unnecessary action that could have further eroded civility in the Senate chamber and public respect outside it. Although senators would still have been free to wear business attire if they wished, they apparently sensed that the message the policy shift was sending would hurt more than help.
This is not to say that how we dress can make us someone we’re not. It can’t. But it can and does reveal something about who we are, what we value and what we think of ourselves and others. How other people perceive us in a transactional world is a reality that we’re better off seeking to shape rather than ignore.
Serious dress for serious business
Some have suggested that the Senate has more important and urgent topics to address than a change in wardrobe protocols. It does, no doubt.
But that doesn’t mean the matter was trivial or unworthy of attention and action. If schools, employers of all types and professional sports leagues think personal appearance is important enough to warrant a dress code, then why not one of the nation’s highest levels of public service?
The public expects those who represent them to think, speak, and act seriously, and to dress accordingly as they conduct serious business. So it was necessary and appropriate for the Senate to remove a distraction that now finds itself, like countless fashion trends, in the dustbin of history.
LaMont Jones, former fashion editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, is senior editor for education at U.S. News & World Report.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.